Charlie
Tuesday, September 11, 2007 7:23:00 AM
You are rather rude....I will give you that. Harsh for a newbie, but you have a right to your opinion!

Charlie

cbc812
Tuesday, September 11, 2007 7:34:00 AM
I am rude.

And you are ____? Go wave your flag and trash other Americans for having a opinion that differs from yours. That's really patriotic. Namecalling is always a sound defense of one's position. The last I checked the war in Iraq has only made this country, my city, coworkers, and my family less safe from Islamic terrorists.

And you have the nerve to call me rude. You can kiss my ass.

usahog
Tuesday, September 11, 2007 7:40:00 AM
"You can kiss my ass."

You got an address attached to that ass... I'll stand in line to kiss it ;0)

Signed

Midwest Armchair Chest Thumper..

btw have you seen doctors about your odds & ends?

cbc812
Tuesday, September 11, 2007 7:41:00 AM
^LMAO, Hog. Thanks for the humor.
usahog
Tuesday, September 11, 2007 7:50:00 AM
Newts (Gingrich) Views on the topic..

Beyond the Petraeus Report: The Report on the Larger War

Here's how I put it in my speech yesterday:

Beyond the Petraeus Report, we need a report on the larger war with the Irreconcilable Wing of Islam.

This enemy is irreconcilable with the modern civilized world because its values would block any woman from being in this room, having a job, voting, being educated.

It is irreconcilable because it cannot tolerate other religions or other lifestyles.

It represents what some have called an "Islamo-fascist" approach to imposing its views on others, and as such, it is a mortal threat to our way of life, to freedom and to the rule of law.

The Irreconcilable Wing of Islam has emerged as an extremist movement against not only non-Muslims but also against moderate Muslims who wish both to preserve their faith and to be a part of the modern world. This extremism has led to civil war in Algeria killing more than 100,000 Muslims. It has led to continuing violence in Lebanon, more than 2,000 killed in Thailand, the Philippines and a number of other places. It has mobilized forces outside traditional trouble spots, including recently Germany, Denmark and Great Britain. And while the vast majority of Muslims wish to be a part of the civilized world and do not want the extremists in the Irreconcilable Wing of Islam to win, the enemy's global reach, including in places like Paraguay and Venezuela, is greater than anyone might have expected a decade ago.

usahog
Tuesday, September 11, 2007 7:50:00 AM
More Newt:

The Reagan, Lincoln and Roosevelt Models for Victory

In my AEI speech, I offered three models of American leadership as we ask ourselves what we could have done differently -- and what we still might do differently -- in the broader war against the Irreconcilable Wing of Islam.

I came upon my third model for American leadership -- Franklin Delano Roosevelt -- while researching and writing my novel, Pearl Harbor and its sequel, which will be out next year.

FDR's clarity of strategic purpose, ruthless management of the system and vision of unconditional victory are models of convincing a free people to bring their energies to bear on winning a better future by defeating an evil opponent.

Here's what I said in my speech:

"As an example of scale, remember that the United States built a two-ocean navy, built more than 299,000 aircraft, built more than 88,000 tanks, mobilized 15,500,000 men and women in uniform, built the most expensive project of the war, the B-29, and used it to deliver the second most expensive project of the war, the Atomic Bomb. Because of the pre-Pearl Harbor preparedness campaign, the United States won the Second World War in three years and eight months -- from Dec. 7, 1941, to Aug. 14, 1945."

What If? Explaining the Larger War With the Irreconcilable Wing of Islam in a Novel Way

Then I built on the Reagan, Lincoln and Roosevelt models of success to ask what a realistic alternative history of the current war might look like now, six years after 9/11.

I asked my audience -- as I ask you now -- to imagine that we, as a nation, stunned by the bitter blows of the day before, now awake the day after September 11 and embark upon a different course of action.

What if, beginning Sept. 12, 2001, we had taken the following steps?

One: What if, on the morning of Sept. 12, 2001, the shocked national political leadership in both parties had understood the necessity to take a deep, long look at the Irreconcilable Wing of Islam?

Two: What if we had begun a series of bipartisan congressional hearings on the scale of terrorist financing from sources in Saudi Arabia, the degree of Iranian and Syrian support for terrorism and the various propagandizing and recruiting efforts that were underway to attract terrorists at a rate faster than we could kill or imprison them?

Three: What if the news media had begun a series of informative, in-depth explorations of the Iranian war against America and then went on to examine the goals of the various irreconcilable groups and the religious fervor with which they are willing to die for their beliefs?

Four: What if the great bureaucracies of national security and homeland security had immediately begun to place defeating the enemy above protecting their normal routine systems?

Five: What if the Office of Management and Budget had been instructed to set aside its peacetime formulas and attitudes and operate within a war-time footing to facilitate the mobilization and build up necessary to both win the war with the Irreconcilable Wing of Islam and preserve America's military and intelligence capabilities on other fronts?

usahog
Tuesday, September 11, 2007 7:51:00 AM
The Wrong Debate About the Wrong Report

The purpose of this alternative history is very simple: To spur America and our leadership to a deeper, more meaningful consideration of the threat we face.

