Poll Question: Which AC/DC?
Buckwheat
Tuesday, February 7, 2012 12:34:26 PM
I prefer the Bon Scott Version of AC/DC. I always thought that Brian Johnson just yells. I did like Back in Black but after that I just lost interest.
plinytheelder
Tuesday, February 7, 2012 1:34:17 PM
Back in Black is their best album, so I'd have to go with Brian Johnson.
dkeage
Tuesday, February 7, 2012 1:39:36 PM

Back in Black is their best album, so I'd have to go with Brian Johnson.

plinytheelder wrote:

..............cattle

plinytheelder
Tuesday, February 7, 2012 1:45:12 PM
mooooooooooooo
DrMaddVibe
Tuesday, February 7, 2012 1:51:02 PM
Bon for the win!

Bon had the fortune to be in the band when it was on it's way to making it and superstardom. He had a swagger and when he sang it was almost like he was in on a private joke and he'd sneer it at you in little morsels. Notably are the songs "Sin City", "Ride On", "Jailbreak" and "Whole Lotta Rosie"...he's telling a story and is a bit player in the telling. The band all has a role and they do it to a deft perfection. Just something about his talk/sing and the high tone mixed with a scream here and there that did it for me.

It was the band's misfortune to lose a guy like him. They don't come around too often and when they do you KNOW you're seeing the real deal. They settled with Brian. Yeah, I say settled because they could've had any number of replacements. I really wish they would've grabbed Marc Storace. They would've been able to continue where they left off damn near seamlessly. PAul Shortino would've been another guy that would've enabled them to just pick up and go. What do your ears tell you?

Instead we got Brian. The dude sounds like he gargled down a Lye milkshake with a Draino backer. He looks like Bruce Springsteen when he's singing...it's that damn painful! By the end of the concert his vocal cords are shot. I've had the opportunity to meet up with him. He has a home in the Sarasota area and LOVES a local tribute band called Highway To Hell. If he's in town he NEVER misses a show and in some cases he'll hop up onstage with the band and sing for them. He LOVES the guy that covers him and he has an uncanny way of doing Bon and Brian's vocals to the point you close your eyes and you'd swear it's them. Likeable guy. I like some of the songs he sang..."Have A Drink On Me", "Safe In New York City", "Big Gun" and "Thunderstruck"...it's AC/DC but it really is a different band that was lucky enough to make it's living on Malcolm inventing some of the best intro guitar riffs that his brother Angus would expand upon with a drum and bass that would give a lightning storm a good run for it's money!

tailgater
Tuesday, February 7, 2012 2:01:50 PM
Dave Evans.

MACS
Tuesday, February 7, 2012 2:09:41 PM

Live Wire

I have a box set called Bonfire of all the songs with Bon Scott. Live Wire, live at the Atlantic Recording Studios in NY, kicks serious ass.

JadeRose
Tuesday, February 7, 2012 2:26:42 PM
I loved Bon but have enjoyed listening to them all these years. I've always admired AC/DC because they are what they are. They write and perform simple cock rock behind Angus's heavy power chords and first Bon's and then Brian's unique voices. They haven't done any concept albums, they aren't in the news for strife within the band. They simply rock out with their cocks out and have been doing so for 40 years. Are they my favorite band? No...but that's ok. They are still a relevant rock band in a world that has way too few of them. Long Live AC/DC.

Btw...I STILL remember dropping the needle on Back in Black for the first time and knowing I was hearing something special. Gaddam that album RAWKS!

teedubbya
Tuesday, February 7, 2012 2:31:23 PM
Bon. Easily.

Glad to see there are only 2 of you so far that love johnson

tailgater
Tuesday, February 7, 2012 2:38:43 PM

Bon. Easily.

Glad to see there are only 2 of you so far that love johnson

teedubbya wrote:

Well, Jade did use the word "c0ck" twice, and he would be likely to check off the "johnson" category by simple force of habit...

It's funny this thread happened today, because it was just last night or the night before when I first heard Dave Evans sing for AC/DC.

He's the original singer, and helped write "Can I sit next to you, girl?".

There's a video on youtube.

Pretty good, actually.

But Bon is the one.

Buckwheat
Tuesday, February 7, 2012 2:39:13 PM

Dave Evans.

tailgater wrote:

A little too Glam Rock for me. I'm glad that they didn't continue down that road!!!!

Shawn - Ditto on the Bonfire Box Set. One of the best boxsets out there.

tailgater
Tuesday, February 7, 2012 6:08:11 PM

Instead we got Brian. The dude sounds like he gargled down a Lye milkshake with a Draino backer. He looks like Bruce Springsteen when he's singing...it's that damn painful! By the end of the concert his vocal cords are shot. !

DrMaddVibe wrote:

Funny thing is, he didn't always sing this way.

His former band is called Geordie.

I used to have a couple albums from them and they're not half bad.

Decent version of House of the Rising Sun.

A few other songs I can't remember, but if you google Brian Johnson Geordie you'll get some good youtube hits.

He actually sings pretty decent, without the harsh scream or anything.

Russ205
Tuesday, February 7, 2012 9:09:29 PM
Bon.....They are both great....but I vote Bon. He his vioce is a little more shrill and devilish.
JuyceMan
Wednesday, February 8, 2012 9:21:37 AM
Bon Scott, fo sho
wheelrite
Wednesday, February 8, 2012 6:43:10 PM
I saw AC/DC in 1978 or 79 .They were the warm up band for Journey,,,
blackfoot11
Wednesday, February 8, 2012 9:07:46 PM
bon.

but..............bon is gone. brian can hit some killer notes, but not for 2 hrs. his studio stuff ia great, but not live.

i'd rather have ac/dc the way it is than none at all.............................

Lancaster6802
Wednesday, February 8, 2012 9:11:53 PM
For those about to Rock, we salute you!
wheelrite
Wednesday, February 8, 2012 9:18:46 PM

bon.

but..............bon is gone. brian can hit some killer notes, but not for 2 hrs. his studio stuff ia great, but not live.

i'd rather have ac/dc the way it is than none at all.............................

blackfoot11 wrote:

agree.,,

me and the old lady saw them again a year or so ago and they were still good...

duwan
Wednesday, February 8, 2012 10:46:59 PM
Both are equally good.
smokestaxx
Wednesday, February 8, 2012 11:59:08 PM
I love 'em both. But growing up mostly knowing brian johnson id have to say i like him a little more. I was very fortunate to be able to see them when they last came to chicago a couple years ago. Not only once but i got to see them twice during that tour. First time was on halloween weekend and the next was when they came around a second time during the winter. It was the loudest most mind blowing experience and i hope ill get another chance to see them once more!