Your favorite?

Can i vote for both?

Is it a tie?

This is a good one as I just smoked my first Roth...... Im gonna have to smoke another PCR and get back to you

Completely different. Both have a place in my humi. But, I will admit that I've bought a two cabs of R's since my last box of PCR's. Funny.....I would say that PCR is a much better cigar, however. I need to evaluate my priority and my actions.

i cant vote since i have not had either one

Totally agree other than approximate size.

Depends upon what I am drinking with it to decide which to pull from the humi.

Prefer the Rex over the Roth.

Rothchilde fresh, PCR with age. We'll have to see how the Rothchildes age.

Verocu #5 is better than both IMHO.

Agreed. Now, where's mine.

You gave them all to me, remember?

Tough choice

The joy of variety. But if u told me I could only smoke one for the rest of my life...

PCR

And I agree with eudodias. #5 is slightly better than both.

Slightly? NAh, #5 is a lot better

Hmm 🤔 I'm gonna have to re-visit the #5s again.

#5 is more dark coffee, the PCR is more chocolatey, a little sweeter. The big thing for me is that the #5 seems to have much better construction. Half the PCRs I've smoked from two different cabs have been over filled.

Just smoked a 5 the other night, damn good little smoke.

did not like the illusione rothschild I had... no, not one bit...

maybe I got a bad one, but the whole time I was smoking it all I could think was "I have no idea what all the fuss over these is about"...

I really should try another one based on the opinions of people here, but I liked it so little I have yet to revisit it...