jpotts
Friday, June 8, 2007 2:42:00 PM
Victor808:

"Sorry, things have been busy.'

Things might be getting busy on my end soon, so you may be winning this debate by default.

"The last thing we were discussing in that thread (you can find it if you have the time) was your "normalizing" method."

The two methods I used were summarizing all of the categories from most to least, giving me something like 8 different groupings and/or permutations. Of them, only 2 of them put democrats in high education levels, the rest all went to republicans. You suggested weighing each group with an average number of years education, something that I included (I believe) in the second method.

The second method had the divisions weighted by population, given that if you used averages alone, the results when taken to extremes – something like 10 out 1000 people being democrats, and 9 of those 10 having doctorates - would not even be close to reality. By factoring in population to the averages, it gave them a weight that (in my view, and not yours) better reflected a true representative number.

The issue was that democrats were behind in all sectors of education except people with PHDs, which pulled the average level of education back to the democrat side. But, because the population of that sample was so rediculisly low, it had, what I felt was, an undue skewing effect on a representative result. The funny thing is that I really had no idea to the extent that factoring for population would effect the final totals, but I pretty much instinctively knew that it needed to be factored in there because of the tests that I needed to put the process to extremes. It just so happened that this swung things the other way. So I guess you could say that whatever my prediction was, it was a belief, and on equal footing with religion.

"Rugrunner got lost a long way into our conversation back there, and any correctness on his part would have to be completely accidental."

So, I'm taking it that he's not going to hear "rugrunner, you're right and I'm wrong" anytime soon? (Not like it matters, he's hasn't been around anyways.) 🙂

"No. I never condemned observation. I'm saying the observation that you made is simply 'the bible shows insight into human nature. ' That is not a datapoint for any conclusion other than "'someone(s) with insight into human nature authored the bible'. As an example I suggested sartre. Thats still a VERY long stretch from any sort of leap to invisible creatures and torturous afterlifes."

Actually, in Old Testament writings, there is no "afterlife" – that's strictly a Christian-centric belief (with a few notable exceptions). The whole point of detailing the specifics of human behavior, especially in Genesis, is to lay the foundation for the Levitican Laws, which follows afterwards. These truisms of human behavior were noted and detailed because the further fit into one of the main focuses of the Bible, and that is how people do and should interact with one another. Thus, without the foundational observations and/or truisms, the laws that were created to govern human behavior would have no fundamental foundation.

Thus, they are "data points". Just as stereotypical behavior provides a foundation for many of the sciences like psychology ("stereotypical" in that it follows a pattern and can be defined).

Or, for a reverse example, saying 1 + 1 = 2 is a fact, and therefore because this is always true, there is a God. An orderly and consistent universe – in your opinion, perhaps – MAY prove God, but that one piece of information alone does not prove the whole point.

And no, I'm now not saying that there is no God.

"Of course it is speculation. But it is speculation based on DATA."

And, again, I can take data that is completely unrelated to, say, mitochondria and use it to "prove" something that is untrue. Data is only relevant or true AFTER something is proven, not before. One justifies the other. Consider it a "circle of life" thing…

"No. I don't understand why that would be necessary to the argument. There is an idea: People can eat whatever they would like. It goes against general hindu religion: cows are sacred and should be treated as such. These two are essentially in conflict. The process of breeding/harvesting cows is clearly not treating them as sacred animals. Yet Hindi can live in a country which permits this without throwing a fit. Therefore one can live under law which is in direct conflict with a religious ideal. (I'm paraphrasing, because I can't remember what I said)."

There is no law that requires a person to eat meat in this country. Your argument: " Therefore one can live under law which is in direct conflict with a religious ideal" is incorrect. The whole premise of this argument is that the Founding Fathers did not draw on the pillars of their religions, but instead incorporated good ideas as a part of the framework of this nation. The problem with that argument is manifold:

1) Virtually all of them were Fundamentalist Christians, or would so be considered by today's standards.

2) It's really clear from the history and writings of people like Jefferson, Madison, and Mason that they were heavily influenced by John Locke.

3) The three main works that influenced the Founding Fathers are deeply rooted in the Bible and Biblical principles (one of them starts out with Adam's relationship to God and the world around him).

4) Additional writings by people like Jefferson, Franklin, Madison, Adams all talk about virtue and religion being fundamental in good governance, and of the virtues of Christianity as a religion.

5) Things that contrasted with a Judean-Christian view of the world were not all that tolerated in colonial times – things like divorce, sodomy, pornography, being a few examples of this.

So, outside of those few, key facts, you might have an argument.

"An interesting idea, but only partially correct. Natural Selection only refers to outside agents influencing which genetic traits survive which fail. We are essentially 'natural selection' at this moment in the earth's history. Almost every species' existence depends on how it interacts with us, and through its interactions with us its traits change (cows are a big example).

Long story short, whether it is impossible in a lab, in a single experiment depends on what you are trying to prove. 'evolution' is a big grouping of theories, each of which requires independent experiments."

None of which have been done to any great conclusion. While I agree that there is more then one version of Evolution, you know as well as I that the Natural Selection crowd dominates this debate. And there very fact that there is dissent within the Evolution community, shows that there is no genuine proof that validates Evolution, just a bunch of scattered pieces that some people may *assume* go together, but until it can be recreated or observed in action, it's all just speculation. Speculation, therefore puts Evolution as a matter of belief, or faith. Thus, Evolution is on the same footing as a religion.

"'First, I’m not defending Intelligent Design.' Then don't bring it into the conversation. If you aren't defending it, then you just threw it out there as a red herring."

I wasn't. I was just pointing out that this is where the speculators of ID MAY have a point. I didn't say they DID have a point.

"No. If a scientist were to evolve something into something else in a lab, that would suggest that a species can evolve into another species in response to external environmental factors. This would in no way whatsoever support Intelligent Design. Why, you ask? Because Intelligent design first and foremost requires the existence of a diety of some sort. Before you can even THINK of suggesting a theory of intelligent design, you have to FIRST prove that there is something out there which would be the active designer. Without proof of a diety, you have no reason to make the leap to intelligent design."

Intelligent Design, from what little I know of it, emphasizes just that: an intelligence that formed a genetic design. It could be a deity, a man, or the green monster standing on the corner. But what is very clear about the concept is that randomness is not a part of the game. Part and parcel of doing an experiment to change a chimp into a man is that fact that conditions are purposely set to get a specific outcome by an intelligent force. If you want to call the little, bald guy with a white lab coat on a deity, then be my guest. But, when boiled down to the barest essence, changes from one species to another are not done by random cause and effect.

Like I said, this is from what little I know, and in some ways there is a certain logic to it.

"Again. difference goes back to the fact that there is REASON to speculate these theories in science, because there is DATA which suggests that these theories are on the right track. Your DATA for your entire religious belief, could also just as easily suggest that Sartre wrote the bible. You have not been able to come up with good data to support ANY religious belief. I can come up with data to support evolutiouary arguments."

Which may or may not be correct – this has yet to be proven, because the concept as a whole is unproven. Much of this argument is somewhat (and I kind of use that term loosely) based on the notion that data did not exist until it was uncovered. In fact whatever data that may or may not prove Evolution existed well before someone found it. And if that did exist, other data points also exist that have not yet been uncovered. And, as I stated before, proof of a concept validates that data that supports it. Just because you have data, does not mean the concept it correct.

Thus, until the concept is proven correct, it is a belief. Belief is the realm of religion.

"First, A donkey would never be proof. It is sterile. The proof (and I don't know if it exists) would be if the final species cannot mate with the ancestral species (while still maintaining its own species). Of course the issue would be that under most conditions, whatever would have caused the selection against the ancestral species would also have caused its extinction. As I said, we cannot do a directed recreation of the exact evolutionary process which has occurred. But doing that is not necesary to prove evolution itself. Hell we can observe the evolution of bacteria/viruses, but I wont use that as an example (too easy). You want something more complicated, you're just going to have to wait. I'll tell you what though, until it's proven, I suggest that you only use 'creationist approved' antibiotics... you know, stuff that worked on the very first bacterial infections. Because I wouldn't want you to compromise your beliefs by assuming that there has been any natural selection among microorganisms."

This would assume that antibiotics came about as a part of the Evolutionary process. Since evolution is not proven, I can only assume that there was a purpose behind the existence if antibiotics.

Secondly, if you know the Bible well enough, you know that antibiotics can be easily approved as bring something that is not in conflict with a religious doctrine.

But moreover, I take issue with this statement: "As I said, we cannot do a directed recreation of the exact evolutionary process which has occurred. But doing that is not necesary to prove evolution itself." Ok, let's stick to the antibiotics thing here, and take God out of it. Antibiotics may have actually existed a long time before we came along, as evidenced by some of the things that Ice Man they found in the Alps was carrying with him (one of them was a fungus that had some antibiotic properties). And in many folk and indigenous cures, molds and fungus were pretty standard in warding off infections. But that alone does not prove that antibiotics existed. Only when someone managed to observe the effect on bacteriological colonies, and then researched how these things worked, did antibiotics come into being (and that being stuff like penicillin). Only AFTER their effectiveness was proven could they be defined as antibiotics. And, in the case of antibiotics, this was something that was basically forgotten, and as the classic story of penicillin tells, was "rediscovered" by accident. But to say that because some molds seem to heal wounds a little better does not say that you can use them to end syphilis – that has to be proven before it can be true.