Six years after the attacks of 9/11, we are having the wrong debate about the wrong report.

We need a blueprint for reform and success. It is not acceptable that we have more impediments to action than enablers for action.

We need a strategy -- not a campaign -- to rationalize ends and means to achieve our objectives in this long war against our way of life.

I will close my message to you today the same way I ended my speech yesterday:

Let us reason together, face the facts, invent the solutions and mobilize the resources for victory.

With leadership, it will be the terrorists who are defeated and the free people who are triumphant.

With leadership, the free people of the world will form an unshakable alliance against evil and an enormous system in defense of the innocent.

It is in the best American tradition that we have the courage at home that we expect on the battlefield.

There is no shortcut.

This is the road to victory over evil.

This is the road to safety, freedom and prosperity for the civilized world.

Your friend,

Newt

cbc812
Tuesday, September 11, 2007 7:57:00 AM
Interesting and pleasantly surprising ideas from the former Speaker. If only his alternative model had been implemented. Iraq was an unfortunate diversion, and the problem we have now is that nobody who got us into this mess is willing to budge on getting us out in a favorable manner, because the need for such a strategic extraction would entail admitting error.

Unlike some, I appreciate cogent ideas and clear thinking from either side of the aisle. Thanks for the info, Hog!

usahog
Tuesday, September 11, 2007 8:09:00 AM
cbc who said we're leaving anytime soon?

I don't see us pulling out of Iraq or anywhere even with a change in Administrations?

what the American People are getting from all our elected officials is lip service.. what we want to hear..

They (any of them) haven't and are not even giving this man (Patraeus) a chance to show were we are at in Iraq and or the war On Terror...

a good friend and BOTL and I were on the phone last night discussing much of these issue's...

and as you pointed out.. you feel no safer today they you did at Sept 11 2001... Neither do many Americans..

There is nothing stoping another Attack on US Soil...

Preventing and doing the best we can "Yes" but not stoping it...

As my friend pointed out.. all they would need (and possibly already have?) is 100 in place sleeper cell personell all over in major city's say two at a time.. who've been collecting up whatever explosives and whatnots they can get their hands on... and then on a certian day/certian hour in these locations they decide to pull up outside a banking institution or some other stratigic locations and blow themselves up?

what kind of fear factor would that be on our economy? on our livelyhoods?

Vigilance is the Key and it will take every American citizen to do their parts to prevent **** like this from happening...

We can go about our lives.. but I have no problem profiling people as I live it everyday

Hog

cbc812
Tuesday, September 11, 2007 8:33:00 AM
Hog, the thing is that we can't leave anytime soon. What we do need is to realize that there will be no "victory" in Iraq, and redeploy our assets (military, financial, diplomatic) in a manner that will further the end of making Americans safer from Islamist terrorists (or any other, for that matter).

The problem with Petraeus' report is that it will be the same old dreck - he knows what happened to General Shinseki. Nobody at the top levels of our government is willing to be straight with us. You KNOW that nobody in the Bush administration would ever say "Okay, this was a major strategic error compounded by poor planning, but it isn't going away. Here's how to minimize the damage and to move forward." That would entail admitting error, which will never happen as long as GWB is in charge. He's already decided to punt. The rest of the government, and indeed the country is too busy attacking those who don't agree with them to actually focus on moving forward.

en455
Tuesday, September 11, 2007 8:51:00 AM
cbc is right on the money on this one.
RICKAMAVEN
Tuesday, September 11, 2007 9:08:00 AM
28. Author: donutboy2000

the democrats are worse then the republicans. we know the republicans are chicken hawks, they love the iraq war. they believe bush like regean are upstanding, patriotic, and great leaders.

the democrats know different, but they won't do anything about it. they are farting around with investigations even as bush tells them to "piss up a rope" and ignores any oversight that the democrats attempt. all the congress has to do is cut off funding and start impeachment hearings,

the democrats have wasted their majority. they talk a good game, but when the whistle blows, they lay down like sheep.

RICKAMAVEN
Tuesday, September 11, 2007 9:09:00 AM
29. Author: GreenWolf70

define "win this war."

RICKAMAVEN
Tuesday, September 11, 2007 9:15:00 AM
45. Author: UsaHog1

referencing newt as an authority? how can you. newt is a pundit that can't keep his own house in order. he is the POS that charlie always talks about, and i believe he still has some baby fat.

RICKAMAVEN
Tuesday, September 11, 2007 9:16:00 AM
27. Author: JonR

don't hurt yourself laughing.

HockeyDad
Tuesday, September 11, 2007 10:15:00 AM
....But Newt does recognize the Venezuela threat!

I've been warning you people....

DrMaddVibe
Tuesday, September 11, 2007 10:17:00 AM
Newt is smart enough to stay out of airport men's restrooms, I'll give ya that! He was also smart enough to step down when he did.

Now he likes to play talking head "I told you so" on the newsies.

Buh-Bye Newt! Gimmie Dr. Ron Paul