Well....I'm a benefit of the doubt give'er more than anything, so perhaps that coincides more with being a generous grader.
In reality, most of us at one point or another have felt slighted in a trade. If somebody hasn't, well, they probably haven't been trading for very long. How we deal with that feeling of disappointment will vary from person to person...just like anything. Some will choose to never deal with that person again and move on, others will make some back-handed comments about the contents of what they receive in the trading forum, while others would just go straight to the source to let them know their thoughts.
I certainly don't fault PAPA for posting his question here. He didn't say who it was, and was asking how he thought it should be handled.
Thats a more than fair question IMO. Not everyone here would agree with that, but it's HIS question...and as I said, with all the other BS that this board is riddled with, I personally welcome a genuine inquiry every now and again. But that's just me.
KPP wrote: