It was definitely a freebie... The owner and his son encourage me to try everything we carry at least once...
For a very mild cigar, it wasn't bad... For the price, there are lots more I would recommend... It's more expensive than a My Father Connecticut by a couple of bucks, so that makes it a "don't buy" in my book... If someone is looking for a unique, mild cigar, I'll point it out... The size - 6x60 - was probably at least partially why I didn't enjoy it much...
Chaz - what you've stated is completely accurate.... If I haven't tried something we carry, I can't recommend it... When I walk someone through the humidor, I start with my personal favorites and do my best to describe what makes those cigars good... Usually I'm pushing My Father cigars, or if they're looking for something cheaper, Alec Bradley... I can recommend these because I've smoked them and enjoy them...
If I recommend something I don't personally enjoy, I'll probably get caught in my lie the next time they come in... People at the shop tend to take my recommendations because I'm truthful.... And if I recommend something to someone and they come back and didn't enjoy it, I usually set them up with something else at a discount...