Each had their strengths and weaknesses but think I’mma more in the Sharona camp too. Nothing “wrong” with Natalie, she was more stable but Bitty Schram gave her character spunk and an edge. Plus, of course, her sometimes skanky wardrobe greatly contrasted with Monk’s near monotone.
Initially when Sharona “left” the show, I really missed her. I don’t know how much money Bitty wanted but wonder if, ultimately, she regretted her decision. Of course she wouldn’t know that the show would last six more seasons but she sure missed out on a bunch of residuals. There were times when Natalie was too goody-goody but as the series progressed, got used to it.
Another thing that my wife and I enjoyed was closure to the series. I’ll refrain from posting any spoilers but it was nice to not have any loose ends.
Palama wrote: