JonR
  • JonR
  • Herf-A-Holic Topic Starter
Tuesday, September 4, 2007 11:36:00 AM
al shrimpton and jessie (the fornicator) jackson?

News

09/04/2007 13:09:13 EST Charges Reduced in 'Jena 6' Attack

JENA, La. - Prosecutors on Tuesday reduced the attempted murder charges against two more teenagers among the "Jena Six," a group of black high school students who were arrested following an attack on a white schoolmate.

Five of the teens were originally charged with attempted second-degree murder and conspiracy to commit murder, carrying sentences of up to 80 years in prison. The sixth faces undisclosed juvenile charges.

Civil rights advocates have decried the charges as unfairly harsh.

On Tuesday, charges against Carwin Jones and Theo Shaw were reduced to aggravated second-degree battery and conspiracy. That same reduction was made earlier for Mychal Bell, who was tried and found guilty and could be sentenced to 22 1/2 years at a hearing Sept. 20.

Also awaiting trial are Robert Bailey Jr. and Bryant Purvis, who still face attempted murder charges, and the unidentified juvenile.

The attack on Justin Barker, 18, came amid tense race relations in Jena, a mostly white town of 3,000 in north-central Louisiana where racial tensions have grown since incidents that started last school year at Jena High. After a black student sat under a tree on the school campus where white students traditionally congregated, three nooses were hung in the tree.

Students accused of placing the nooses were suspended from school for a short period.

The six black students were accused of beating and kicking Barker on Dec. 4. A motive for the attack was never established. Barker was treated at a hospital emergency room and released after about three hours.

Shaw's attorney, George Tucker, said Tuesday that he still doesn't believe his client will get a fair trial in Jena.

Shaw himself has dreams of attending Gramling State University. "Just drop all the charges and let us go on with our lives," the teenager told CNN Tuesday.

JonR

MACS
Tuesday, September 4, 2007 11:42:00 AM
I'm not up on current events, but how are they being charged with attempted murder if they just whooped the kid's ass?

Doesn't it say he was treated and released 3 hours later? That doesn't sound anything LIKE attempted murder to me. Sounds like an ass whoopin'.

Maybe he had it coming and maybe he didn't, but it damn sure ain't attempted murder.

*shrug*

Charlie
Tuesday, September 4, 2007 11:56:00 AM
Six against one sounds like a ass kicking for some reason other than attempted murder to me as well, but I never want to side with Al Sharpton and Jesse Jackson on anything!

Charlie

andytv
Tuesday, September 4, 2007 12:01:00 PM
here is some more info.........

http://www.snopes.com/politics/crime/jena6.asp 

rfenst
Tuesday, September 4, 2007 12:12:00 PM

"Attempted murder" has nothing to do with the amount of damage inflicted on the victim, but rather: 1) the state of mind of the accused, coupled with 2) the conduct by the acused that could reasonably be expected to result in death.

Take for example: 1)the accussed intentionally and knowingly 2)shooting a gun at the victim's head. But, bullet completely misses the victim, such that the victim was not even grazed. This would still be considered to be "attempted murder."

Pacman357 is highly likely more qualified to explain this than I am..

pacman357
Tuesday, September 4, 2007 1:47:00 PM
#5 Right you are. It's the intent of the actor plus some other action. In other words, what you were trying to accomplish plus, in most jurisdictions, that you take what is referred to as a "substantial step" towards committing that crime. The "substantial step" is what makes an attempted crime a crime in and of itself.

You can be guilty of attempted robbery just by pulling up to the bank with a mask on, if the prosection can show you were there with the purpose of robbing the bank. Something like you told someone you were going to do that, you had a gun and a demand note, things of that nature.

You can try to kill someone and never lay a finger on them. Shooting and missing is the easiest example. Buying rat poison and putting it in food, where the person lives anyway. Hiring someone to do the deed.

What constitutes a crime will always depend on the laws of the jurisdiction. Whether the prosecution can prove any crime, what they can prove, whether they have to cut a deal to get other defendants convicted, wishes of the family, availability of witnesses, strength of the evidence, and a whole host of other potential influencing factors can dictate why deals get cut in cases and what deals are cut, if any. The problem in trying to assess them from outside of the case, that is not having all the relevant info. and not being experienced in the handling of such cases in the relevant jurisdiction, some times leads to results that seem skewed one way or the other. A perfectly rationale outcome may be plea bargained in a case while defying common sense to those not immersed in the case. And remember, once a jury gets the case for deliberations, no one knows or can control what happens. There's almost always some incentive for one side or both to plea bargain.

pacman357
Tuesday, September 4, 2007 1:51:00 PM
Oops. Rational, not rationale.

BTW, even after handling hundreds (more like thousands) of criminal cases over most of two decades and trying over 100 criminal trials, I couldn't begin to tell you, without looking at all the evidence and having some info. on how the case proceeded, whether I think these guys got good deals or not. I don't think any experienced criminal defense attorney or prosecutor would disagree with me on that either. You can't describe the entire iceberg just from the tip poking up out of the water.

MACS
Tuesday, September 4, 2007 3:40:00 PM
Okay... now that you've lawyer'ed it all up and the jury has heard YOUR side, I'll say my peace...

There were SIX of them. He was released from the hospital in THREE hours.

Do you think if SIX men were attempting to kill ONE man, he'd spend a little more than 3 hours in the hospital??? Christ, if they were TRYING to kill him, I think he'd be DEAD, it was SIX against ONE.

I submit to you that it was nothing more than an ass whoopin'.

The defense rests your honor.

RICKAMAVEN
Tuesday, September 4, 2007 4:16:00 PM
six brave men against one coward, shows a lot of class on the part of the six, regardless of their intentions.

couldn't they handle it with just 5.

MACS
Tuesday, September 4, 2007 4:22:00 PM
Don't get me wrong, Rick... what they did was assinine. But it wasn't attempted murder.
pacman357
Tuesday, September 4, 2007 4:52:00 PM
#8 Could be a very valid argument, depends on the facts and applicable law. Then again, they could just be very ineffective at whatever they were attempting. For example, with your training and background, one of you could have probably inflicted far more damage in five minutes.

To give you an idea how flaky or goofy the law can get, I'll give you an example of just one way a person can commit Assault in the Second Degree in WA, a serious charge (and a "strike" under this state's three strikes law, where the third strike means life without parole):

"(1) A person is guilty of assault in the second degree if he or she, under circumstances not amounting to assault in the first degree:

...

(f) Knowingly inflicts bodily harm which by design causes such pain or agony as to be the equivalent of that produced by torture."

Can you explain where someone crosses the line and inflicts bodily harm which by design causes such pain or agony as to be the equivalent of that produced by torture? I can't, and I'm an experienced criminal defense attorney. Our appellate courts have upheld that as NOT being unconstitutionally vague.

Like I said, facts and applicable law.

JonR
  • JonR
  • Herf-A-Holic Topic Starter
Tuesday, September 4, 2007 7:59:00 PM
Yo MACS:

"Do you think if SIX men were attempting to kill ONE man, he'd spend a little more than 3 hours in the hospital??? Christ, if they were TRYING to kill him, I think he'd be DEAD, it was SIX against ONE."

Maybe they had small feet?

JonR

MACS
Tuesday, September 4, 2007 8:30:00 PM
Jon... if all the MoFo's in Philly had small feet, maybe the death toll would be lower?
JonR
  • JonR
  • Herf-A-Holic Topic Starter
Tuesday, September 4, 2007 9:02:00 PM
Yo MACS:

"Jon... if all the MoFo's in Philly had small feet, maybe the death toll would be lower?"

Nah, they all have the same size...Mac-10's.

LOL

JonR

MACS
Tuesday, September 4, 2007 9:04:00 PM
LMAO!

Nice rejoinder!