Now here's a screwed up situation and it's even coming from a U.S. Judge...
http://reuters.myway.com/article/20050131/2005-01-31T170559Z_01_N31419718_RTRIDST_0_NEWS-SECURITY-GUANTANAMO-DC.html 

what kinda track record does this Judge have???

Hog

He was appointed by carter. need I say more?

it is a She... but yea probably appointed by Carter.. I didn't have time to look up her record...

When this one gets to the higher courts it will be over turned... there is no way these Combatants have the rights "Of" or "Two" Our Constitutional Laws....
and they do not fit in Under the Laws of the Genieva Convention....

Hog

Probably a left wing advocate of all things unAmerican! Ask him what about the rights of the people of New York City on 9/11 and the thousands of innocents that died as a result of "non battlefield combatants"!

Charlie

Charlie, those deaths are rectified... they feel that "Throwing Money" at their remaining Family's all has been taken care of....

Hog