"Two different requests. Genetically converting an ape to a man is very possible. Just a lengthy experiment requiring the violation of a number of laws. Hell, I know your rightwing nuts would be against it, since every embryonic mistake would have to be aborted (and yes there would be many). Here's something I don't think you quite understand. I remember an experiment we did in Developmental Bio lab many years ago. In essence we were recreating a landmark experiment by a scientist regarding limb growth factors. In the experiment, we would cut a window in a fertilized chicken egg, find the 2mm embryonic chicken, and cut off a limb bud (basically a bump on the embryo). We would then open a second egg, and take that limb bud and graft it on to the second embryo (basically scrape the embryo and drop it on). If all the factors required for the development of a limb were contained in the limb bud, then the second chicken would have an extra wing/leg. Do you know how many things could go wrong in that experiment? The original scientist tried it 400 times before it worked, and yet succeeding ONCE proved the theory. Hell, in our class only one worked, and we knew exactly how it was supposed to work. EVEN IF YOU HAVE ALL THE TOOLS NECESSARY, AND KNOW EXACTLY HOW IT WILL GO, YOU NEED TO DO MULTIPLE TRIALS."

Ok, you want to know what basic difference between my challenge and your illustration? Your chicken wing experiment was done once already, and was - by your very words - repeatable. My challenge (as far as I'm aware) has not, and is not.

It's a real long stretch between saying something can be done, and actually doing it.

"EVOLVING an ape into a man would require the complete recreation of the entire earth over the entire period of time. If I asked you to recreate Waterloo, you'd probably say thats impossible too. Does that mean it didn't happen?"

One did happen, and was documented as having happened. There were firsthand observations of Waterloo. There are still artifacts of things that were in Waterloo. There is nothing that documented Evolution, not have there been any first-hand observations of Evolutionary change. One is creating something that has a long trail of documentation that was spawned from it's inception, the other has virtually no documentation other than what's been discovered (and there's a lot more yet to discover). Big, big difference in examples.

"Oh, and just because I continue to argue with you on this, don't actually assume that means your arguments are good. Just means you like to keep repeating them."

Because you fail to acknowledge that just because there is data that points to something, doesn’t mean that "something" exists. It has to be proven to exist before that data is shown to be relevant.

"I'm not sure where you're even going with this. I suggested we abolish the term marriage, and just have the legal definition be 'civil union'. That would still be a legal process, basically the same as acquiring a marriage license right now. Don't see how your little rant plays into it."

It's how something on which you and I may agree can be turned on it’s head when someone else doesn't agree with us. You and I seem to acknowledge that a consentual relationship between two adults (our difference in opinion is that I further define it as a man and a woman) constitutes a "marriage", and that is the BASIC definition that you and I are using here. But the original concept of "gay marriage" was so that gays would have the same "rights" and "privledges" that married heterosexuals have. Ok, so let's say, for the sake of argument, that you and I come to an agreement on that.

The next people to complain will be those that don't want a recognized marriage at all, but want to have all the same "rights" and "privledges" that married couples have. And they'll use the EXACT same arguments that are used right now to frame the present debate over "gay marriage".

Slippery slope.

"What about stupid married couples, who don't follow through with wills right away?"

As it stands right now, will or no will, everything gets thrown into probate court. This however, depends on what state you live in. If you set up trusts, and appoint an executor, when someone dies, the executor still maintains control. Needless to say, before my great uncle and aunt, and one of my grandmothers died, all of their money was thrown into trusts. So, if I die, and let's say that a bank account was in my name only, that would need to go to a probate court.

Granted, I'm not a financial genius here. But I know my dad is putting virtually everything he has into trusts and appointing my brother as an executor. Consequently, he's also the executor of my grandmother's estate, which is also mostly bound up into trusts. It's a messy, messy business.

"If they are straight, they are generally protected because of the recognized relationship. If they are gay, they aren't. Are stupid straight people somehow more important than stupid gay people? Then there is the issue of health insurance. I believe companies are still allowed to provide health insurance for straight married couple spouses, but not gay. I think the UW here lost a professor because the state insurance plan wouldn't cover his gay spouse. So, it is unequal. Interesting."

While you might have an argument for public sector employment, private sector employment is pretty much "at will". If they don't like how you part your hair, you get fired. And if they don't want to provide insurance to your wife and/or partner, they don't. I've seen (and have actually worked at a company) companies that ONLY provided catastrophic insurance for me. There was no spousal or family plan. But these days, a lot of companies provide "partner" health insurance, or as an alternate you can take on the insurance burden for yourself, and go with a cut rate plan, and have your "partner" go on as a dependant. There is no restriction in this, and regardless of how you have sex, your money is still green.

"It will happen because people can't seem to make decisions rationally."

As I've said before, rationale (and rational choices) are relative. What may be rational for you, is not rational for someone else.

"Frighteningly enough, I blame the christian right. This is just a mental exercise (please don't turn this into a silly argument as well), but think of how most of the arguments against gay marriage run from the christian right. "Its wrong because it says so in the bible" (I'm boiling the argument down for brevity sake). Well, that is unfortunately using the bible as a serious crutch in an argument. What happens when that bible is taken away? Hypothetically, lets assume that gay marriage is approved nationwide, because the bible is a bad argument against it. It actually gives those groups with questionable arguments (child/bestiality) more power, simply because half of the christian right's argument was based on religious belief. Suddenly, the argument isn't focused on the relevant parts of the issue, but on whether or not one can legislate religion (which shouldn't even be an issue in child/horse marrying)."

Your problem with this is that those you call the "Christian Right" have both founded this country, and have been in charge for a good 200+ years. And while you may not like the Bible, it is a main source document for the very rights you enjoy. People seem to forget that slavery was not actually an issue of "civil rights", but a basic religious dispute between people who wanted to keep it (the slave holders) and the people that wanted to get rid of it (the abolitionists). The slave-holders used the notion that black people were not "men" in the conventional sense, and that a specific passage of Genesis – the one where one of the sons saw Noah's nakedness – gave whites (or at the furthest end of the definition: non Africans) the authority to rule blacks. Abolitionists saw this as an outright conflict with Christian teachings, the main points of Levitican law.

The fact that slaves benefited the south's economy cemented slavery in the south.

The Bible is a HUGE portion of this nation's heritage. You cannot easily dismiss it because it doesn't fit your ideology.

Consequently, the Bible (or at least the portions that matter) has no one religion that can lay claim to it. Muslims reference may different portions of the Bible (fitted to their religion, of course), as do Jews (Old Testament), and Christians. And much of the morality that both you and I subscribe to is based off of a semi-puritanical view of the world. I know you'll disagree with this, but then again think about what you consider right and wrong, and contrast that to the many Biblical principles I've highlighted in out little argument here. You may very well discover that you have far more in common with what the Bible advocates, than not.

"'Well, that depends. Should an entire society pay for the misdeeds of a minority?' Yes."

And what if a good portion of that society was against said misdeed from the very beginning? They are to be held accountable?

"'Secondly, 'intelligence' and 'rationalization' are relative concepts. Some people think that it’s a smart thing to do female circumcisions.' I agree. Hell, it may be a smart thing. I don't think its smart, but no one knows everything. Maybe I'm missing something."

Well it looks like we kinda agree on something else.

HockeyDad
Friday, June 8, 2007 4:35:00 PM
^Top.

erkwgz
Friday, June 8, 2007 4:39:00 PM
Why???
pabloescabar
Friday, June 8, 2007 4:40:00 PM
21. Author: jpotts Date: 06/08/2007 06:42 PM Reply

Victor808:

"Sorry, things have been busy.'

Things might be getting busy on my end soon, so you may be winning this debate by default.

"The last thing we were discussing in that thread (you can find it if you have the time) was your "normalizing" method."

The two methods I used were summarizing all of the categories from most to least, giving me something like 8 different groupings and/or permutations. Of them, only 2 of them put democrats in high education levels, the rest all went to republicans. You suggested weighing each group with an average number of years education, something that I included (I believe) in the second method.

The second method had the divisions weighted by population, given that if you used averages alone, the results when taken to extremes – something like 10 out 1000 people being democrats, and 9 of those 10 having doctorates - would not even be close to reality. By factoring in population to the averages, it gave them a weight that (in my view, and not yours) better reflected a true representative number.

The issue was that democrats were behind in all sectors of education except people with PHDs, which pulled the average level of education back to the democrat side. But, because the population of that sample was so rediculisly low, it had, what I felt was, an undue skewing effect on a representative result. The funny thing is that I really had no idea to the extent that factoring for population would effect the final totals, but I pretty much instinctively knew that it needed to be factored in there because of the tests that I needed to put the process to extremes. It just so happened that this swung things the other way. So I guess you could say that whatever my prediction was, it was a belief, and on equal footing with religion.

"Rugrunner got lost a long way into our conversation back there, and any correctness on his part would have to be completely accidental."

