J.Redleg
Tuesday, January 9, 2007 5:27:00 PM
Russ, he's a program engineer. He knows computers better than I do, and a wireless router is not supported by the service provider.

And his internet router is working fine. He does pay for internet. He just hasn't gotten a wireless router.

(Russ, am I that easy to read?)

J.Redleg
Tuesday, January 9, 2007 5:27:00 PM
Russ, he's a program engineer. He knows computers better than I do, and a wireless router is not supported by the service provider.

And his internet router is working fine. He does pay for internet. He just hasn't gotten a wireless router.

(Russ, am I that easy to read?)

usahog
Tuesday, January 9, 2007 6:07:00 PM
not on the forum your not ;0)

that was thrown in there for ya JRed! LOL

Wow if he know's what he's doing then I don't know what to tell ya.. it's a damn'd if you do, and damn'd if you don't situation...

my ex FIL (pushing daisy's now) was a ****, he owned a feed store and did custom bailing, both round and square bails... I was his number one Toby, I guess he felt that because I was married to his daughter I should be kissing his Arse 24/7 I bought this for along time.. then wised up.. of course he was this way with many people.. we went out one day and cut all day long to rake and bail up by the end of the week.. when we cut the weather was good and suppose to remain good through-out the week.. well next day a front moved through and for two days we couldn't get back out to rake.. 3rd day we raked in the morning re raked late afternoon and then noon next day went to bailing.. skipping a re-rake in the am and re-rake early afternoon then bailing... = sour hay... I knew this, he knew this.. but he was trying to beat the weekend and possible more weather.. bails were heavy, (still wet) I vented my thoughts to him, Ignored.. bailed stored in loft or guy's barn and stacked also on the ground in stalls... 2 months later the barn burnt to the ground.. I then expressed my last thoughts to the SOB and told him that would be the last time I road the wagon for him... That was also the last time I went to Thanksgiving or Christmas dinner with them...

I was sour, I was wrong, I should have not held that burden in me so long.. but at that time I was very young...

He passed away a sour man himself... Shame..

Hog

usahog
Tuesday, January 9, 2007 6:10:00 PM
loft "or" guy's barn

or = of

Mrs.Tank
Tuesday, January 9, 2007 6:17:00 PM
buy him the wireless router as a late Christmas present. Explain that you appreciate everything he's done for you and that you wanted to do this for him.

In my case, when we go wireless, the neighbor (shared wall) told me that I should be able to tap into hers without problem. (still plan on setting up my own and protecting it)

rugrunner
Tuesday, January 9, 2007 8:21:00 PM
I still say buy him the router and tell him you don't like him making you part of his misdeeds.

But then I have been accused of having a moral code that's too rigid for polite (cbid) society.

If I found pot in my 19 year old's room I'd call the cops.

To just give him the router without sticking your finger in his eye at the same time would be giving him a pass on being a jerk. If he can afford family cruises he can buy a router. If he knows computers he knows what he's doing is wrong.

C 1/319 A.F.A.R. 13B2P Redlegs rule! (sorry ARN)

usahog
Tuesday, January 9, 2007 8:25:00 PM
"If I found pot in my 19 year old's room I'd call the cops."

I didn't call the cops, but I put'em out on the street!

Hog

rugrunner
Tuesday, January 9, 2007 8:31:00 PM
The easy thing to do and the right thing to do are seldom the same thing.
usahog
Tuesday, January 9, 2007 8:40:00 PM
woulda been easier to call the cops... they ended up coming anyways... either way, as a parent.. it hit/hurt deep, and still does...

Hog

tailgater
Wednesday, January 10, 2007 3:30:00 AM
Is this really theft?

He has a laptop that receives the signal. When he logs into internet explorer, it probably automatically pulls in the strongest signal, is that correct?

Let's say he buys a wireless router. If he goes onto his deck to smoke a cigar he'll be using his own signal. But if he goes way to the back corner, and into his shed he may receive his neighbors signal because it could be stronger.

Is it still theft?

He hasn't made any modifications to purposely "steal" his neighbors signal, so why is this theft?

sw48362
Wednesday, January 10, 2007 3:53:00 AM
Buy him a router. He bought you a vacation. Decent router starts at 40.00. Also you can configure his wireless settings to see only your home router. (if you wish).

