porschesales225
Thursday, February 14, 2008 8:01:00 AM
my understanding of the law down here is that as long as an officer of the same sex is present they will search you.

Ill withhold my opinion about this until the whole story comes out. If it had been a case of one officer mis behaving I would give it more credit but they are leveling charges against a whole shift. Hard to believe not one person went hey arent we being a little rough here.

kms
  • kms
  • Herf-A-Holic
Thursday, February 14, 2008 8:12:00 AM
It's interesting that we only get a portion of the story, and the videotape that we see obviously starts in the middle of whatever was happening.

One possibility: The woman was tweaked out on drugs or booze, and needed to be restrained in order to arrest/search.

I guess the point is that it doesn't show the whole story, as others have said. If the whole thing was mostly unprovoked and they behaved that way, then they should be fired and put in prison themselves. But we really won't know the whole story until we hear both sides.

I personally think that what I posted, while not as shocking, is more egregious an offence, given that there was very little provocation and there was still a somewhat violent result. I think I'll repost it in another thread as folks seem to be missing it.

sw48362
Thursday, February 14, 2008 8:16:00 AM
Some people tend to hire others that are somewhat like themselves. So I can see why they all thought, that this was ok.

Getting them naked and then putting them on display. Um didn't something similar like this happen in a military prison. Was big in the news not to long ago

Sorry they were way wrong! even if she did have a lighter up her ass!

RandyB
Thursday, February 14, 2008 8:16:00 AM
be sure and watch part 2, it shows more video and lays the claim that the Sheriff dept did not release ALL of the video, sounds like a cover up.
sw48362
Thursday, February 14, 2008 8:18:00 AM
^ no lighter up her ass has been reported as of yet!
JHC
  • JHC
  • Herf-A-Holic
Thursday, February 14, 2008 8:28:00 AM
#23... I was thinking the same thing. The prisoners all over again. Right here at home.
kms
  • kms
  • Herf-A-Holic
Thursday, February 14, 2008 10:06:00 AM
^One interesting thing that that brings up is yet another of the many very good arguments against "aggressive" interrogation techniques (read: torture).

Many of our interrogators in the military and intelligence world are now learning that this sort of stuff is OK. In the past, after wars, you often end up with a good number of former military etc. going into the police force. In turn, at the end of every major conflict the US has been involved in in the past 100 years, there is a period immediately following where there are a lot of problems with the Police using excessive force and basically violating rights.

Our acceptance for this in our military and intelligence leaders leads to this crap, and it also erodes our moral and civil high ground.

JDELLLL
Thursday, February 14, 2008 11:03:00 AM
Yeah, and if you don't have a little street discipline, you may as well have the police say, "pardon me, if I ask you in a nice way, will you please refrain from.....but if you don't, it's okay".
jpotts
Thursday, February 14, 2008 12:10:00 PM
The problem with all of this is that there is a long string of events that led up to this, that no one knows about.

I find it really hard to believe that giving out the wrong drivers license would lead a person to being arrested. There's more to it. I also find it really hard to believe that the answer to a single question led to a strip search. And there was no explanation was to why this chick was in a fight.

The video is pretty shocking, but that's just a really small part of this entire sequence of events, and of course the family is going to portray this entire episode as being the fault of law enforcement.

I'd be interesting to hear what eventually comes of this.

VaMtnMan
Thursday, February 14, 2008 8:17:00 PM
I think there is a lot more to this Video then the News is giving us. It sounds like to me, she was put on Suicide watch. If that is true, then yes all of her clothes would be removed. And no, she does not get a blanket because she could use it hang herself. As for just leaving all of her clothes on and handcuffed, I can remember a lady getting arrested last year in an Airport (her mother-in-law was some N.Y. politician if I remeer correctly), she was left handcuffed, and tried getting out of them and choked herself to death.

The question about "Have you tried to Kill yourself Before" has to be asked, because if they don't ask it, and she does hurt herself, some bleeding heart liberal will be saying they should sue the Sheriffs Dept. If when they ask it, and you joking say "Maybe", well what are they to believe. They are going to treat you like you might hurt yourself, to protect themselves in case you do. As far as Males being present, this was not a Strip Search. In a Strip Search, they are taking your clothes off to check for contraban. In this case, they were taking them off so that she couldn't use them to hurt herself. So after reading all of this, Answer this one question. If they had not taken her clothes, and put her in a normal cell, and she hanged herself, would you not be here on this board saying that the Sheriffs Dept should have know she would hurt herself, and should be Sued?

Two more things to give thought to. First off,in my previous job of 9 years as a Police Officer, I have seen a lot of half to fully naked females, and it never got me off. I could see in one of the deputies eyes in the video, he sure as hell didn't want to be messing with this female. Second, if anyone here thinks it is an easy job, they are always hiring. Only job I know where you can be punched, kicked, spit on, bit, and cursed at all in the same night, and then have to go tell someone that their kid was just killed by a drunk. Oh, and all in the same night. Oh yea, and then have a bunch of people who are scared of their own shadow, sit there and try and tell you that all of the above was your own fault in one way or another. Oh yea, great job.

ScottHar
Thursday, February 14, 2008 8:52:00 PM
Yo, kms! re 27: "Many of our interrogators in the military and intelligence world are now learning that this sort of stuff is OK."

Let's distinguish between acceptable -- and, yes, even "aggressive" -- interrogation methods and illegal abuse. The former IS, in fact, "OK." The latter is severely punished, as evidenced by the multiple convictions that resulted from the Abu Ghraib abuses (i.e. I don't believe Cpl. Graner -- sentenced to 10 years in prison -- is under any delusion that his behavior was "accepted" by the military).

Also, you assert that "at the end of every major conflict the US has been involved in in the past 100 years, there is a period immediately following where there are a lot of problems with the Police using excessive force and basically violating rights."

I'm hoping you can support this claim with credible statistical evidence. Otherwise, you can understand how this might strike some as a sweeping slander of both U.S. troops and U.S. law enforcement.

When we know so little about this Stark County incident, to jump in and claim that it's an obvious byproduct of soldiers who engage in government-condoned "torture" may not be the most responsible assertion.

Other than that... I generally dig your posts, man. (Not being sarcastic: you can be pretty damn funny!) Maybe I should have started off by saying "Nice to meet you." Or maybe I should have had decaff today.

ScottHar