So, I'm taking it that he's not going to hear "rugrunner, you're right and I'm wrong" anytime soon? (Not like it matters, he's hasn't been around anyways.) 🙂

"No. I never condemned observation. I'm saying the observation that you made is simply 'the bible shows insight into human nature. ' That is not a datapoint for any conclusion other than "'someone(s) with insight into human nature authored the bible'. As an example I suggested sartre. Thats still a VERY long stretch from any sort of leap to invisible creatures and torturous afterlifes."

Actually, in Old Testament writings, there is no "afterlife" – that's strictly a Christian-centric belief (with a few notable exceptions). The whole point of detailing the specifics of human behavior, especially in Genesis, is to lay the foundation for the Levitican Laws, which follows afterwards. These truisms of human behavior were noted and detailed because the further fit into one of the main focuses of the Bible, and that is how people do and should interact with one another. Thus, without the foundational observations and/or truisms, the laws that were created to govern human behavior would have no fundamental foundation.

Thus, they are "data points". Just as stereotypical behavior provides a foundation for many of the sciences like psychology ("stereotypical" in that it follows a pattern and can be defined).

Or, for a reverse example, saying 1 + 1 = 2 is a fact, and therefore because this is always true, there is a God. An orderly and consistent universe – in your opinion, perhaps – MAY prove God, but that one piece of information alone does not prove the whole point.

And no, I'm now not saying that there is no God.

"Of course it is speculation. But it is speculation based on DATA."

And, again, I can take data that is completely unrelated to, say, mitochondria and use it to "prove" something that is untrue. Data is only relevant or true AFTER something is proven, not before. One justifies the other. Consider it a "circle of life" thing…

"No. I don't understand why that would be necessary to the argument. There is an idea: People can eat whatever they would like. It goes against general hindu religion: cows are sacred and should be treated as such. These two are essentially in conflict. The process of breeding/harvesting cows is clearly not treating them as sacred animals. Yet Hindi can live in a country which permits this without throwing a fit. Therefore one can live under law which is in direct conflict with a religious ideal. (I'm paraphrasing, because I can't remember what I said)."

There is no law that requires a person to eat meat in this country. Your argument: " Therefore one can live under law which is in direct conflict with a religious ideal" is incorrect. The whole premise of this argument is that the Founding Fathers did not draw on the pillars of their religions, but instead incorporated good ideas as a part of the framework of this nation. The problem with that argument is manifold:

1) Virtually all of them were Fundamentalist Christians, or would so be considered by today's standards.

2) It's really clear from the history and writings of people like Jefferson, Madison, and Mason that they were heavily influenced by John Locke.

3) The three main works that influenced the Founding Fathers are deeply rooted in the Bible and Biblical principles (one of them starts out with Adam's relationship to God and the world around him).

4) Additional writings by people like Jefferson, Franklin, Madison, Adams all talk about virtue and religion being fundamental in good governance, and of the virtues of Christianity as a religion.

5) Things that contrasted with a Judean-Christian view of the world were not all that tolerated in colonial times – things like divorce, sodomy, pornography, being a few examples of this.

So, outside of those few, key facts, you might have an argument.

"An interesting idea, but only partially correct. Natural Selection only refers to outside agents influencing which genetic traits survive which fail. We are essentially 'natural selection' at this moment in the earth's history. Almost every species' existence depends on how it interacts with us, and through its interactions with us its traits change (cows are a big example).

Long story short, whether it is impossible in a lab, in a single experiment depends on what you are trying to prove. 'evolution' is a big grouping of theories, each of which requires independent experiments."

None of which have been done to any great conclusion. While I agree that there is more then one version of Evolution, you know as well as I that the Natural Selection crowd dominates this debate. And there very fact that there is dissent within the Evolution community, shows that there is no genuine proof that validates Evolution, just a bunch of scattered pieces that some people may *assume* go together, but until it can be recreated or observed in action, it's all just speculation. Speculation, therefore puts Evolution as a matter of belief, or faith. Thus, Evolution is on the same footing as a religion.

"'First, I’m not defending Intelligent Design.' Then don't bring it into the conversation. If you aren't defending it, then you just threw it out there as a red herring."

I wasn't. I was just pointing out that this is where the speculators of ID MAY have a point. I didn't say they DID have a point.

"No. If a scientist were to evolve something into something else in a lab, that would suggest that a species can evolve into another species in response to external environmental factors. This would in no way whatsoever support Intelligent Design. Why, you ask? Because Intelligent design first and foremost requires the existence of a diety of some sort. Before you can even THINK of suggesting a theory of intelligent design, you have to FIRST prove that there is something out there which would be the active designer. Without proof of a diety, you have no reason to make the leap to intelligent design."

Intelligent Design, from what little I know of it, emphasizes just that: an intelligence that formed a genetic design. It could be a deity, a man, or the green monster standing on the corner. But what is very clear about the concept is that randomness is not a part of the game. Part and parcel of doing an experiment to change a chimp into a man is that fact that conditions are purposely set to get a specific outcome by an intelligent force. If you want to call the little, bald guy with a white lab coat on a deity, then be my guest. But, when boiled down to the barest essence, changes from one species to another are not done by random cause and effect.

Like I said, this is from what little I know, and in some ways there is a certain logic to it.

"Again. difference goes back to the fact that there is REASON to speculate these theories in science, because there is DATA which suggests that these theories are on the right track. Your DATA for your entire religious belief, could also just as easily suggest that Sartre wrote the bible. You have not been able to come up with good data to support ANY religious belief. I can come up with data to support evolutiouary arguments."

Which may or may not be correct – this has yet to be proven, because the concept as a whole is unproven. Much of this argument is somewhat (and I kind of use that term loosely) based on the notion that data did not exist until it was uncovered. In fact whatever data that may or may not prove Evolution existed well before someone found it. And if that did exist, other data points also exist that have not yet been uncovered. And, as I stated before, proof of a concept validates that data that supports it. Just because you have data, does not mean the concept it correct.

Thus, until the concept is proven correct, it is a belief. Belief is the realm of religion.

"First, A donkey would never be proof. It is sterile. The proof (and I don't know if it exists) would be if the final species cannot mate with the ancestral species (while still maintaining its own species). Of course the issue would be that under most conditions, whatever would have caused the selection against the ancestral species would also have caused its extinction. As I said, we cannot do a directed recreation of the exact evolutionary process which has occurred. But doing that is not necesary to prove evolution itself. Hell we can observe the evolution of bacteria/viruses, but I wont use that as an example (too easy). You want something more complicated, you're just going to have to wait. I'll tell you what though, until it's proven, I suggest that you only use 'creationist approved' antibiotics... you know, stuff that worked on the very first bacterial infections. Because I wouldn't want you to compromise your beliefs by assuming that there has been any natural selection among microorganisms."

This would assume that antibiotics came about as a part of the Evolutionary process. Since evolution is not proven, I can only assume that there was a purpose behind the existence if antibiotics.

Secondly, if you know the Bible well enough, you know that antibiotics can be easily approved as bring something that is not in conflict with a religious doctrine.

But moreover, I take issue with this statement: "As I said, we cannot do a directed recreation of the exact evolutionary process which has occurred. But doing that is not necesary to prove evolution itself." Ok, let's stick to the antibiotics thing here, and take God out of it. Antibiotics may have actually existed a long time before we came along, as evidenced by some of the things that Ice Man they found in the Alps was carrying with him (one of them was a fungus that had some antibiotic properties). And in many folk and indigenous cures, molds and fungus were pretty standard in warding off infections. But that alone does not prove that antibiotics existed. Only when someone managed to observe the effect on bacteriological colonies, and then researched how these things worked, did antibiotics come into being (and that being stuff like penicillin). Only AFTER their effectiveness was proven could they be defined as antibiotics. And, in the case of antibiotics, this was something that was basically forgotten, and as the classic story of penicillin tells, was "rediscovered" by accident. But to say that because some molds seem to heal wounds a little better does not say that you can use them to end syphilis – that has to be proven before it can be true.

"Two different requests. Genetically converting an ape to a man is very possible. Just a lengthy experiment requiring the violation of a number of laws. Hell, I know your rightwing nuts would be against it, since every embryonic mistake would have to be aborted (and yes there would be many). Here's something I don't think you quite understand. I remember an experiment we did in Developmental Bio lab many years ago. In essence we were recreating a landmark experiment by a scientist regarding limb growth factors. In the experiment, we would cut a window in a fertilized chicken egg, find the 2mm embryonic chicken, and cut off a limb bud (basically a bump on the embryo). We would then open a second egg, and take that limb bud and graft it on to the second embryo (basically scrape the embryo and drop it on). If all the factors required for the development of a limb were contained in the limb bud, then the second chicken would have an extra wing/leg. Do you know how many things could go wrong in that experiment? The original scientist tried it 400 times before it worked, and yet succeeding ONCE proved the theory. Hell, in our class only one worked, and we knew exactly how it was supposed to work. EVEN IF YOU HAVE ALL THE TOOLS NECESSARY, AND KNOW EXACTLY HOW IT WILL GO, YOU NEED TO DO MULTIPLE TRIALS."

Ok, you want to know what basic difference between my challenge and your illustration? Your chicken wing experiment was done once already, and was - by your very words - repeatable. My challenge (as far as I'm aware) has not, and is not.

It's a real long stretch between saying something can be done, and actually doing it.

