retmac
Sunday, July 2, 2006 9:17:00 AM
i'm pretty new at the cigar game'but i really have been enjoying them. my fovorite so far has been the sinatra "my way". if anybody has a fovorite, or one they think i should try, how about a shout. thanks.
donsnyderiii
Sunday, July 2, 2006 10:54:00 AM
This question has been asked a lot. If you do a search, you'll see many suggestions. It really boils down to personal taste and everybody’s is different. The key is to try many different cigars and keep a journal of what you've tried, liked and disliked. All of the veterans who post here will tell you the same thing and that the samplers are your best bet when purchasing. I too am fairly new to this site and just recently ordered my first cigars from them. I saved a ton of dough verses what I would have paid at a walk-in retailer.

That said, I have been smoking a lot of the Rocky Patel Vintage 1992 Churchill and Robusto.

J.Redleg
Sunday, July 2, 2006 11:04:00 AM
Retmac,

Welcome.

Being new, I'd recommend you try as many cigars that you can get your hands on.

My recommendation for most new to the game is the Cu Avano Maduro. But don't stop there.

Good luck.

John

Whistlebritches
Sunday, July 2, 2006 11:45:00 AM
I would say start off with some mild to medium 5'rs and work your way up from there if necessary.There are lots of mild dominicans to choose from so pick a couple and go from there.I worked my way to more medium to medium full smokes thru this manner.I still like the mild stuff but only before lunch if I have time for a morning gar.

BTW, what does RETMAC stand for?Could we have a new squid in our presence?

NON SIBI SED PATRIAE

Ron

TBWCW
Sunday, July 2, 2006 12:17:00 PM
Hey Whistlebritches, where did you go to school? My class ring says NON SIBI SED PATRIAE.
Whistlebritches
Sunday, July 2, 2006 12:43:00 PM
I went to the school of sailing in the Persian Gulf Yacht Club,80-89.

Ron

Whistlebritches
Sunday, July 2, 2006 12:48:00 PM
For those whose Latin is as poor as mine.

NON SIBI SED PATRIAE = Not for self, but for country

Kind of the unofficial motto of the US Navy.It is also inscribed over the chapel doors of the United States Naval Academy.No I didn't attend but I did work for some damn fine officers who did.

Ron

TBWCW
Sunday, July 2, 2006 1:19:00 PM
It was also the motto for the class of 1995 which graduated in the 150th year of USNA. Perhaps not the most original motto, but we believed that originality wasn't required.
chemyst
Sunday, July 2, 2006 6:01:00 PM
I'm new to cigars, too, and got the bug from a Hoyo de

Monterey Excalibur at a charity golf tournament.

Since then I've tried Partagas Naturales, Drew Estates

Natural 'Root' maduro, and Puros Indios Presidente.

I liked the Excalibur, Partagas and PI the best so far.

Try samplers from c-bid and other vendors. Eventually

you'll give away what you don't like, and learn what

you prefer. My current thinking is to smoke a bit

less, but higher quality. Although price isn't always

the best yardstick, in many cases you do get what you

pay for.

Look for reviews/ratings to help you in your quest for

your favorite, and a clue to satisfaction/price ratio.

From one noob to another...

Chemyst

allbidness
Sunday, July 2, 2006 6:47:00 PM
Wassup chemyst?

I got a cheap, good one for ya - Rocky Patel Select Sungrown! Due to necessity, I've found quite a few inexpensive stick I enjoy immensely. But you can't smoke them all the time so once in a while...

The biggest mistake I made was not trading with a FOG early on to take advantage of their guidance and knowledge. There are a hell of a variety of good smokes out there and it's easy to be overwhelmed!

Or just plain whelmed, for that matter 😉

Sfraun04
Sunday, July 2, 2006 6:52:00 PM
***Threadjack On***

Steve, I think you were guided quite well from when you first came to CigarBid 😉

***Threadjack Off***

Getting on target, check out some of the samplers that feature different brands of cigars. Go from there and enjoy!

jpotts
Monday, July 3, 2006 8:05:00 AM
My opinion is to stick with the main labels, and avoid the one-offs and no-names. There's a reason why Rocky Patel and CAO are so highly sought, and that is "consistency". Sometimes you can find a "diamond in the rough" with trying a number of cheaper, unknown brands, but that's pretty rare. They always have something wrong with the offering: whether it's construction problems, flavor inconsistencies, or whatnot. When you spend more money on the bigger name brands, you're getting a higher-quality product...ideally.

I agree with one of the posters that said "start with mild-to-medium smokes and work up," as after a time your palette will change, and you'll acquire a taste for cigars. Secondly - in theroy - you'll be able to build up a tolerance for the higher nicotine levels that fuller-bodied cigars often bring to the table.

(I say "in theroy" because I just had a Joya de Nicaragua Antano 1970 Churchill that nearly kicked my a**. Nearly...)

As you might ascertain, I like CAO almost across the board. I also like Baccarats (though you'll have to age them for about 6 months), Hoyo de Monterrey, La Finca (relatively unknown brand), Onyx Reserve (which is a good starter for a person moving up into a full-flavor cigar), Savinelli, Por Larranga, and several others.

Oh, and one last piece of advice: don't worry about what other people think of your selection. Taste is the most subjective part of cigar smoking. Some people like a straight tobacco taste, others like the various subtle flavors that extensive curing produces. One does not always trump the other, nor is one preferred over the other. Beauty - for lack of a better word - is in the eye of the beholder. What isn't subjective are the standards of the brand in question as it relates to consistency, quality control, and so on. You don't want to pay some $100.00 for a box of cigars, only to discover you've got to toss half of them because they taste like Pine Sol...

chemyst
Monday, July 3, 2006 8:18:00 AM
allbidness,

Just working and trying to get time for a couple

cigars each week. I was browsing upcoming events.

There's something in Atlantic City next month that

sounds big. Then later, there are tastings in

Cherry Hill and Newark(?).

So many events, so little time! 🙂

Chemyst

dadz
Monday, July 3, 2006 1:58:00 PM
I'm way new too. Absolutely, your taste is everything.

Interesting you like the Sinatra.

I liked the Fitipaldi.

Slow burning
Monday, July 3, 2006 3:24:00 PM
Try Cusano 18 Connecticut. Very flavorful and tasty.
corbu12
Wednesday, July 5, 2006 9:39:00 PM
I agree with Slowburning...Cusano 18 is a nice flavorful smoke...a little mild for me these days...but a nice cigar.