DaQueenBeez
Tuesday, November 13, 2007 7:21:00 AM
rfenst:

Actually, no, we hadn't considered that. I really didn't even know that it was an option, but I'm wondering now if we might not end up needing to use it. I really hope not.

Obviously this is totally new territory for us - advice from folks more "in the know" than we are is really all we have to work with, I'm afraid. We're following what seem to be the obvious courses with reporting and questions and such, but the people who are supposedly investigating this aren't very helpful AT ALL, and the insurance company is looking out for it's OWN interests (naturally.) We aren't even really sure how long we are supposed to give the investigators to find the plane before calling it a loss and filing a claim. We waited 3 weeks before contacting the insurance co. to ask that very question, and they just said they'd send paperwork for us.

We've been hoping the plane (and the party/parties responsible for it's disappearance) would be located, but as far as we can tell, the police don't have much more information than they started with, and it's been gone for almost a month now (if it had been gone for a week when we were notified). At what point do you say, "this is looking pretty hopeless and I'm really not interested in continuing to write checks for a plane that I will probably never have access to again"? We really don't know.

Where's ScoobyDoo when you need him, eh? He'd have caught the bad guys in 30 minutes minus commercial breaks with an explanation of exactly how old man Fitsimmons stole the plane using a werewolf mask and a fog machine! 😉

Tammy

rfenst
Tuesday, November 13, 2007 2:56:00 PM
Checks for a plane? I presume you mean loan payments. If this is the case, then you definitely need to expedite the claim payment process. Legal advice appears in order.

I would also contact the lender, presuming that is what you are alluding to, and advise that the plane has been stolen. The lender highly likely has a lien on the plane and is the first loss-payee in line under your insurance policy.

This should trigger the lender to get involved to get the claim paid faster. After all, they have lost their security on your presumed loan (the plane) and are now faced with the prospect that you will stop making payments.

Hope this helps a bit...

pacman357
Tuesday, November 13, 2007 3:25:00 PM
Dear Queen (oh, God, please don't tell Mrs. Pacman I addressed another human female that way), sorry to hear you are still having trouble with this, although I'm glad my advice has helped a bit. It's a true Catch-22...you don't exercise your rights and you could accidentally end up screwing yourself (can't tell you how many cases I've handled when someone thought they were saying something harmless in their own case), or you assert and the cops ask "Well, gee, what do you have to hide?" My answer to the latter has often been, BTW, that the officer needs to start really working on the case like a grown-up cop or hand it off to someone who can rather than pick on the victim. BTW, crucial difference is that by exercising your rights, you're not pinned down to an ambiguous statement later, and I don't know of a court that allows a jury to hear that a person excercised his rights to remain silent and/or invoke counsel.

My Floridian counterpart raises a good point about possibly hiring someone to push on the insurance company. The fact that the cops asked you or Beez to poly worries me greatly. I'm assuming you didn't spirit away your own plane and start this thread to cover it up...safe assumption, I'd say. However, it appears that the cops, lacking any real skills or evidence, have just decided to try to either rule out Beez or lean on him. Either are bad signs. Either they suspect him because they can't find anything else or they are limited in abilities and they learned from watching Law & Order that you have to rule out the victim.

If you can find someone who handles both criminal cases and bad faith insurance claims, you may have a good shot at protecting yourselves. Someone who can run interference and maybe even knows a reporter who can write a story in the local paper about the victims getting victimized all over again, this time by the cops. That latter part may or may not fly where you live, so I'd ask the attorney you find about that before trying to wage your own media campaign (some prosecutors and/or cops would feel the need to fight back in the media and accuse you and/or Beez publicly, which is a fight you don't want).

Finding that attorney might be tough if you haven't done so before. I'd check the yellow pages, maybe the local or state bar association for referral services, or maybe even go to the county seat and hang out at the felony level court for motions calendars...see who appears to know their stuff and just ask if they handle something like that (although ask around the court if the attorney is a nitwit or superstar...court staff, jail officers, etc.).

BTW, polygraphs are not totally useless. I've used them in the past to convince a prosecutor that a client is innocent. The trick is controlling the situation...knowing a good polygrapher, having enough info. to give him/her so he/she can ask the right questions, and not divulging the results until your test subject comes back clean (meaning you also need to have a polygrapher you can trust to keep his/her mouth shut if the results come back inconclusive, or worse).