"EVOLVING an ape into a man would require the complete recreation of the entire earth over the entire period of time. If I asked you to recreate Waterloo, you'd probably say thats impossible too. Does that mean it didn't happen?"

One did happen, and was documented as having happened. There were firsthand observations of Waterloo. There are still artifacts of things that were in Waterloo. There is nothing that documented Evolution, not have there been any first-hand observations of Evolutionary change. One is creating something that has a long trail of documentation that was spawned from it's inception, the other has virtually no documentation other than what's been discovered (and there's a lot more yet to discover). Big, big difference in examples.

"Oh, and just because I continue to argue with you on this, don't actually assume that means your arguments are good. Just means you like to keep repeating them."

Because you fail to acknowledge that just because there is data that points to something, doesn’t mean that "something" exists. It has to be proven to exist before that data is shown to be relevant.

"I'm not sure where you're even going with this. I suggested we abolish the term marriage, and just have the legal definition be 'civil union'. That would still be a legal process, basically the same as acquiring a marriage license right now. Don't see how your little rant plays into it."

It's how something on which you and I may agree can be turned on it’s head when someone else doesn't agree with us. You and I seem to acknowledge that a consentual relationship between two adults (our difference in opinion is that I further define it as a man and a woman) constitutes a "marriage", and that is the BASIC definition that you and I are using here. But the original concept of "gay marriage" was so that gays would have the same "rights" and "privledges" that married heterosexuals have. Ok, so let's say, for the sake of argument, that you and I come to an agreement on that.

The next people to complain will be those that don't want a recognized marriage at all, but want to have all the same "rights" and "privledges" that married couples have. And they'll use the EXACT same arguments that are used right now to frame the present debate over "gay marriage".

Slippery slope.

"What about stupid married couples, who don't follow through with wills right away?"

As it stands right now, will or no will, everything gets thrown into probate court. This however, depends on what state you live in. If you set up trusts, and appoint an executor, when someone dies, the executor still maintains control. Needless to say, before my great uncle and aunt, and one of my grandmothers died, all of their money was thrown into trusts. So, if I die, and let's say that a bank account was in my name only, that would need to go to a probate court.

Granted, I'm not a financial genius here. But I know my dad is putting virtually everything he has into trusts and appointing my brother as an executor. Consequently, he's also the executor of my grandmother's estate, which is also mostly bound up into trusts. It's a messy, messy business.

"If they are straight, they are generally protected because of the recognized relationship. If they are gay, they aren't. Are stupid straight people somehow more important than stupid gay people? Then there is the issue of health insurance. I believe companies are still allowed to provide health insurance for straight married couple spouses, but not gay. I think the UW here lost a professor because the state insurance plan wouldn't cover his gay spouse. So, it is unequal. Interesting."

While you might have an argument for public sector employment, private sector employment is pretty much "at will". If they don't like how you part your hair, you get fired. And if they don't want to provide insurance to your wife and/or partner, they don't. I've seen (and have actually worked at a company) companies that ONLY provided catastrophic insurance for me. There was no spousal or family plan. But these days, a lot of companies provide "partner" health insurance, or as an alternate you can take on the insurance burden for yourself, and go with a cut rate plan, and have your "partner" go on as a dependant. There is no restriction in this, and regardless of how you have sex, your money is still green.

"It will happen because people can't seem to make decisions rationally."

As I've said before, rationale (and rational choices) are relative. What may be rational for you, is not rational for someone else.

"Frighteningly enough, I blame the christian right. This is just a mental exercise (please don't turn this into a silly argument as well), but think of how most of the arguments against gay marriage run from the christian right. "Its wrong because it says so in the bible" (I'm boiling the argument down for brevity sake). Well, that is unfortunately using the bible as a serious crutch in an argument. What happens when that bible is taken away? Hypothetically, lets assume that gay marriage is approved nationwide, because the bible is a bad argument against it. It actually gives those groups with questionable arguments (child/bestiality) more power, simply because half of the christian right's argument was based on religious belief. Suddenly, the argument isn't focused on the relevant parts of the issue, but on whether or not one can legislate religion (which shouldn't even be an issue in child/horse marrying)."

Your problem with this is that those you call the "Christian Right" have both founded this country, and have been in charge for a good 200+ years. And while you may not like the Bible, it is a main source document for the very rights you enjoy. People seem to forget that slavery was not actually an issue of "civil rights", but a basic religious dispute between people who wanted to keep it (the slave holders) and the people that wanted to get rid of it (the abolitionists). The slave-holders used the notion that black people were not "men" in the conventional sense, and that a specific passage of Genesis – the one where one of the sons saw Noah's nakedness – gave whites (or at the furthest end of the definition: non Africans) the authority to rule blacks. Abolitionists saw this as an outright conflict with Christian teachings, the main points of Levitican law.

The fact that slaves benefited the south's economy cemented slavery in the south.

The Bible is a HUGE portion of this nation's heritage. You cannot easily dismiss it because it doesn't fit your ideology.

Consequently, the Bible (or at least the portions that matter) has no one religion that can lay claim to it. Muslims reference may different portions of the Bible (fitted to their religion, of course), as do Jews (Old Testament), and Christians. And much of the morality that both you and I subscribe to is based off of a semi-puritanical view of the world. I know you'll disagree with this, but then again think about what you consider right and wrong, and contrast that to the many Biblical principles I've highlighted in out little argument here. You may very well discover that you have far more in common with what the Bible advocates, than not.

"'Well, that depends. Should an entire society pay for the misdeeds of a minority?' Yes."

And what if a good portion of that society was against said misdeed from the very beginning? They are to be held accountable?

"'Secondly, 'intelligence' and 'rationalization' are relative concepts. Some people think that it’s a smart thing to do female circumcisions.' I agree. Hell, it may be a smart thing. I don't think its smart, but no one knows everything. Maybe I'm missing something."

Well it looks like we kinda agree on something else.

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

.....what'eva

jpotts
Friday, June 8, 2007 5:27:00 PM
Man, I just don't feel the support from other users on this board over some real debate over the issues...

I'm hurt.

Don't worry guys, there's always a potrential limit as to how much a web browser can display at one time. Eventually victor808 and I will hit it. Be patient.

HockeyDad
Friday, June 8, 2007 6:28:00 PM
I can't properly participate because I am in shock and awe over the Paris Hilton travesty of justice.

...but your apology is accepted.

victor808
Monday, June 18, 2007 11:29:00 AM
Potts,

I have a bit of time, and better get to this before it disappears.

On the "education" issue. We were looking at broken down data already. There were two categories which Ds won, post-graduate and I believe college graduate (but was too close to really be a 'win'... it was a synthesis category anyway). We tried to push Rug for a definition of "educated" so we could properly apply the data, but he refused to respond to that question. Since the line of "educated" never was set, I had to create a method where each level of education could be compared (I chose years, but anyone could have suggested something else). If rug had just said "high school graduate is educated" then the line could have been set there, and the number of people in each group (D&R) could have been compared. R would have won that, but would have to argue why he chose that set point.

Without his input as to where the set point of education is, we were left with the second method (years applied to each category so that we can combine the information in each category). This allowed us to get a "years education per person" for R&D. With this method, D's won, but really not by a lot. I was still willing to say that the entire theory was bogus. You wanted to "factor in population" which was unfortunately bad math. by factoring population you took "years D education/number of D's" and then multiplied it by "Number of D's/Number of R's" (this was your normalization factor). As any 4th grader knows, when you do that, the # D's factors out. This leaves you with "years D education/number of Rs" and compared that with "years R education/number of Rs". This is essentially the same as "years R education" vs "years D education". Basically you did math to get back to the original, pre averaging comparison (total years of education in each group), but your mathematical manipulations made it look to people as if you actually were comparing any sort of averages. You weren't.

Now, about that time, I found a quote by rug from earlier in the thread that said something like "on average..." so, through no fault of your own, you lost on about 5 different levels. Ultimately, your math was bad. Bad math. I cannot stress how bad your math was. A bad representation of bad math. Bad. But, even if your math weren't bad, you would have been constrained to an average anyway. The whole thing could have been solved if rug had just stepped up and defended himself anyway.

"Actually, in Old Testament writings, there is no "afterlife" – that's strictly... ...Thus, they are "data points". Just as stereotypical behavior provides a foundation for many of the sciences like psychology ("stereotypical" in that it follows a pattern and can be defined). "

Doesn't matter if your datapoints are used to found laws, or used to govern human behavior. That still leaves the fundamental premise of your religion (a god) exposed. This argument is whether there is data to support a religious belief. Right now you're simply treating the bible like Sun Tzu's Art of War, and trying to keep the "invisible green monster in the corner" separate. Unfortunately, you are not allowed to do that. Your religion comes as a unit.

"And, again, I can take data that is completely unrelated to, say, mitochondria and use it to "prove" something that is untrue. Data is only relevant or true AFTER something is proven, not before. One justifies the other. Consider it a "circle of life" thing… "

Data is always relevant. The existence of mitochondrial DNA is true and relevant. It could be applied (falsely as well) to any number of arguments. But the strength of the theory/argument is whether there is consistency. There is consistency in the evolution argument because multiple data points support each other, and do not contradict. You still have to provide a SINGLE data point in support of a religious belief, let alone multiple corresponding data points.

