The Big Ugly
Sunday, June 25, 2006 8:40:00 AM
Tonite, a buddy of mine tried to smoke a Monte #2 (it was sitting in his humi at about 68% for 6 months) and he had to trash it after the first 1 1/2 inches.

He said the draw was "too tight" (hurt his jaws), he let it rest for a few minutes, tried to relight it, and then gave it up for a Padron 6000 (maddie).

Has anyone else ever have burn/draw issues with their Cubans/Monte's? How can he "fix" this?

I've only smoked 4-5 Cubans, so I am NOT the resident expert.

Open to all comments and any suggestions.

Thanks for your help,

TBU

andytv
Sunday, June 25, 2006 8:47:00 AM
It is possible for any cigar to have a tight draw, even if it had been kept at ideal conditions.

We are dealing with rolled up bunches of leaves, and although the foks who roll them are quite talented and QC is remarkably good for the better brands, it can happen.

I used a "Draw Poker" (thanks Bloody) on a RYJ Cuban that had a tight draw, and it worked remarkably well.

That being said........I believe keeping your sticks at 60-65% is better then 65-70%.

usahog
Sunday, June 25, 2006 9:13:00 AM
for Cubans yes like andy said above.. lower humidity levels to 65-67% are better on them.. also seems better for any maduro's as well..

and a draw poker works great...

Hog

sli38
Sunday, June 25, 2006 9:51:00 AM
Monte #2's are over produced IMHO and construction problems are very common.
130Medic
Sunday, June 25, 2006 2:53:00 PM
I just recently had the same problem with a Montecristo #1. Reluctantly tossed it for a second one, which had no problem at all. I guess every once in a while it happens.

First cuban that I ever tossed.

130Medic
Sunday, June 25, 2006 2:54:00 PM
I think I need to get a draw poker.......
donutboy2000
Sunday, June 25, 2006 3:04:00 PM
Construction qulaity has improved greatly in the last few yaers, but you can sometimes still get a hard draw or a plugged cigar. With a No 2 the problem is often at the tapered end. Cut off another 1/4" and see if that helps. If not, try the drawpoker. I prefer a drill.
TBWCW
Sunday, June 25, 2006 3:13:00 PM
As others have said, 68% is probably just too much for that cigar. 65% would probably be better, or just dry box them before smoking.
BigAlnAZ
Sunday, June 25, 2006 4:50:00 PM
I had a similar experience with a RyJ #1 Cuban last month. I poked it and all was well. I have smoked 2 or 3 more since then without any problems. I must say that I was a bit surprised to find a plug in an RyJ Cuban, but there you have it. The cuban RyJ #1 Tubos are a real treat, by the way.

Big Al

Sboecker1
Sunday, June 25, 2006 6:19:00 PM
A bad draw is worse than anything including an enever burn. The latter just ticks you off, the formaer can ruin the whole experience. A draw poker has saved the day for me on many ocasions. What's mare, I seen to have more problems with toroedos than anything else. But as some here have said maybe that is due to the fact that I keep everything at 68-70 and usually don't dry box.
gringococolo
Monday, June 26, 2006 12:09:00 AM
I was the smoker referenced in the origional post. I lived in Puerto Rico for 2 years (similar climate to Cuba) and I can tell you I don't think I ever had a day at %70 humidity or lower. I do not understand why I should have to "dry box", poke, overcut, let sit out for a week, or otherwise baby a $20 cigar?? Especially one that was created in a very humid environment. I love the unique flavor of cuban tobacco, I think it is kind of "flowery", but I should not have to "stroke" a supposedly expert made cigar. I think the Cubans could be in serious trouble if they don't get their quality control issues solved. I rarely get a cuban to be consistent in construction, but I can get a box of perdomos, padrons, fuentes, drew estates, el rey de mundo, CAO's, etc.. (I could go on forever) and get quality construction %85 - %95 percent of the time at any humidity... hell sometimes we will smoke non-cubans after they have been the mail for 2 weeks.

