Quick, without thinking too much or making anything up or trying to impress, list in this order:

1. Cigar you enjoyed the most yesterday. The one you enjoyed the most, not necessarily the most expensive one.

2. Cigar you enjoyed the most last week

3. Cigar you enjoyed the most last year

4. The one you enjoyed the most, ever.

Here are mine:

1. Yesterday. Trilogy maduro.

2. With a memory like mine, this is hard. I think it was a Puros Indios toro maduro that Carlos Diez sent me. That's a good cigar. (or was that TWO weeks ago???)

3. That's an easy one. Had my first Ashton VSG Enchantment last month. It was grrrrrrrrrrrrrreat and after a great meal. (or was that TWO months ago?????)

4. This is a hard one. I think I will give the nod to a PAM sent to me by Xibbumbero, or any cigar with my brother on his patio up in Cincinnati.

5. All time? Maybe a Montecristo #2 one night in Paris. Probably the occasion and the setting as much as the cigar. I am still looking for my all time favorite cigar. Your turn, thanks.

you got 60%.

go to sleep

A D Rick? All that work for a frikkin D?

Yesterday: Cuban Parejo Rothchild Maduro
Last week: Joyo De Nicaragua Antano 1970 Gran Robusto
Last year: LGC Serie R #5 Maduro
Ever: (tie) Opus X Perfecxion #2 & Camacho Figurado Corojo

1. Cigar you enjoyed the most yesterday.
Diamond Crown #3 Robusto with a glass of 10 yr port. last night.

2. Cigar you enjoyed the most last week
Fuente Double Chateau Sun grown.

3. Cigar you enjoyed the most last year
Several Cuban Bolivar Double Coronas while my son smoked Cuban Montecristo #4's on deck of our cruise ship in Greece and Italy last year.

4. The one you enjoyed the most, ever so far.
Had to be my first Cuban Bolivar Belicoso Fino, Cabinet selection from the cabinet, the rest of which I am keeping buried and rationing one a month!

5. All time?
I keep hoping for a true rival to cuban cigars from
some other place besides the island south of miami.

Mike Gardner (iquester)

Yesterday: La Aroma de Cuba Robusto. Love these little guys.

Last Week: 2yr aged Padron #5000 Maduro. Not a fancy premium, but a great, great smoke.

Last Year: Cuban Trinidad Fundadores. What can I say? Castro used to give these away personally.

All time: Cuban Cohiba Esplendido from 1997. My personal standard for greatness. Sure, I hope it will be toppled by another, greater smoke, but that is a pretty tough one to beat.

Recalling all of that made me drool for cigars. Maybe I'll cancel classes and smoke all day at the bar.

Thanks for the question. Life is better now.

John

1. Cigar you enjoyed the most yesterday.
Indian Tabac Super Fuerte maddie torp

2. Cigar you enjoyed the most last week
Camacho 11/18

3. Cigar you enjoyed the most last year
The PAM I smoked on my b'day

4. The one you enjoyed the most, ever.
Don't know that I've smoked that one yet ... I keep hoping that will be the next one I light up ... but, of those I HAVE already smoked, those that COULD be candidates for this honor that quickly come to mind include a few different:

Habanos, Perdomos, Padrons, Bucaneros, CAOs, and Camachos ...

1. Cigar you enjoyed the most yesterday.
Monte #4

2. Cigar you enjoyed the most last week
Bucanero El Capitan Maduro

3. Cigar you enjoyed the most last year
La Perla Black Pearl

4. The one you enjoyed the most, ever.
Monte #2 thought to be a fake (too light, too big)

Yesterday...........Excalibur Maduro III

Last Week...........Montecristo #2 ISOM (bombed by Chris Wilhelmi!

Last Year...........CAO Black

Favorite ever.......Montecristo #2 ISOM

This is a tough quiz, since my favorites change and really I have top 5's in catagories! Good question though....Bucaneros, LaGloria Cubana Serie R, Joya de Nics (Wow, get seated), Onyx Reserves, etc!

Charlie

1-HdM epicure #2 ISOM
2-Partagas Serie D#4
3-Opus X Power Ranger
4-Too many great ones-unable to single just one out

eleltea

#2. "I think it was"

#4. "I think I will give the nod to"

5. "All time? Maybe"

i gave you credit for the 2 you answered and extra credit for penmanship and spelling.

eleltea

see how well the others answered? you need to hit the the books and catch up with the rest of the class.

i'll give you extra credit for "works and plays well with others". make it a 70%, but this is the last time.

When is it going to be my turn? I have had my arm up for 10 minutes!!! Since Rickmaven is not going to call on me, I am going to rudely jump in:

As you all know, I live in a place where I can purchase and Smoke Havana's so don't be surprised with my choices:

1. Cigar you enjoyed the most yesterday.
PAM Anniversary 64 - Burned it for an Ole Friend 🙂

2. Cigar you enjoyed the most last week
RyJ LE 2001 - Awesome! Awesome! Awesome!

3. Cigar you enjoyed the most last year- tie!
Montecristo Number 2 and Partagas LE 2001

4. The one you enjoyed the most, ever.
Montecristo A Series - Smoked it while I after I come home from the Desert...

Okay, Rick - I turn the floor back over to you. I apologize for interrupting. 🙂

Regards,


B

Yesterday=IT Warrior
Last week= PSD#3 EL
last year= Monty Millenium Robusto
Ever= see above..X

Rick's real first name is Simon. lmao
I am enjoying the responses and taking sugestions. Hope this keeps going.

Yesterday - Avo XO Intermezzo
Last Week - CAO Black Gothic
Last Year - Monte #2 ISOM
Ever - Monte #2 ISOM

Yesterday: Savinelli Seconds Torpedo

Last Week: Bolivar Corona ISOM

Last Year: CAO Black Bengal

Ever: Pleiades Pluton Maduro - my first smoke ever...the one that started it all.

Yesterday -
Padron 1926 (spent entire casino winnings of just under $55 for 3 1926 #6 natties--side note: I would not buy these unless there are "free"-- aka casino winnings)

Last Week - Opus X #4 from E-chick, Camacho Liberty

Last Year - PAM Imperial with 8 months box age. wowzers!

Ever - not in any particular order:
* My first cigar (a Diamond Crown #4)
* My first OpusX (#2)
* My first Havana (Partagas Super Partagas with so much plume on it I thought somebody was playing a trick on me and dipped it in fine powdered sugar)
* My first PAM
* My first Buc Full Sail
* My first Camacho Liberty (what an incredible smoke--arguably the best ever total corojo puro with Diplomas and 11/18s right behind)
* Every cigar I've smoked on my fishing trips in the middle of nowhere taking in the peacefullness of the wilderness with it's quiet solitude broken only by the chirping of birds and the gurgling of a river or stream.

1.Cigar you enjoyed the most yesterday. The one you enjoyed the most, not necessarily the most expensive one.
**Sinatra (only had one cigar yesterday)


2. Cigar you enjoyed the most last week

**Oliva Grand Maduro

3. Cigar you enjoyed the most last year

**Davidoff Millenium Robusto

4. The one you enjoyed the most, ever.

**1964 Padron Anniversary

Happy Smokin, Joel
Go Lakers!

Yesterday = Lone Wolf Corona

Past Year = Thomas Hinds Vintage Churchill Aged 2.5 years

Best Ever = Vega Fina Lonsdale 1998 Edition

My Pick For Up and Coming Cigar for 2003 = Jose Bartolo