". The whole premise of this argument is that the Founding Fathers did not draw on the pillars of their religions, but instead incorporated good ideas as a part of the framework of this nation. The problem with that argument is manifold:

1) Virtually all of them were Fundamentalist Christians, or would so be considered by today's standards.

2) It's really clear from the history and writings of people like Jefferson, Madison, and Mason that they were heavily influenced by John Locke.

3) The three main works that influenced the Founding Fathers are deeply rooted in the Bible and Biblical principles (one of them starts out with Adam's relationship to God and the world around him).

4) Additional writings by people like Jefferson, Franklin, Madison, Adams all talk about virtue and religion being fundamental in good governance, and of the virtues of Christianity as a religion.

5) Things that contrasted with a Judean-Christian view of the world were not all that tolerated in colonial times – things like divorce, sodomy, pornography, being a few examples of this. "

Circumstantial evidence. By itself, this would suggest that the founding fathers would have wanted a religious country, but you are purposely neglecting statements which contradict your argument. Basically, 1) it doesn't matter what their personal belief is; 2)doesn't matter what their influence is; 3)doesn't matter if they believe that christianity is virtuous; 4) doesn't matter if the laws they drafted were consistent with a religion.... IF they specifically state: "their legislature should make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof, thus building a wall of separation between Church and State" or "Strongly guarded . . . is the separation between religion and government in the Constitution of the United States,"

These are pretty clear, and unless you can come up with an alternate interpretation of these quotes, they trump their personal religious beliefs etc.

"None of which have been done to any great conclusion. While I agree ...... matter of belief, or faith. Thus, Evolution is on the same footing as a religion. "

Again, you are lumping every single definition of "belief" in one category, just for fun. I believe that when I get on the plane tomorrow it will not crash. Why? Because while there is a chance that it may crash, the evidence suggests that it is likely it will not crash. I also believe that when I meet Mila Jojovich (not that I have any plans to any time soon) she will take one look at me and immediately decide I am the love of her life and want to run off to an island with me. I have no evidence to suggest that this may be true, but I sure as hell believe it.

Do you think those two "beliefs" are on the same footing? If you do, you have very poor critical reasoning skills. You are simply lumping scientific theories in with religious beliefs because it is an easy tactic to try to argue for the inclusion of religion (no data points) in situations where science(data points) is used, such as policy or education.

"Intelligent Design, from what little I know of it, emphasizes just that: an intelligence ...down to the barest essence, changes from one species to another are not done by random cause and effect. "

Right and wrong. ID does not specify the intelligence in their literature. However, you have to specify the intelligence if you are going to create a theory. Keep in mind, if you use "lab worker" as the intelligence behind the design, you have to some argue that there were "lab workers" present on earth to initiate and control evolution. You have to show some data/evidence that there was something there... alien space ship, "made by god", invisible green monster droppings...

"Which may or may not be correct – this has yet to be proven, because ... just because you have data, does not mean the concept it correct"

Consistency. When new data is identified, the fact that it reinforces the existing theory, rather than contradicting it, strengthens the theory. This is well beyond the "belief" you attribute to religion, which has no datapoints, let alone external reinforcement of data.

"This would assume that antibiotics came about as a part of the Evolutionary process. Since evolution is not proven, I can only assume that there was a purpose behind the existence if antibiotics.

Secondly, if you know the Bible well enough, you know that antibiotics can be easily approved as bring something that is not in conflict with a religious doctrine. "

I dont' think you understand the point, or got the reference (it was a berke breathed comic reference). First, the antibiotics have not evolved (as such), the bacteria has evolved. Because of the external selection against bacteria which are susceptible to pennicillin (natural selection) we run across more and more strains of bacteria which are resistant to penn. Because of that, we utilize different antibiotics (developed by scientists). The question is, if you don't believe in evolution, then the antibiotic resistant bacteria MUST not exist. Therefore, you should only use the original pennicillin (bad idea). To do otherwise would be working on the theory that the bacteria has evolved.

I dont' think your tirade on pennicillin discovery makes much sense. Obviously the antibacterial chemical has always existed. Your point? many medicines are simply extracts of existing, known chemicals. "But to say that because some molds seem to heal wounds a little better does not say that you can use them to end syphilis – that has to be proven before it can be true. " Wrong. it is always true. It has to be proven before it can be known to be true. The truth always existed (because the following data always existed: that some mold kills bacteria, that syphilis is a bacterial infection etc etc). Your point made no sense here.

"Ok, you want to know what basic difference between my challenge and your illustration? Your chicken wing experiment was done once already, and was - by your very words - repeatable. My challenge (as far as I'm aware) has not, and is not.

It's a real long stretch between saying something can be done, and actually doing it. "

Again... as I've said before. If I told you I could transcribe the entire Encyclopedia by hand, would you say "that's impossible"? I don't think you would... because it obviously can be done. I can write. I can read. I can acquire an encyclopedia. .... Is it possible I'll die before completing it? yes. Is it possible I won't get funding to support me while I do this full time? yes. does that mean it cant' be done?? No. Lets try turning this around.

Give me one good reason WHY the plan I laid out for you cannot be accomplished. "Its too complicated" is not a proper answer.

Waterloo - " One is creating something that has a long trail of documentation that was spawned from it's inception, the other has virtually no documentation other than what's been discovered (and there's a lot more yet to discover). Big, big difference in examples. "

Eh. We all know the statement "history was written by the winners". You "believe" that the items which have been written are true. You "believe" that people have properly identified artifacts. Does that make the existence of waterloo "religious"? No. This goes back to the differences in "belief" Evidence suggests waterloo occurred. corraborations between artifacts etc. If you think evolution is on the same footing as religion, then so is wateroo.

Marriage -

I think I see where you are going. Unfortunately, you are missing another critical point. In order to acquire these rights, a couple must become legally identified as a couple ("civil union", whatever). Any couple can do that. So what? A couple wants the same rights and priv's as a civil union, they go to the clerk of court and get a license. If someone doesn't want to be a recognized "civil union" then there is no record of their legal/financial status and no reason for them to receive any of the benefits. That argument requires that legal status be given without any paper trial, which is essentially impossible (or at minimum unwise). Again.... a slippery slope exists at EVERY argument. If we are unable to recognize when an argument is being made using irrelevant points, we get what we deserve.

"While you might have an argument for public sector employment, private sector employment is pretty much "at will". ....."

Yes, money is always green. Public sector IS an issue. Not the only one though. If an employer has an insurance policy which covers workers and spouses, then two workers of different sexuality are going to essentially get different compensation. The only way for a gay worker to rectify this situation would be to actually make a fuss about it and point out their status as a homosexual with a live in partner. If they were married, then there would be no reason for their private business to become part of the workplace if they didn't want it to be.

"As I've said before, rationale (and rational choices) are relative. What may be rational for you, is not rational for someone else. "

Logic is always logic. When arguments are no longer applying logic, with a clear idea of what the RELEVANT facts are... we get bad decisions.

".......You may very well discover that you have far more in common with what the Bible advocates, than not. "

Not my point. I'm not arguing the influence of the bible itself. I'm stating that those who rely solely on the bible ultimately set the argument up for a "slippery slope" situation, because they have already taken logic and rational decision making out of the equation.

"And what if a good portion of that society was against said misdeed from the very beginning? They are to be held accountable? "

I'm not sure where you are even going with this. For fun, lets say "yes".

victor808
Monday, June 18, 2007 12:39:00 PM
Oh.. and we will crash cbid somehow... 🙂
victor808
Wednesday, June 27, 2007 11:22:00 AM
Didja forsake me on this on Pottsie?
jpotts
Wednesday, June 27, 2007 11:36:00 AM
^ You know, you're ruining my fun.

I was going to wait a few weeks before adding my comments.

Bastige!

victor808
Wednesday, June 27, 2007 11:41:00 AM
No problem... just wanted to make sure you knew it was your turn to crash the server! 🙂
jpotts
Wednesday, June 27, 2007 12:16:00 PM
I actually missed your last long response...I've noticed that the link color returns to the "never accessed" color on the web browser if it hasn't been clicked in a long time. I usually look at the colors of the link titles to see what I have read before I add comments. So I think that's why I missed it the first time. Then, when I got bored waiting for a reponse, I went searching.
HockeyDad
Wednesday, June 27, 2007 6:57:00 PM
I forgot what this thread is about.
8trackdisco
Wednesday, June 27, 2007 7:03:00 PM
This glory hound is STILL dead?

Where's a good Paris Hilton story when you need it.

Oddboggle
Wednesday, June 27, 2007 10:48:00 PM
I wonder what Harpo Marx would say about all this...

Oddboggle

jpotts
Friday, June 29, 2007 10:17:00 AM
Victor808:

"On the 'education' issue."

If you want to keep picking the "you can't factor in the population" scab that's fine. I showed you the test where you had 100 PHDs compared to 100,000 High School level people, and in that instance the PHDs won out because, when you applied a number of years to each education grade and then took the average across the population, it shows that 100 people were more educated than 100,000. Where this is incorrect is that education is cumulative across a population, where some may have all the same level of education in different areas, say carpentry and electronics. Thus, one skill set compensates for the absence of another across a large population.

