beefy_64
Wednesday, February 15, 2006 8:30:00 AM
I put a 4 oz jar of beads in my humi a week ago. Let it sit (cigars still in) and waited for it to stabalize. My analog hygrometer is reading 66% but my digital is reading 55%. I put them both in a warm damp towel and the digi read 99% and the analog read 97%. My house is dry but which hygrometer do I believe. I have some very nice cigars that I don't want ruined.

Plese HELP!

ddandb
Wednesday, February 15, 2006 8:37:00 AM
Do a salt test....
beefy_64
Wednesday, February 15, 2006 8:39:00 AM
? ok I'll show my ignorance what's that
ddandb
Wednesday, February 15, 2006 8:44:00 AM
Cut and pasted from another thread..........

Luckily, as nature would have it, when salt and water (NaCl and H2O for you studious types), are in a saturated solution at equilibrium, the resultant humidity is 75%. This gives a fantastic reference point to calibrate our hygrometer. There is an easy way to determine if your hygrometer is accurate. Here's the procedure you should use: you need a ziploc bag, a screw-on beer bottle cap (or other small container) a small amount of salt (regular 'ole table salt), and water.

1.Place the salt in the bottle cap (or other small container).

2.Dampen the salt with water. Do not put so much in that the salt gets "sloppy". You want a damp pile of salt in the bottle cap.

3.Place both the hygrometer and the bottle cap full of damp salt in the ziploc bag and seal it well. (It is important not to let air on or out while the test is going on.)

4.Keep it like this for over 8 hours.

After 8 hours in the damp salt environment, the actual humidity inside the bag will be 75%. Compare it to your hygrometer, your hygrometer should also read 75%. If not, you will then know exactly how far off your hygrometer is. If it's off, note the amount and direction that it actually reads and be sure to add or subtract that amount when reading the hygrometer. If the hygrometer has a control to adjust it (either the needle or the display), you can set the hygrometer to 75% immediately after the test.

beefy_64
Wednesday, February 15, 2006 8:47:00 AM
Thanks I'm trying it right now
beefy_64
Thursday, February 16, 2006 9:15:00 AM
thanks for the help. My digi is low by 2% and the analog was high by 7%. My humi is still only about 60% even with the beads and the humidifier in it. I just added a container of distilled water. I guess my house is Really dry.
alr829
Thursday, February 16, 2006 1:30:00 PM
i have the same problem---beads,foam,all the same still reading in the high 50,s,low 60,s---same in all humidors and coolodor??? a damp sponge helps very little--hope mother nature will balance,and spring comes soon
BAC_zero
Thursday, February 16, 2006 1:51:00 PM
Are you in a cold climate? Most hygrometers measure "relative" humidity... which is effected by temperature. The warmer the air, the more humidity it can hold. I've seen weird readings using beads (which are supposed to be very consistent) when the inside temperature drops into the 60 degree range.
bousdeuce
Thursday, February 16, 2006 2:42:00 PM
I got my beads about 3 weeks ago (65% beads), and cannot get the humidity above 61%. I have a 150 count humidor with beads on the bottom, and a tray of em on the top shelf. I wonder if it is the winter air here, I keep spraying the beads with distilled water about every couple days.
HKGuns
Thursday, February 16, 2006 7:32:00 PM
Relative humidity is NOT affected by temperature. Hence the term "RELATIVE". I wish people would quit promoting this myth.
Qrash
Friday, February 17, 2006 3:52:00 AM
Definition from Wikipedia: Relative humidity is the ratio of the current vapor pressure of water in any gas (especially air) to the equilibrium vapor pressure, at which the gas is called saturated at the current temperature, expressed as a percentage. Equivalently, it is the ratio of the current mass of water per volume of gas and the mass per volume of a saturated gas.

While HKGuns is "technically" correct, i.e., RH is not "affected" by temperature, the technicality is meaningful for ONLY ONE SINGLE "current" temperature, again, the "RELATIVE" inference. However, I think most people are concerned (and frequently confused) about the temperature-humidity interrelationship. Change the temperature and do not change the amount of water vapor in the air and the RH level will be different ... all too often with serious affects on cigar storage conditions.

For those interested in a little thermodynamics, here is a link to a good MS Word formated psychrometric chart:

http://www.linric.com/freechrt.doc 

The important factor is that BOTH temperature and relative humidity are critical and equally important variables when discussing cigar storage conditions.

Just a quick summary of a few data points from the psychrometric chart …

NOTE ALL DATA at 70% RH ... from the 70% RH isohume curve:

At 60F air contains 55 grains of water per pound of dry air.

At 70F air contains 80 grains of water per pound of dry air.

…. Note: A whopping 45% more water is in 70F versus 60F air at 70%RH

At 80F air contains 110 grains of water per pound of dry air.

… Note: A whopping 38% more water is in 80F versus 70F air at 70%RH

… Note: A whopping 100% more water is in 80F versus 60F air at 70%RH

IMHO ... far too many cigar enthusiasts neglect the importance of the temperature parameter and obsess about RH alone. Most enthusiasts are familiar with the "70/70" mantra ... that good (or near ideal) cigar storage conditions are at 70F and 70%RH. If RH was the only important parameter, we would have only a "70" mantra. Temperature is a very critical consideration.

