HockeyDad
Friday, June 1, 2007 2:42:00 PM
ANNEX IRAQ! I can support that. That's what a good war is all about.

Canada can wait in line and be the 52nd state.

GreenWolf70
Friday, June 1, 2007 2:58:00 PM
Seems like the new strategy and leadership is running Al Queda out of Iraq, not to mention out of Lebanon too. As Iraqis feel secure enough to speak out against the terrorists, the situation in Iraq will greatly improve. Hell, it took the Bosnians 3 or 4 years just to believe their votes were really being counted.

War usually gets rid of most of the peace-time accumulated, butt kissing, "no idea what they are doing" military leadership, but it does take a while for the process to shake out.

If you really want to scare yourself, take a look at the General we have opposing Kim Il Young in Korea. It makes you wonder which one is crazier.

Washington Post

June 1, 2007

Pg. 11

Sunni Insurgents Battle In Baghdad

Residents of Western Neighborhood Join Groups' Fight Against Al-Qaeda in Iraq

By John Ward Anderson, Washington Post Foreign Service

BAGHDAD, May 31 -- Sunni residents of a west Baghdad neighborhood used assault rifles and a roadside bomb to battle the Sunni insurgent group al-Qaeda in Iraq this week, leaving at least 28 people dead and six injured, residents said Thursday.

The mayor of the Amiriyah neighborhood, Mohammed Abdul Khaliq, said in a telephone interview that residents were rising up to try to expel al-Qaeda in Iraq, which has alienated other Sunnis with its indiscriminate violence and attacks on members of its own sect.

"I think this is going to be the end of the al-Qaeda presence here," Abdul Khaliq said of the fighting Wednesday and Thursday, which began over accusations that al-Qaeda in Iraq had executed Sunnis without reason.

The Baghdad battle is evidence of a deepening split between some Sunni insurgent groups and al-Qaeda in Iraq, which claims allegiance to Osama bin Laden. Although similar rebellions occurred in Diyala province earlier this year, the fighting this week appears to be the first time the conflict has reached the streets of Baghdad.

Abdul Khaliq said he hoped U.S. forces would stay out of the fight. "But if the Americans interfere, it will blow up, because they are the enemy of us both, and we will unite against them and stop fighting each other," he said.

In the western province of Anbar, which is predominantly Sunni, tribal leaders have formed an umbrella group, the Anbar Salvation Council, to join with U.S. and Iraqi troops in a common fight against al-Qaeda in Iraq, which used to dominate the province. Lt. Gen. Raymond T. Odierno, the No. 2 commander of U.S. forces in Iraq, said at a news briefing Thursday that 12,000 Anbar residents have joined the Iraqi security forces in the first five months of this year, compared with 1,000 in all of last year.

Tribal leaders say they are signing up because they oppose al-Qaeda in Iraq's extremist ideologies and its attacks on local residents, but critics of the council say the U.S. effort in Anbar amounts to backing one private army against another.

In an attack clearly meant to intimidate the tribes, a suicide bomber wearing an explosives vest blew himself up Thursday among 150 recruits waiting to enter a police compound in the Anbar city of Fallujah, killing 25 people and wounding at least 20, said Ayman Hussein Zaidan, an official at Fallujah General Hospital.

In a second suicide attack Thursday in Anbar, six people were killed, including three policemen, when a car bomb exploded at a telephone exchange in Ramadi, the provincial capital about 60 miles west of Baghdad, said Col. Tariq al-Dulaimi, a local police chief. He said seven police officers and two bystanders were wounded in the blast.

The Amiriyah neighborhood, located near Baghdad International Airport in the western part of the capital, has been hit hard by rampant violence, a lack of services and the expulsion of Shiite families. It is considered a virtual no man's land.

Problems arose on Tuesday when the Islamic Army, a powerful Sunni insurgent group, posted a statement at a local mosque criticizing al-Qaeda in Iraq for killing dozens of other Sunnis in Fallujah and Baghdad "on suspicion only," without sufficient evidence that they had done something wrong, according to a copy sent to The Washington Post. The message warned al-Qaeda in Iraq to stop the practice, which it said could lead to clashes between them.

Late Wednesday afternoon, according to residents reached by phone who would not be quoted by name for security reasons, an armed group scrawled graffiti on a school wall reading: "Down with al-Qaeda, long live the honest resistance." When al-Qaeda in Iraq members came to wipe away the writing, a roadside bomb exploded nearby, killing three of them, residents said.

Al-Qaeda in Iraq then attacked a mosque associated with the Islamic Army, killing the group's leader, Razi al-Zobai, and four other fighters, complaining in a statement that the Islamic Army had become involved in the political process in Iraq, residents said. In retaliation, the Islamic Army attacked a mosque associated with al-Qaeda in Iraq, killing one of the group's leaders, known as Sheik Hamid, and four other members, including Waleed Saber Tikriti, a doctor who treated al-Qaeda in Iraq's wounded, residents said.

On Thursday, al-Qaeda in Iraq reinforcements arrived from other Baghdad neighborhoods, residents said, and furious fighting erupted between the groups, lasting about four hours. Nine fighters from al-Qaeda in Iraq and six from the Islamic Army were killed, according to Abu Ahmed al-Baghdadi, an Islamic Army leader reached by telephone. He said six civilians were injured by a mortar round fired by al-Qaeda in Iraq "criminals."