What you fail to recognize is that when NOT compensated for education, your proposed averaging of years education falls apart when the applied dataset is taken to extremes. In my method, by factoring in the difference in populations, if one side has a very low number of people with a high average of years education, the population discrepancy evens out the final result. If you have the exact same populations, but one has a higher average number of years per person, then the result reflects that. Finally if you have a low number of people on one side with a very low average number of years education, the adjustment for population drives the final result even lower than averaging. Just plain taking the averages does not affect the numbers one way or the other, which you even admitted in this original debate was an inaccurate representation of the final analysis.

Furthermore, when I developed the method, I was not looking to make one side or the other win to prove a point. What I did was apply the same test to your proposed method to see if the resultant numbers made any sort of logical sense. Using straight averages didn't, factoring population did. It just so happened that the results of this evening value proved rugrunner right.

Had we stayed with my initial analysis, where I broke down each level of education and provided a cumulative results over different combinations, democrats would have still come out behind, winning only 2 of something like 7 different valuations.

Then again, this is one of the reasons why I generally don't argue statistics because you can make the numbers pretty much say anything you want by applying whatever test one deems fit. And, if someone doesn't like the result, they can say your process is "unsound".

My process isn't unsound. If the populations match up exact, the one with the higher average number of years still wins. Unfortunately, there were less democrats in one population than the other. Too bad.

"Doesn't matter if your datapoints are used to found laws, or used to govern human behavior. That still leaves the fundamental premise of your religion (a god) exposed. This argument is whether there is data to support a religious belief. Right now you're simply treating the bible like Sun Tzu's Art of War, and trying to keep the "invisible green monster in the corner" separate. Unfortunately, you are not allowed to do that. Your religion comes as a unit."

It's funny, but you keep arguing MY religion. I'm arguing religion in a general sense. Take God out of the equation. I've said before that there are religions that have NO God, god, or gods, which literally undercuts your premise…and I know this.

Secondly, and you somehow fail to acknowledge this, but if a theory based on datapoints ends up being wrong, then those datapoints essentially never existed. The datapoints themselves may physically exist, but they do not apply in any way, shape, or form to the theory. So, it is as if these datapoints never existed in the first place. Ergo, until something is proved, regardless of whatever "datapoints" you point at, it is a matter of belief, and on the same footing as religion. Now, you can call this "science" if you like, because these things can be "studied". However, the Roman Catholic Church has people who "study" miracles, which are themselves datapoints because they literally fit your criteria: observed behavior, physical evidence, and so on. To me, your concept of "science" semantically sounds more like a "religion".

"Data is always relevant."

WRONG! Big, big error in that statement. Data that is incorrectly applied or used to "prove" a specific point is irrelevant. I cannot say the sky is orange, and then point to mitochondrial DNA (to use an absolutely absurd example) as "data". The two basically have nothing to do with one another.

"The existence of mitochondrial DNA is true and relevant."

Whether or not the data is relevant can ONLY be determined after something is proven. Evolution is not proven. Man-made Global Warming is not proven. Mitochondria "evolving" from bacteria is not proven. Period.

"It could be applied (falsely as well) to any number of arguments. But the strength of the theory/argument is whether there is consistency. There is consistency in the evolution argument because multiple data points support each other, and do not contradict. You still have to provide a SINGLE data point in support of a religious belief, let alone multiple corresponding data points."

You can have one or more data points that are wrong. Just because they're bent to fit a particular form doesn't mean that they were originally a piece of the puzzle being put together. Again – and you seem hung up on thinking something exists because there's "data" to support it – data is not shown to be correct until the theory to which it is applied can be proven. Generally, theories can only be proven until all of the exceptions are accounted for. And, as you've said before, it very well may be impossible to prove Evolution because of all the variables involved.

So, this stuff (regardless of data) is little more than speculation and belief given the distinguished monikor of "science".

". The whole premise of this argument is that the Founding Fathers did not draw on the pillars of their religions, but instead incorporated good ideas as a part of the framework of this nation. The problem with that argument is manifold:

1) Virtually all of them were Fundamentalist Christians, or would so be considered by today's standards.

2) It's really clear from the history and writings of people like Jefferson, Madison, and Mason that they were heavily influenced by John Locke.

3) The three main works that influenced the Founding Fathers are deeply rooted in the Bible and Biblical principles (one of them starts out with Adam's relationship to God and the world around him).

4) Additional writings by people like Jefferson, Franklin, Madison, Adams all talk about virtue and religion being fundamental in good governance, and of the virtues of Christianity as a religion.

5) Things that contrasted with a Judean-Christian view of the world were not all that tolerated in colonial times – things like divorce, sodomy, pornography, being a few examples of this. "

"Circumstantial evidence."

You mean, beside the writings of many of the Founding Farthers?

"By itself, this would suggest that the founding fathers would have wanted a religious country, but you are purposely neglecting statements which contradict your argument."

No I'm not. I'm aware of numerous writing that seemingly contradict my assertions. Problem is the actions of MANY of these supposedly "anti-religion" Founding Fathers like Thomas Jefferson and Madison while they were in office…like federally funded Bible distribution programs.

Most people point to about three of 4 important members of the Founding Fathers who were allegedly Deists. While all nice and fine, there were more than 4 people in founding the country, constructing the Declaration of Independence, framing the Constitution, and so on. They were overwhelmingly Christians.

And for each quote you pull out that identifies these people as non-religions, I can pull out a paragraph that identifies them as so.

"IF they specifically state: 'their legislature should make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof…'"

This is from the Bill of Rights, what was meant to LIMIT government interference into religious matters. It stops the government from CREATING a new or state-sponsored religion, and it prevents them from interfering in things like worship.

However, considering that you very rights you hold dear are founded in the more than one religion(specifically Judism and Christianity), this does not apply to our argument.

"'…thus building a wall of separation between Church and State'"

First, this came from a letter written by then president Jefferson to a Baptist minister. There was a concern that one religion and/or branch of the Baptist religion was going to be able to legislate their particular flavor of Christianity out of existence…which is EXACTLY what the religious amendment to the Bill of Rights was meant to prohibit. However, both Jefferson and Madison, people supposedly die-hard advocates of a "secular" government did not have an issue with bodies like Congress to elect a Chaplin to offer a prayer before each session (a practice that continues to this very day). Madison argued FOR this practice. This is a BLATANT contradiction to everything that secularists propose about both Jefferson and Madison.

And, again, you assume that the religious teachings that these people absorbed since their birth had absolutely NO effect on their outlook. You read their writings, you find that this is patently false.

"Again, you are lumping every single definition of "belief" in one category, just for fun. I believe that when I get on the plane tomorrow it will not crash. Why? Because while there is a chance that it may crash, the evidence suggests that it is likely it will not crash. I also believe that when I meet Mila Jojovich (not that I have any plans to any time soon) she will take one look at me and immediately decide I am the love of her life and want to run off to an island with me. I have no evidence to suggest that this may be true, but I sure as hell believe it."

Planes crash all the time. You can believe that a plane won't crash, and it very well may not. But there is the distinct possibility that it could. So until that plane touches down safely, and you depart without harm, your belief is simply that: a belief. It may be a pretty secure belief, but it's still unproven until you arrive safely to where you’re going.

As far as Mila Jojovich is concerned…well, far be it from me to shatter any illusions you might have. Just have her keep saying "Multipass!" LOL!

"Do you think those two 'beliefs' are on the same footing?"

Until they're proven, yes.

"Right and wrong. ID does not specify the intelligence in their literature. However, you have to specify the intelligence if you are going to create a theory. Keep in mind, if you use 'lab worker' as the intelligence behind the design, you have to some argue that there were 'lab workers' present on earth to initiate and control evolution. You have to show some data/evidence that there was something there... alien space ship, 'made by god', invisible green monster droppings..."

If the green monster on the corner is invisible now, how do you know he's there in the first place?

"Consistency. When new data is identified, the fact that it reinforces the existing theory, rather than contradicting it, strengthens the theory. This is well beyond the 'belief' you attribute to religion, which has no datapoints, let alone external reinforcement of data."

And, as I've pointed out, if the data points only fit the theory buy mere coincidence, they do not prove anything as it relates to the theory at hand.

"I dont' think you understand the point, or got the reference (it was a berke breathed comic reference)."

I no longer get the daily newspaper paper anymore, mainly because they no longer printed "Outland".

"First, the antibiotics have not evolved (as such), the bacteria has evolved."

Antibiotics are generally taken from molds. There are some exceptions to this. Molds, if you believe the theory of Evolution, evolved. Secondly, the fact that antibiotics was not an evolutionary creature was exactly my point.

"Because of that, we utilize different antibiotics (developed by scientists). The question is, if you don't believe in evolution, then the antibiotic resistant bacteria MUST not exist. Therefore, you should only use the original pennicillin (bad idea). To do otherwise would be working on the theory that the bacteria has evolved."

Antibiotics are essentially a poison. They just happen to be more effective against bacteria than they are people. People develop resistances, tolerances, and immunities from poisons all the time. So are these people "evolved"?

