teedubbya
Thursday, February 11, 2010 10:51:00 AM
I heard they were just waiting for their mom to come out of the cave
DrafterX
Thursday, February 11, 2010 10:54:00 AM
^ is she looking for CROS..??
victor808
Thursday, February 11, 2010 10:59:00 AM
.... so THAT'S where CROS is???

poor CROS...

teedubbya
Thursday, February 11, 2010 11:01:00 AM
he is the right color
Brewha
  • Brewha
  • Herf-A-Holic Topic Starter
Thursday, February 11, 2010 11:15:00 AM
#89 – jpotts, it is clear to me that you do not have understanding or this particular science. You should consider watching PBS as they have informative and dispassionate programming on this subject.

You autocratic attitude that people are idiots for not rejecting the theory (the one accepted and taught at accredited universities) put you in a poor light. That is as someone who is less than schooled. The book “On the Origin of Species” sites numerous examples of natural selection. You could always read it, you know.

I feel that if we all had your worms-eye view of the world we would be reduced to name calling and a means of furthering investigation.

teedubbya
Thursday, February 11, 2010 11:18:00 AM
I guess you told him Mr. Poopie Pants
edsbar60
Thursday, February 11, 2010 11:21:00 AM
Now you did it!

Here comes the 800 page dissertation from potts...

teedubbya
Thursday, February 11, 2010 11:22:00 AM
in a way potts is right. his very existence shows there is no link missing.
SHOE
Thursday, February 11, 2010 11:29:00 AM
128 - LMAO

Wait, Brewha, you were insinuating that people were stupid in you're very first post. That's kind of like name calling. Just sayin'....

FuzzNJ
Thursday, February 11, 2010 11:29:00 AM
dissertation? Hardly. Psychotic rambling, possibly.
SHOE
Thursday, February 11, 2010 11:38:00 AM
If God doesn't exist then why don't you say "Neanderthal-dammit" when you get mad?
cbc812
Thursday, February 11, 2010 12:34:00 PM
The Flying Spaghetti Monster is laughing at all of you.
rfenst
Thursday, February 11, 2010 1:15:00 PM
No offense to the writer is intended or desired!

It was written earlier on this thread that:

"Newton’s theory presents the strength of gravity ... not the source

dimensions may affect gravity

do we know all we could know of dimensions...no

therefore, the theory of gravitation is a theory . ...not fact"

----------------------------------------------------

I have done my best to break the above statement down into an accurate syllogism or pair of linked syllogisms to explore the logic of the statement from a philosophical and mathematical framework. So, I have reworded things just a bit to try to make it all flow and have come up with the following syllogistic premises and conclusion(s):

1. Newton's Theory explains the strength of gravity.

2. Newton's Theory does not explain the source of gravity.

3. Gravity may be affected by dimension.

4. Our knowledge of dimensions is incomplete.

5. Incomplete knowledge is a theory.

6. A theory cannot be a fact.

7. Therefore, gravity is not a fact.

Forgetting that the proper nomenclature is Newton’s Law(s), it would seem, according to the rules of logic that: A) If and only if every premise is true and the conclusion flows from the premises, then the conclusion must be TRUE; 😎 If any premise is false even though the conclusion(s) seems to flows from the premises, then the conclusion must be FALLSE/fallacious; and C) If the truth or falsity of any premise cannot be determined, even thought the conclusion flows from the premises, the truth or falsity/fallacious of the conclusion simply cannot be determined.

First of all, it just doesn’t seem to flow at all. Second, #1’s truth depends upon the definition of the word “strength”. Third, neither #3 or #4 cannot be determined to be either true or false right now, if ever. Fourth, I do not believe that #5 is necessarily true- because it, again, depends on how the words “incomplete knowledge” and “fact” are defined. As to #6, it too is definition dependant, but is likely false. As a result, my conclusion is that the conclusion (#7) has either not been proved or is false/fallacious.

Please advise if you think I missing some premise(s) that is/are either implied and so universally accepted that leaving it out makes my syllogism(s) incomplete.

(25+ years ago I took two classes in logic (math) and two or three classes in philosophy (liberal arts). Now, if I could just remember what learned and understood back then. Maybe I will just have to refresh myself on this kind of stuff from a purely an analytical perspective…)

rfenst
Thursday, February 11, 2010 1:40:00 PM
My friend jpotts,

Your following remark is respectfully a classic for you:

"Anyone who denies this is a total idiot, and refuses to face reality."

I am going to use it from now on and cite you as the "author"!

rfenst
Thursday, February 11, 2010 1:44:00 PM
90. Author: SHOE

No offense, but virtually everyone here believes in the same, single G-d, who is the basis of all Judeo-Christian religions.

rfenst
Thursday, February 11, 2010 1:50:00 PM
114. Author: victor846

How sure are you that "she" was even female?

rfenst
Thursday, February 11, 2010 1:58:00 PM
This thread reminds me of the discussions Neopuritan and I have under the influence of 5-6 cigars per day during our two day long herfs!

(Except we are more polite to each other..)

victor808
Thursday, February 11, 2010 1:59:00 PM
... close inspection...
JTokash
Thursday, February 11, 2010 2:06:00 PM
Gravitation, in the description of Einstein's general theory of relativity, is caused by the bending or warping of space-time. This warping then results in inertial objects (those with mass) to "feel" its effect as a force. Newton's Laws are simply approximations of Einstein's formulation.

The interesting thing is that warping of space-time appeals as a better explanation of what's going on because not only does a warped space-time effect objects with mass (i.e. cause "gravity"), but it also effects mass-less objects such as photons of light (see for example the gravitational lensing effect wherein light from distant stars is bent as it passes black holes or other galaxies). On the contrary, Newton's formulation doesn't even remotely consider the bending of light due to extremely massive objects.

Robert, regarding your points #3 and #4 - gravity is in fact effected by dimension. At the extremely small length scales, such as those found in molecules and atoms, Newton's and Einstein's descriptions of gravity both fail. To address this, we need to look into quantum field theory, but that introduces "virtual gravitons" and other bizarre phenomena that eventually leads to requiring an application of string theory or M-theory, and that then requires 10-26 dimensions. So it gets really nasty at tiny length scales because humans often have a hard enough time thinking and working in 3 dimensions let alone 4 or more.

-JT

Brewha
  • Brewha
  • Herf-A-Holic Topic Starter
Thursday, February 11, 2010 2:12:00 PM
#133 – Dude, I admire your strength of intellect in the dissection of the issue. However, brevity is where clarity begins. You may have won a triple nerd score for your assessment.

And for what it is worth, your statement “6. A theory cannot be a fact.” Is, well . . . not entirely accurate.

Point of reasoning: all logic followed too far will wrap back on itself and lose relevance and meaning. Or, if you prefer, base conclusion only on observation, not other conclusions.