My router is encrypted, but if it wasn't and someone was hitching a ride on my internet link. I'd dump a nasty bug on their computer, and put the laptop out of commission for good. Make sure his personal fire wall is turned on.

Buckwheat
Wednesday, January 10, 2007 4:17:00 AM
Rug, ya better watch it on the Kentucky comments.

Redleg, if he feels comfortable stealing the internet usage you might as well tell him to just go ahead and break into his neighbor’s house and steal the router as well.

jpotts
Wednesday, January 10, 2007 7:46:00 AM
Most high-speed internet offerings are package deals, meaning that whomever has the high-speed connection gets charged the same amount whether it's being used or not, whether one person or fifty people are online. The WAN connection costs nothing to no one. The only internet access that I know of that has a charge for transaction volume is cellular, which means having a CDMA phone card in your laptop and communication with a cellular tower network.

So if he's tapping into a cable-modem network or even DSL, TECHNICALLY, it's not theft. And, if they wanted to secure their wireless network, they should have clamped down on who can and cannot connect to their wireless LAN.

Now, you father-in-law plays a dangerous game, as whomever's network he connected to can trap the individual packets going back and forth through the router. This means that someone with a little bit of savvy can monitor his e-mail, monitor what he's seeing on his browser (with the excepyion of SSL pages), and so on. Thus, in some respects, the joke may ultimately be on your father-in-law...

And I'd tell him that.

victor808
Wednesday, January 10, 2007 8:07:00 AM
I'm with jpotts.

The only real risk your father in law is taking is on his own information being stolen.

He is stealing the neighbors bandwidth.... but if they wanted to secure it that is well within their power.

dave97402
Wednesday, January 10, 2007 8:14:00 AM
I have cable with wireless router. We have been having trouble with the router...not working on all computers...never did figure out why...but now (just last night) bought my own cable modem with built in wireless and all is working fine.

Anyway, if I am in my garage, I'm surfing having fun, sometimes IF I check to see what my signal is, I find I'm actually connected to my neighbors connection. Now my wireless is there, but for some reason my computer decided that the neighbors was the one to connect to. My signal was actually the stronger signal. Is that wrong, or my fault? I have made my network the preferred, but often it still connects to the neighbors. How much am I required to do to ensure that I am not in the wrong? Do I have to walk next door and help them encrypt it so I can't log on?

J.Redleg
Wednesday, January 10, 2007 8:20:00 AM
We had a talk. His coworker told him to spend the $50 and buy a good wireless router. Looks like there will be six signals now.
Buckwheat
Wednesday, January 10, 2007 8:34:00 AM
"TECHNICALLY, it's not theft"

However, if you live in Florida (and some other states), it is LEGALLY theft (third-degree felony charges of unauthorized access to a computer network.)

plinytheelder
Wednesday, January 10, 2007 9:19:00 AM
Its theft.

You can't use induction from the hi-voltage line to make electricity. The argument, "I'm not taking anything they are sending down the lines, has already been fought in court.

If you are receiving or sending info onto the internet, aren't you using bandwidth or the equivalent?

Sure you are. Therefore, you're using their (the ISP) proprietary property, and they can use legal action to get their fees back.

victor808
Wednesday, January 10, 2007 11:17:00 AM
Wouldn't the burden be on the person with the wireless router? they are the ones sending the cable(or DSL) company's bandwidth out for the whole neighborhood to enjoy.

Tapping into an electricity cable (or TV) from the originating company is one thing. But the neighbor has paid for a very specific amount of bandwidth (3Mb or whatever). As long as that bandwidth gets to the neighbor's outlet, and the neighbor's check gets to the cable company, that transaction seems closed. Whether the neighbor splits that to be used by the whole neighborhood, or just uses it themselves, but downloads porn 24 hrs a day is irrelevant.

So, the father in law is stealing bandwidth from the neighbor. But not really from the cable company. And since the neighbor has chosen not to secure their router (probably the easiest thing to do), I'd question whether it is implied consent.

teedubbya
Wednesday, January 10, 2007 11:22:00 AM
It is theft and is prosecuted if/when found. But its like cuban cigars...... common.

But it is also wrong and dangerous (identity theft etc)

But then again I have no need to inform folks how strong my moral code is..... I just know it.