"I dont' think your tirade on pennicillin discovery makes much sense. Obviously the antibacterial chemical has always existed. Your point? many medicines are simply extracts of existing, known chemicals. "But to say that because some molds seem to heal wounds a little better does not say that you can use them to end syphilis – that has to be proven before it can be true. " Wrong. it is always true. It has to be proven before it can be known to be true. The truth always existed (because the following data always existed: that some mold kills bacteria, that syphilis is a bacterial infection etc etc). Your point made no sense here."

My response made no sense because your initial argument made no sense. To assert that Christians that don't believe in antibiotics because they don't believe in evolution is just as silly as my response. Antibiotics are chemical compounds, no living creatures. They are initially derived from living creatures, but they themselves are not living.

Again... as I've said before. If I told you I could transcribe the entire Encyclopedia by hand, would you say 'that's impossible'? I don't think you would... because it obviously can be done. I can write. I can read. I can acquire an encyclopedia. .... Is it possible I'll die before completing it? yes. Is it possible I won't get funding to support me while I do this full time? yes. does that mean it cant' be done?? No. Lets try turning this around.

Give me one good reason WHY the plan I laid out for you cannot be accomplished. 'Its too complicated' is not a proper answer."

First, there are LOTS of impossibilities in our existence. Matter cannot be created or destroyed, but only change forms is one such example.

What you did was a massive dodge of an obvious fact, and it's really clear. Again, do the experiment if we know so much about Evolution.

"Eh. We all know the statement 'history was written by the winners'."

Which is an obvious reinforcement that it existed in the first place: there was a winner who was able to write about it.

"You 'believe' that the items which have been written are true. You 'believe' that people have properly identified artifacts. Does that make the existence of waterloo 'religious'? No. This goes back to the differences in 'belief' Evidence suggests waterloo occurred. corraborations between artifacts etc. If you think evolution is on the same footing as religion, then so is wateroo."

Nice try attempting to turn my arguments on their head.

People were around to document the events of Waterloo. People observed Waterloo. People died in Waterloo. There is a mountain of evidence – physical, allegorical, observational, and so on - that shows that Waterloo existed. Now, you can assume that the people who documented the events of Waterloo were liars, and that the grave markers of the dead soldiers there are fabricated. That's your business. But, unlike evolution, there is far more evidence that Waterloo existed, happened, and that the French were defeated than there is that Evolution actually occurred. And much of this is because of proportion. Waterloo happened over a few days, and in a period of time when people could record the events of it. Evolution supposedly occurred over a HUGE time-span, with virtually none of it observed.

Now, I could take your argument and turn it on its head by saying that Bigfoot exists because we have hair samples, foot impressions, photographic observations, sound recordings, and person observations. Yet most established scientists balk at the existence of Bigfoot, and ask for more evidence to prove its existence conclusively.

This blade cuts both ways, you know.

I think Colonel Steve Austin fighting Bigfoot is evidence enough for some.

"I think I see where you are going. Unfortunately, you are missing another critical point. In order to acquire these rights, a couple must become legally identified as a couple ('civil union', whatever). Any couple can do that. So what? A couple wants the same rights and priv's as a civil union, they go to the clerk of court and get a license. If someone doesn't want to be a recognized 'civil union' then there is no record of their legal/financial status and no reason for them to receive any of the benefits. That argument requires that legal status be given without any paper trial, which is essentially impossible (or at minimum unwise). Again.... a slippery slope exists at EVERY argument. If we are unable to recognize when an argument is being made using irrelevant points, we get what we deserve."

In order to identify something as irrelevant, you have to have a definition to compare it against. I know what I put forth SOUNDS silly, but it only appears that way because there is a defined notion by you and I what a union or "marriage" is. However, with people always wanting to redefine everything so that they can claim some benefit from it, every time you redefine something, it opens it up for a further definition. Thus producing a "slippery slope".

My whole issue is that people are pushing for "gay marriage" for its "benefits". However, when you realize that these "benefits" are available in alternative channels, it undercuts the initial premise.

"Yes, money is always green. Public sector IS an issue. Not the only one though. If an employer has an insurance policy which covers workers and spouses, then two workers of different sexuality are going to essentially get different compensation. The only way for a gay worker to rectify this situation would be to actually make a fuss about it and point out their status as a homosexual with a live in partner. If they were married, then there would be no reason for their private business to become part of the workplace if they didn't want it to be."

I'm missing the point you're trying to make here.

"Logic is always logic. When arguments are no longer applying logic, with a clear idea of what the RELEVANT facts are... we get bad decisions."

Logic in the classic, school-room sense is "logic." However, what is and is not relevant, especially in a fairly complex issue, is relative. Just as what's "good" and "bad" are relative. Regardless of what you think, virtually all people make choices based on "good" and "bad". You can dress it up in "logic" all you like, but the impulse behind a decision is based off of morality.

"Not my point. I'm not arguing the influence of the bible itself. I'm stating that those who rely solely on the bible ultimately set the argument up for a 'slippery slope' situation, because they have already taken logic and rational decision making out of the equation."

If that's the case, you can take "relevant information" and "logic" to conclude that only a man and woman who are both fertile can marry. All others cannot. Because the prime focus of sex is procreation, and the point of pair-bonding is for the raising of children. All other considerations are irrelevant.

Be careful where you go with this. You're coming close to undercutting your own argument.

"I'm not sure where you are even going with this. For fun, lets say 'yes'."

You know what? Let's drop this. I can't remember where the hell I was going with this now.

I'm out on vacation all next week. Enjoy.

cbc812
Friday, June 29, 2007 10:42:00 AM
^#233

HD - It was about Jerry Falwell.

Update - He's still dead. He and Saddam are roomies.

victor808
Wednesday, July 4, 2007 7:30:00 PM
Okay Pottsie,

I'm sitting outside, bored out of my thick skull, might as well tackle this.

Education:

You seem to think that your discovery that a small, highly educated population will have a higher average than a large diversly educated population is important.. It isn't. That's the nature of averages. Doesn't matter if the democratic party consisted of one person with 50 PhDs, and the republican party consisted of 5 people with 11 PhDs... the Dem's would have a higher average education. That's what AVERAGE means. I don't criticize you for being wrong, you were stuck with the limitations rug set on the statement (he stated that republicans were, on average, better educated)... I'm criticizing you for not understanding the concept behind an average.

Your attempt to weight the two groups with the population of one group made it NO LONGER AN AVERAGE. Doesn't matter if you didnt' know what the answer would be before doing the exercise... the exercise itself was incorrect because the final numbers are "years education/Rep pop". When you are comparing two groups with the same denominator, you are ONLY comparing the numerator. So, in essence, with your mathematical manipulations you went right back to the beginning, comparing total years of education of the two groups. This is just as disengenious, because you can do the same population manipulations with this. Is a group of 100 people, each with one year of education, more educated than one person with 99 years of education?

It is VERY important to know exactly what you are saying with the numbers. Rug specified AVERAGE, I gave AVERAGE NUMBER OF YEARS PER PERSON.

Your other method (the original method involving population buckets) was perfectly valid. Since it was a category method however, there really is no way of achieving an average. I seem to recall asking Rug to specify a level at which people were "educated" so that we could use that method... However, he was reluctant to do so. If he had offered a category up, then of course the conversation would have taken a completely different turn. It's funny, we were/are basically arguing based on a set of rules a third party is unwilling/unable to define... But, my problem was NOT with your category method, hell, my problem isn't even with the "education argument" my problem is with your bad math in the above paragraph. 🙂

"My process isn't unsound. "

Yes it is. As I stated before. 1 Dem with 99 years of education vs 100 Reps with 1 year of education (they completed 1st grade). On average, Dem has 99 years/person, Rep has 1 year/person. Your method: dem has 0.99years of ed/Rep person; Rep has 1yr/Rep person. Your method would argue that the republicans have a higher "weighted average" (I put in quotes, because it is not a weighted average). What you fail to realize is that you are just comparing total years, you've just shifted it by 2 decimal places.

"Take God out of the equation"

I am arguing your religion because it is the most directly relevant here, just as we are arguing Evolution because it is the most directly relevant scientific theory. Secondly, we are arguing the concept of "belief" a religion that has no "belief" or "faith" is not relevant to the argument anyway. The religions that DO have an element of belief (belief in enlightenment, heaven/hell, god, allah, whatever) become nothing more than traditions when you take that element out. So, you cannot take god out of the equation, thankyouverymuch.

On datapoints.

Okay.. you seem to think that data disappears with the theory. WRONG.

Lets look at this. Datapoint: Mitochondria have separate DNA from the person. DNA which does divide during normal cell meiosis/mitosis.

Theory: People evolved from simpler creatures. Existence of mitochondrial DNA in all creatures, down to eukaryotes, suggests that it may have originally been parasitic bacteria which has integrated completely into our being.

Okay.. for a moment lets say that god comes down and says 'evolution is wrong', I did it all.

Does that erase the datapoint? Nope. The data still exists. Mitochondria STILL have separate DNA. Wow.

I'm not surprised you had a bit of trouble with this, because you have been having trouble with the concept of an actual datapoint anyway. The data is NEVER DEPENDANT ON THE THEORY. It must ALWAYS be that the theory is dependant on the data.

"Data that is incorrectly applied or used to "prove" a specific point is irrelevant."

