I find this to be a little humorous...I made a similar post about this exact same subject three or four weeks ago, and many people jumped in to explain to me how you either have the ability to determine these subtle flavors, or not. Maybe I wasn't experienced enough to recognize these flavors yet...try exhaling through you nose, etc. I still say that if these people can decern such suptle nuances, they should be taste testers for a food company. I, on the otherhand, I have tried many different cigars over the last three years, and all that I can recognize from a cigar is a range of bad to excellent tobacco flavor; bitter, spicy, salty, grass, harsh, mild, medium, or strong, and that is it. I'm going to have to call B.S. on most of these descriptions...especially pencil shavings, acorns, dirt, metal, etc...puleeese. However, if you can truly taste these things, then I'm happy for you; just because I can't pick up these flavors certainly does not mean that you can't. However...I really think that some people just get carried away sometimes, trying to impress other people with their experience and obvious expertise. They hear all of these flavor descriptions given, and they feel that if they don't experience them as well, their fellow herfers will think they are not educated in the obviously fine art of cigar smoking. No insults meant, that is just what I believe.