Baghdadi said about 40 members of al-Qaeda in Iraq fought a force of 30 fighters from the Islamic Army and the 1920 Revolution Brigades, another Sunni insurgent group. The latter two groups were aided by local residents who oppose al-Qaeda in Iraq, he said.

Despite being outnumbered, the Sunni insurgent leaders asserted, they had a significant advantage over al-Qaeda in Iraq because its members were staying in abandoned Shiite houses that were well known, while the Sunni insurgents were blended among the population.

jpotts
  • jpotts
  • Herf-A-Holic Topic Starter
Friday, June 1, 2007 8:04:00 PM
DrMaddVibe:

Concerning some of your comments on this thread: all I can say is "at least it's not just me saying this sh*t."

Keep up the good fight!

DrMaddVibe
Friday, June 1, 2007 8:12:00 PM
Excelsior!
jpotts
  • jpotts
  • Herf-A-Holic Topic Starter
Friday, June 1, 2007 8:25:00 PM
Ok, my take on the the premise of this thread.

I think that if any of the people I mentioned in the beginning of the thread take office, we'll still be in Iraq for another 4 - 6 years.

I think if a frontrunner republican gets into the White House, we'll still be there for another 4 - 6 years.

In fact, I think the only way the troops will be pulled from Iraq is if Ralph Nader or Dennis Kusinich get into office, because they're absolute nut-jobs.

The reason for my thinking?

No one likes war, but Americans don't like losing a war. And they sure as hell don't want the word Iraq to be synonymous with Vietnam, and I think the DNC has polling data TELLING them this. It's the reason why you're not hearing an awful lot from jack Murtha these days, and why the supplamental funding bill got passed without a provision for a timeline. They don't want to be blamed for another Vietnam-style retreat.

Secondly, the perception is that the democrats are weak militarially (and, putting my personal feelings aside, I'm saying that this is the perception). Continuing the stuggle in Iraq for another 4 years, when the concflict winds down will help eliminate that perception. In short, it is not in the best interests of a democrat president to be in office after the troops are withdrawn, or in the process of withdrawing troops. As a matter of fact, if the troops are already withdrawn, and things go to hell in Iraq while a deomcrat is sitting in the White House, then they'll be in the unenviable position of either recomitting troops to resecure that place, or answering the uncomfortable question of why troops were withdrawn when the forgone conclusion was that everything would collapse when we pulled out.

There there is the little matter of Iran getting their dirty little fingers in the situation.

Lastly, the democrats have made this Bush's war. In fact, they've gone OUT OF THEIR WAY to do that. If things go well before or just after he leaves office, they can't take any credit for it. They can only take credit for it if things go well while they are in the Oval office, and calling the shots.

They can talk about pulling out troops all they want during the primaries, but the issue will be a loser come the general election.

There are lot more factors that go into my prediction, but my general opinion is that pulling troops out is a no-win situation for democrats in the next presidential election.

Oddboggle
Friday, June 1, 2007 10:05:00 PM
Why are things always win/lose when it comes to war?

This isn't a matter of pride, or taking or giving credit for ending a war; this isn't a game.

Everybody wants the war to end, our troops back home, and a fricken exit strategy. As it stands, there's no end in sight, and winning -- rather, re-winning the war -- is left to how you wish to interpret that.

Oddboggle

plinytheelder
Saturday, June 2, 2007 4:23:00 AM
Greenwolf, The leader of North Korea is Kim Jong-Il.

His dad was Kim Il-Sung.

The rest of your post was pretty good though.

plinytheelder
Saturday, June 2, 2007 4:28:00 AM
As far as the thread goes, the next President, regardless of which party they're from, will keep us in Iraq for longer than most people want.

Its the nature of our political machine. A President continues the policies of the President he replaces.

The lone exception was Gerald Ford with Vietnam.

teedubbya
Saturday, June 2, 2007 9:00:00 AM
Saddam couldn't hold Idi Amin's jockstrap
HockeyDad
Saturday, June 2, 2007 11:03:00 AM
I have it on good information that Iraq is safer than Philadelphia.
pabloescabar
Saturday, June 2, 2007 11:04:00 AM
...true dat
DrMaddVibe
Saturday, June 2, 2007 11:05:00 AM
#69...he actually used it as a hammock!
jpotts
  • jpotts
  • Herf-A-Holic Topic Starter
Sunday, June 3, 2007 10:04:00 PM
Oddboggle:

Wars are ALWAYS about win / lose. Secondly, there has never been a war ever fought where an "exit strategy" was laid out. But is an "exit strategy" could be defined, it would be that our side"won" and the other side "lost".

Pulling out has long-reaching implications. Our pulling out of Vietnam allowed that king of gurrilla-war strategy to seem to be effective. So, every enemy we fight in the future will use that tactic of prolonging a war so that the Americans get tired of it, and go home. Thus, they can say they won.

Secondly, we have allies in Iraq. If we pull out and leave them stranded, we send a message to all of our other allies that we'll pimp them too. And they, in turn, won't even bother forwarding things on our agenda.

People seem to forget all of the allies we left high-and-dry in Vietnam.

Vietnam did more damage to this nation's standing in the world than any of the perceived wrongs of George W Bush. It will be further bolstered by a "loss" in Iraq. I'm not sure if any of this plays into the calculations of the frontrunner democrats.