No. A very interesting point is that the data actually MUST be accounted for regardless of the theory. Any theory which is to compete with the theory must also account for the data. Ex. Evolution has bone evidence. If you are going to argue that god created everything, then there must be some way to account for the data that has already been discovered. And yes, the church just throws up a little smokescreen "god created it to confuse us" or some tripe like that... but that's not even worth dignifying with a response.

"until something is proved, regardless of whatever "datapoints" you point at, it is a matter of belief, and on the same footing as religion."

So, here is the crux of the problem. I think I've figured out what the sticking point is. You like to use VERY VAGUE WORDS. Belief. That's a vague word. Belief can be applied to anything where there is between 0% and 99.99% certainty. Data is what increases certainty. With zero data at all, you have zero certainty. If I tell you that the moon will begin accellerating at the earth in one hour, you'd ask me for data. If I have no data, you'd have zero certainty in my statement. That could be called a belief. On the other hand I could tell you that the sun will become visible here in Madison at approximately 5:whatever in the morning tomorrow. Since we have data tracking the earths movement right now, as well as the movement of all other significant planetary bodies, as well as a wealth of data from previous days, we can give that a 99% certainty of belief. But there is always that infentisimally small chance that the moon will actually start accellerating in an hour, strike the earth and alter it's rotation to cause the sun to be visible at an earlier/later time (and our death, but that's not important to this).

These both fit under the technical umbrella "belief", but they are significantly different concepts. One has data, one has none. In general terminology, belief is used when there is little or no data, such as religions or fantasies of Mila Jojovich. When there is data to support a theory, it is called SPECULATION.

Now, I have offered some data to support the theory of evolution. Does it put it in the 99% category? Probably not. But it DOES put it in a category significantly higher than "the moon will start crashing into the earth in an hour". Because there is ACTUAL DATA (as we've gone over time and time again) a more appropriate term is speculation. It is a scientific theory, with data to support it. ANY other theory which wishes to compete with this theory MUST also take into account the data which exists (bone evidence, mitochondria etc).

"and you seem hung up on thinking something exists because there's "data" to support it "

Okay.... I'll just let that one hang there for you. 🙂 think about it.

RE: founding fathers...

Well, lets take a different tact (mainly because I am NOT a history buff, and have no desire to go quote hunting).

If these founding fathers WERE so religious (your statement), then why is religion so clearly omitted from the government?

Again, doesn't matter a bit what religion the general rules of law were based on... Doesn't matter who wrote what to influence the choice of civil liberties. With all these religious guys running around, why is there no mention of "god"? "their creator" is a VERY vague title, and implies that the government was SPECIFICALLY created to allow for a multitude of religions to be equally protected.

Now, given that the general rule of law was crafted to protect a multitude of religions (and to prohibit legislating any one out of existence, your own words)... then we are left with a government which MUST be kept separate from religion. To look to religion for an answer would require defining which one. Without any mention of a religion (very deliberately I'd say) that gives the doctrines of the invisible green monster just as much sway. THIS is why the gov't must be kept separate. Otherwise, invisible green monster says "all christians should be thrown to the lions"... and you have to respect my religion. 🙂

"If the green monster on the corner is invisible now, how do you know he's there in the first place? "

He's always been invisible.. you just don't read my posts completely. 🙂

"I no longer get the daily newspaper paper anymore, mainly because they no longer printed "Outland". "

An excellent comic.

"Antibiotics are generally taken from molds. There are some exceptions to this. Molds, if you believe the theory of Evolution, evolved"

Early antibiotics were taken from mold. My point is that the early antibiotics (penn) are no longer effective. Most antibiotics are organically synthesized these days. I believe most may still be loosely based on the chemical structure of penn, but they are altered as bacteria evolve so that they can still be relevant.

"People develop resistances, tolerances, and immunities from poisons all the time"

You don't understand the difference between an individual's resistance and a bacterial resistance. Please look up how bacteria develop resistance to antibiotics before making this sort of comparison.

"To assert that Christians that don't believe in antibiotics because they don't believe in evolution is just as silly as my response. Antibiotics are chemical compounds, no living creatures. They are initially derived from living creatures, but they themselves are not living. "

Again, you perhaps need to bone up on your science a bit. I'm not criticizing, because I understand this isn't your field. I will try to break this down for you, because I do want you to understand where I was going with the original statement.

1) Penn is discovered because of it's ability to kill bacteria by binding a specific enzyme and inhibiting the formation of the cell wall.

2) As a large population of bacteria is killed by penn, a small percentage MAY not die. These bacteria don't die because there is a mutation in the specific enzyme penn binds to. This mutation, under normal circumstances, makes the bacteria sub-optimal. However, in a penn-rich medium, these bacteria are actually more optimal, and are selected for.

3) The penn resistant bacteria, which normally would be outcompeted for resources, are now the only game in town.

4) If there is sufficient resources, and no other anti-bacterial agents or immune responses, these penn-resistant bacteria will multiply.

This is an actual example of natural selection (in a microcosm).

My point is, that if one does not believe in evolution (and by association natural selection), then there is no reason to believe that the above mechanism ever occurred. Therefore, there is no reason to ever use any antibiotic other than pennicillin.

"First, there are LOTS of impossibilities in our existence. Matter cannot be created or destroyed, but only change forms is one such example.

What you did was a massive dodge of an obvious fact, and it's really clear. Again, do the experiment if we know so much about Evolution. "

First off, matter can be interchanged with energy (e=mc^2). So you're starting off on the wrong foot here.

Secondly, your dodge is just as massive, which is what I was trying to point out. I have stated a method by which the task could be completed. In addition, I have given reasons why it could not be practically completed. To say "then do it", when I've laid out exactly why I cannot,is a cheap dodge. If you want to argue theory, and state in scientific terms why this task would fail, please do so. Otherwise you are simply cheapening the argument.

"People observed Waterloo. People died in Waterloo. There is a mountain of evidence – physical, allegorical, observational, and so on - that shows that Waterloo existed."

Still a "belief" by your statement. mounds of evidence are only mounds of potentially unrelated datapoints by your statement. In this part, I'm simply following your rules. More evidence, according to you, does not elevate something from "belief".

"unlike evolution, there is far more evidence that Waterloo existed, happened, and that the French were defeated than there is that Evolution actually occurred"

And there is far more evidence that evolution existed than there is that god exists. Yet you are willing to lump evolution in with religion.

"Now, I could take your argument and turn it on its head by saying that Bigfoot exists because we have hair samples, foot impressions, photographic observations, sound recordings, and person observations. Yet most established scientists balk at the existence of Bigfoot, and ask for more evidence to prove its existence conclusively. "

The point of my entire post is that the strength of any theory is the strength of its data. You want to lump everything into "belief", I'm trying to point out that there is a difference between "belief" in a god which has no data to support it's existence, and the "belief" in a bigfoot (which has little bits of evidence which rarely can be supported individually), and the "belief" in a scientific theory, which has evidence which is repeatable (anyone can isolate mitochondrial DNA).

On Homosexual couples:

"However, with people always wanting to redefine everything so that they can claim some benefit from it, every time you redefine something, it opens it up for a further definition. Thus producing a "slippery slope". "

Yet we cannot remain static. Any policy has be able to alter with changing environments. I agree that people will always try to push further, but that's not a good argument against change, since it applies to ANY argument.

"My whole issue is that people are pushing for "gay marriage" for its "benefits". However, when you realize that these "benefits" are available in alternative channels, it undercuts the initial premise. "

Not all benefits are available. UW here has lost two professors because the state doesn't offer partner benefits. In addition, where private insurance companies are involved, some may specifically not offer "partner" benefits, (because the private employer doesn't want to pay for it)... companies will always try to shave cash where they can, and having separate legal definitions allows for a loophole where gay couples can clearly be discriminated against. Hospital visitation is also a very grey area as far as I'm concerned, especially in emergency situations.

"I'm missing the point you're trying to make here"

Hell if I remember.

"If that's the case, you can take "relevant information" and "logic" to conclude that only a man and woman who are both fertile can marry. All others cannot. Because the prime focus of sex is procreation, and the point of pair-bonding is for the raising of children. All other considerations are irrelevant. "

Actually, I consider that a fair point. I've argued that myself. (I think in one of these posts I suggested that based on your statement that we shouldn't allow infertile couples to marry)... If you want to boil it down to children, then do so. Homosexual couples can either have or adopt a child, so as long as they are included in this, I have no problem. If legally, only couples who either had, or intended to have a child were allowed the "married status" (whatever you want to call it is fine), then I'd be okay with it. I have no intention of marrying either way.

"I'm out on vacation all next week. Enjoy. "

Enjoy your vacation.

This post's a bit rambly... I'm on the porch drinking and smoking, so who knows where it went...

Have fun!

Oddboggle
Wednesday, July 4, 2007 10:01:00 PM
Great post, Victor!

AGAIN, you whupped JPotts pansy azz. I've seen about four other people do it just this last week or so. So I wouldn't expect him to answer this. I think he just hopes everybody'll forget, so he hides until it's safe to emerge again. "I'm on vacation next week." Yeah, RIGHT! Like we've never heard that one before.

Again, great post. Slam dunk, brother!

Oddboggle

victor808
Tuesday, July 24, 2007 5:06:00 AM
Pottsie?

Pottsie?