Dear Queen (oh, God, please don't tell Mrs. Pacman I addressed another human female that way), sorry to hear you are still having trouble with this, although I'm glad my advice has helped a bit. It's a true Catch-22...you don't exercise your rights and you could accidentally end up screwing yourself (can't tell you how many cases I've handled when someone thought they were saying something harmless in their own case), or you assert and the cops ask "Well, gee, what do you have to hide?" My answer to the latter has often been, BTW, that the officer needs to start really working on the case like a grown-up cop or hand it off to someone who can rather than pick on the victim. BTW, crucial difference is that by exercising your rights, you're not pinned down to an ambiguous statement later, and I don't know of a court that allows a jury to hear that a person excercised his rights to remain silent and/or invoke counsel.
My Floridian counterpart raises a good point about possibly hiring someone to push on the insurance company. The fact that the cops asked you or Beez to poly worries me greatly. I'm assuming you didn't spirit away your own plane and start this thread to cover it up...safe assumption, I'd say. However, it appears that the cops, lacking any real skills or evidence, have just decided to try to either rule out Beez or lean on him. Either are bad signs. Either they suspect him because they can't find anything else or they are limited in abilities and they learned from watching Law & Order that you have to rule out the victim.
If you can find someone who handles both criminal cases and bad faith insurance claims, you may have a good shot at protecting yourselves. Someone who can run interference and maybe even knows a reporter who can write a story in the local paper about the victims getting victimized all over again, this time by the cops. That latter part may or may not fly where you live, so I'd ask the attorney you find about that before trying to wage your own media campaign (some prosecutors and/or cops would feel the need to fight back in the media and accuse you and/or Beez publicly, which is a fight you don't want).
Finding that attorney might be tough if you haven't done so before. I'd check the yellow pages, maybe the local or state bar association for referral services, or maybe even go to the county seat and hang out at the felony level court for motions calendars...see who appears to know their stuff and just ask if they handle something like that (although ask around the court if the attorney is a nitwit or superstar...court staff, jail officers, etc.).
BTW, polygraphs are not totally useless. I've used them in the past to convince a prosecutor that a client is innocent. The trick is controlling the situation...knowing a good polygrapher, having enough info. to give him/her so he/she can ask the right questions, and not divulging the results until your test subject comes back clean (meaning you also need to have a polygrapher you can trust to keep his/her mouth shut if the results come back inconclusive, or worse).