I never leave the house without my silver Xikar. But, if a v-cutter is available, I'll gladly use that to pierce an 'X' into the cap over any other method. I love that cut. The pull is great, and the flavor seems to be maximized since much of the cap is still in place.
Punch cutters have become a last resort for me. I do favor the feel of a punch-cut cigar, but I smoke fuller-bodied cigars (much too quickly), which can make the flavor somewhat harsh towards the end.
Scissors can be hit or miss. I've found most models tend to crush your cigar, rather than cut them. Although, the cigar scissors in the Swiss Army Knives always did a good job.