Okay … just trying to reinforce: There seems to be persistent discussion and dialog (obsession?) about humidity (and Relative Humidity) without consideration of the EQUALLY important parameter, Temperature. Probably the most important consideration: Work to find a storage condition that provides cigars YOU consistently like to smoke … and try to keep BOTH Temperature and RH as consistent as possible … Qrash

zoinks
Friday, February 17, 2006 7:10:00 AM
I found this on another site that I can't list because they sell cigars, but it's good info of the way relative humidity changes with temperature and how you can attempt to maintain the 70/70 environment.

We are aiming to maintain the same amount of water (mgm/liter) around our cigars as seen at 70% RH at 70 degrees F (which is 13.15 mmHg water vapor pressure).

So, to be able to know what is happening with our cigars at temperatures other than 70 degrees F, we must use a table of adjusted relative humidity values to make sure that our humidors keep our cigars in the peak of condition.

Temperature, water vapor pressure and relative humidity required to equal 70% RH at 70 degrees (13.15mmHg).

The columns are

Temp, Water Vapor Pressure and Relative Humidity

66 16.37 80.33%

67 16.95 77.58%

68 17.55 74.93%

69 18.17 72.37%

70 18.79 70.00%

71 19.45 67.61%

72 20.11 65.39%

73 20.81 63.19%

74 21.51 61.13%

75 22.25 59.10%

76 23.00 57.17%

It is not possible to attain an absolute humidity level that will keep cigars from drying out at temperatures below 60 degrees F. This observation will put to rest the fallacy that the refrigerator is a good place to store cigars. Not only do we have to worry about our premium cigars beginning to acquire the flavors from left over foods but the cigars will dry out and become essentially unsmokable. The freezer is an even worse place to store cigars. The humidity becomes virtually zero, and the loss of moisture from cigars will accelerate to produce a bone-dry smoke.

alr829
Friday, February 17, 2006 8:10:00 AM
WOW---i thought i simple answer was in store,boy was i wrong---problem is i live in the cold of the lake Erie area our gas bill has went out of orbit---i am retired and have lowered my heat in my home to 60--so it looks like my cigars are at risk---can i bring the cigars to the west coast for 6 weeks,and use the spare room??
BAC_zero
Friday, February 17, 2006 8:11:00 AM
No, HKGuns is NOT technically right.

"Change the temperature and do not change the amount of water vapor in the air and the RH level will be different ... "

That's my point! To get RH, you have to measure humidity AND temperature. Trust me, I used to build RH sensors for a living. You are measuring the humidity "RELATIVE" to the temperature. Warmer air can hold more water vapor (humidity) than colder air. 65% RH at 40 degrees is much drier than 65% at 70 degrees.

Qrash
Friday, February 17, 2006 10:17:00 AM
BAC_zero: I think you missed my point. We both understand the critical interrelationship between temperature and humidity. However, I think HKGuns meant (and if he did not then he is indeed wholly mistaken), that RH is “temperature-independent” and therefore “Relative” (as you emphasized) ONLY from the standpoint of the infinitesimal temperature point where the specific RH is measured (… actually even this is subject to only isobaric conditions). At isobaric conditions there is, for example, one and only one water vapor content in air (at equilibrium) at a particular temperature and RH of, say 70%. However, clearly, just by looking at the isohume (constant RH) curves on the psychrometric chart, you see the obvious … per my quote that you highlight. If HKGuns is focusing only on that “relativistic” limitation, he is technically correct. But the slightest change of T results in an RH change … unless there is a corresponding change in water vapor content in accordance with the respective isohume.

Pay particular note to the brief summary data table provided for equilibrium water vapor content in air at constant 70%RH and a fairly narrow range (60F to 80F) that our cigars may typically be exposed to … highlighting the importance of the temperature-(relative-)humidity relationship. While there are comparatively minor “chemistry/kinetics” influences associated with storing and aging our cigars within that narrow T-range, psychrometric thermodynamics is THE “major player,” and I am constantly amazed by myopic focus or obsession with RH without simultaneously recognizing the equally important T-parameter.

BAC_zero
Friday, February 17, 2006 11:30:00 AM
You're right, Qrash... I see what you're saying.

I just re-read my post and noticed it sounds a little "tense". It wasn't meant to, I was in a hurry when I wrote it, so I didn't think about the wording much.

Appologies to you, and to HKGuns, if my post came across as if I was attacking... I wasn't. 🙂

jespear
Friday, February 17, 2006 1:00:00 PM
I was lost at the "salt test". *lol*

jes

sw48362
Friday, February 17, 2006 1:16:00 PM

put a heater in that humidor. In the northern states, it's tough keeping those cigars at an optimum RH.

But, No dry boxing needed.

BAC_zero
Friday, February 17, 2006 1:39:00 PM
That's another good question. Anyone know a good, reliable (and hopefully cheap) way to heat a humidor? I thought about rigging up a thermostat and a heating element (possibly a light bulb), but I wonder if it will be sensitive enough. Temperature changes are my biggest enemy right now. It’s just so dag-gum cold here!
beefy_64
Friday, February 17, 2006 1:57:00 PM
the temp in my humi is 71 degrees. about 61% humidity.