pacman357
Tuesday, November 13, 2007 3:31:00 PM
Something else that occurred to me, and I don't handle these kinds of things (mostly the people who are actually accused of the thefts, that end of the biz), I'd review my insurance policy. They might be required to provide some sort of legal counsel at this stage, especially if Beez has been buzzed (sorry) by the cops. You might also have a duty to notify them before hiring one or give them a chance to hire an attorney or give the OK before they would cover the costs. You may not get any help there, and I could be waaaaaaay off base, but I'm just trying to think of the various ways insurance companies might look to screw you, and it seems to me they may have some sort of counsel provision or their contract gives them a chance to save their own azzes before you hire an attorney, at least as a ways to try to insulate themselves from a possible bad faith lawsuit. You might also seek a consultation with an attorney about just bringing in an attorney formally in case the insurance company is covered that way or in the laws where you live.
DaBeez
  • DaBeez
  • Aficionado Topic Starter
Tuesday, November 13, 2007 4:14:00 PM
When I told the deputy that I had gotten some free advice from firends of a friend and that I was not going to do the polygraph, he didn't seem too concerned. I explained that I was concerned about what the security organization where I work would do (I have a clearance) and what the insurance would if there were any inconclusive questions. He said," Let me ask a couple of questions and get back to you. Don't hire a lawyer yet, we may not need the polygraph." That was a week ago and we haven't heard a thing since. The insurance was supposed to send the loss papers yesterday. Once we fill them out and return them, they are supposed to release funds for the claim. I guess we'll see. We did notify the lien holder the day after we reported the plane stolen. We also called the FAA, Id DOT, the insurance, TSA, and made sure the FBI and Homeland Security were notified.

The interview with the sheriff and FBI was the type of questions that I would have expected and we answered to the best of our ability. The simple fact is that the FBO was acting as our representative for the sale of the plane and had the logs and keys. The logs ended up in the plane (not normal unless transporting them for sale or maintenance). The last time we saw the logs, they were in the office at the FBO. The sheriff has the only set of keys for the door that we know of, so it was broken into or someone got access to the keys and made a copy. Anything they ask us beyond that is speculation on our part and we made that clear to them.

We'll keep you guys in the loop about the saga.

Beez

pacman357
Tuesday, November 13, 2007 4:38:00 PM
Sounds like you're not suspects. I think you ducked the poly question gracefully, BTW. Still, I'm bothered that someone would ask you. The things take more than just a few minutes, and unless you are going to a guy they have in-house (not recommended), they run around $400 give or take where I work. Hardly lunch money. Just watch your back, cowboy.
pacman357
Tuesday, November 13, 2007 4:41:00 PM
BTW, went back and re-read #39. May not have been a cop. May have been a private eye or an insurance company ******. Yes, in both senses of the word. I'd be even more wary of them, since they don't have to observe your constitutional rights. For anyone like that, I'd demand to see them in person and get some ID and time to check out their license and employment before talking with them.

Then I wouldn't talk with them. Not without a lawyer on hand, that is.

DaBeez
  • DaBeez
  • Aficionado Topic Starter
Wednesday, January 9, 2008 8:42:00 PM
Final (I hope) update on the plane issue. The insurance co. asked for a formal sworn statement prior to issuing a claim check just before Christmas. We did get an attorney involved so that we would have representation at that. It was a fairly long interview, and ended up being about 3 hours long between the 2 of us. We did find out that the insurance company or police had learned that some number of hours (we don't know exactly how many) had been flown on the airplane by at least two individuals who did NOT have our authorization to use the aircraft. They asked a lot of specific questions about the audio panel from the plane, and it really sounded like they might know where it is, which would indicate that the plane has been parted out. For the most part, the questions asked were really the type of questions we expected. We did find out later that the FBO has been listed for sale several places, but the owner is denying knowledge of it being for sale. Kind of indicated that he may be having some financial problems, which is what the Power County detective had alluded to previously. We did recieve a check for the full declared hull value minus the deductible Tuesday and have sent that on to pay off the note and hopefully finalize this mess. Those of you who offered advice and support, we really appreciate it. If we find out anything else, we'll certainly post and keep you updated. We have some theories of our own based on all the bits and pieces of information we've gleaned from the insurance co. and the police, but it's still pure speculation on our part. Right now we're wondering about the possibility of filing charges against the people who are known to have flown the plane without our permission. May not be able to, since it's no longer our plane. Thanks again for all of your support.

Beez

usahog
Wednesday, January 9, 2008 8:50:00 PM
^ Still smoken cigars or polishing off a rifle?

Hog

burgess_b
Thursday, January 10, 2008 1:00:00 AM
dabeez--it WAS your plane at the time, so i think you can press charges. hell, if someone stole your tv, and you got a new one after insurance, the criminal is still punished, right? punish them!
fishinguitarman
Thursday, January 10, 2008 3:46:00 AM
51!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Torpedo1
Thursday, January 10, 2008 4:45:00 AM
It seems like you are getting some resolve. That is great, minus the headache and aggravation.

You live to smoke another day!!!

porschesales225
Thursday, January 10, 2008 5:17:00 AM
sounds like he was letting people test drive your plane before he sold it i mean it got stolen. ask your attourney but you could press charges for them using your plane without permission its theft even if they bring it back.