I wish that they would just export the cuban leaves so we can get some quality rolled smokes with that unique flavor from a better factory.

Herfin in Hapon,

-Gringo

rodehog56
Monday, June 26, 2006 3:36:00 AM
To answer some of your concerns:

First off, the Cuban Government is getting out of the Cigar business. The job has been taken over by Altaids, a Spaish Co. to oversee the Cuban Cigar manufacturing. This was actually done about four years ago and we will see changes here in the near future.

Second, all cigars no matter where they are made, must be kept as close to 70-70 as possible. I used to believe the same as you that "cigars are made in a humid tropical climate". True, yet they are stored and cured in block houses lines with cedar in most instances, at a consistent 70-70 environment.

So, temp and humidity does make a difference when storing cigars. We can become anal about this and that just makes us crazy. Do the best you can. Your cigars will love it and so will you.

I live in Florida and used to keep my cigars in humidors at 70% humidity and between 75-80F all the time. They would last for a while and some would be ok and some would be as dry as the sand on the beach. I now keep them in a coolidor at 70-70 and what a difference. No matter the temp outside and it does vary daily, they are just happy little campers.

Last point, you can replace moisture in a cigar, but when the natural oils have been "sweated out" there is nothing you can do to replace the oil lost from improperly storing cigars. This will create a not so enjoyable smoke.

Too much variation in temp and humidity, can expand and reduce the size of cigars along with the flavor and taste.

Happy smoking. Don't "sweat" the details too much. Do what you can and enjoy your life.

gringococolo
Monday, June 26, 2006 4:38:00 AM
rodehog56,

Thanks for the info/reply. I am actually pretty good at maintaining my cigars at about %66-68. I guess what kills me is that all my other cigars in the same humidor; (Padron 6000{M}, Opus X's, Pimp Sticks, Centurian XX, Partagas Black, and others) all smoke/burn perfectly...all the time. I had that freakin MC#2 in there for 6 months (straight from humi to humi) and the thing just drove me nuts. I had a Siglo IV also... I let TBU smoke it when we went camping (also a tight draw). I have had better luck with Cuban R&J's and Partagas. I guess I just give up on MC's this wasn't the first super tight draw I have had from them (I did have a great H.Umpman in Thailand, and they are made in the same factory I think). OK I will stop bitchin.. and save the cash and get some more Opus's. Yea baby....

Gringo

The Big Ugly
Monday, June 26, 2006 4:54:00 AM
Gringo,

Get off the computer and bring your ass over here so we can herf!!!

TBU

sli38
Monday, June 26, 2006 6:48:00 AM
I keep all my Cubans in a seperate cabinet humidor at 63%. Never have draw problems. The hummi RH got turned up by accident recently to 68%, had nothing but problems. Also almost all draw problems will work themselves out with age.
burgess_b
Monday, June 26, 2006 8:40:00 AM
looks like i found ANOTHER herfin buddy...

now, where do we get those pokers???

usahog
Monday, June 26, 2006 12:31:00 PM
"now, where do we get those pokers???"

B shoot me an email... usahog(at)hotmail(dot)com

Hog

docrks
Monday, June 26, 2006 1:57:00 PM
sli38 wrote:

" Also almost all draw problems will work themselves out with age."

I have NOT found this to be the case at all. There are some late 2000 and 2001 Cohiba Lanceros that defy even the strongest vacuum to draw anything out of. I also experienced boxes of Monte 3s also from 2001 and 03 HdM Le Hoyo du Gourmet that are 'NAILS' and can't be smoked..... and no amount of aging is going to fix these cigars.

burgess_b
Tuesday, June 27, 2006 7:01:00 AM
thanks hog--email sent!
blackdog2000
Tuesday, June 27, 2006 7:12:00 AM
Ouch. I've got a Monte 3 I picked up recently. I was going to save it. Maybe I should just do it up instead of looking forward to a rocket.