Presidential "signing statements" have officially become a constitutional controversy. Last Wednesday, the Republican chairman of the U.S. Senate's judiciary committee, Arlen Specter, introduced legislation that would let Congress sue President Bush over such statements, which he often appends to legislation he signs.
"If the president is permitted to rewrite the bills that Congress passes and cherry-pick which provisions he likes and does not like," says Senator Specter, "he subverts the constitutional process." Earlier in the week, a blue-ribbon panel appointed by the American Bar Association filed a report arguing the same--that "the use of presidential signing statements to have the last word as to which laws will be enforced . . . poses a serious threat to the rule of law" and violates "our constitutional system of separation of powers."
Just what are signing statements? And what's the constitutional fuss? Time to review the legislative process--and to see how signing statements have been tacked on.
"I'm Just a Bill . . .
Sitting Here on Capitol Hill"
Article I, section 1, of the U.S. Constitution gives "all legislative powers herein granted" to the Congress. In other words, it says that Congress gets to make the laws of the land. Simple enough, but there's a constitutional catch: Congress's would-be laws, called "bills," generally don't take effect unless the president signs them.
Actually, once both houses of Congress have passed a bill, there are three ways it can become a law:
The president can sign it, which is what happens most of the time.
The president can veto it, and both houses of Congress can vote by two-thirds majorities to override the veto.
The president can fail to return the bill to Congress "within ten days, Sundays excepted, after it shall have been presented to him"--assuming Congress is in session. If Congress isn't in session and the president doesn't respond to a bill, the bill fails through what's known as a "pocket veto." If Congress is in session and the president fails to respond, the bill becomes a law "in like manner as if he had signed it."
According to your high school civics book and Schoolhouse Rock, that's the end of the legislative journey. The bill either becomes a law, or it doesn't. But wait, there's more.
"I'm Gonna Sign . . .
But Not Before I Opine"
Early presidents pretty much followed these constitutional rules to the letter, and the Constitution says nothing about "signing statements." George Washington, for example, once noted that the Constitution required that he either "approve all the parts of a bill, or reject it in toto."
But starting in the early 19th century, presidents periodically began appending signing statements (basically, their own executive notes) to laws they signed. In the early days, most such statements were uncontroversial. They praised the law's creators in Congress, or applauded the policy the law supported. Many were akin to today's press releases.
Every now and then, though, a president would issue a signing statement that raised a substantive legal issue--questioning a law's constitutionality, restricting its enforcement, or sidestepping some of its provisions.
Such legally substantive signing statements stirred up constitutional controversy from the start. When President Tyler used one to question the constitutionality of a bill he signed in 1842, a congressional committee protested that the Constitution empowers the president to sign bills or to veto them--not to sign them and add comments that amount to "a defacement of the public records and archives."
"You Say It's Wrong . . .
But It's My Right To Be Strong"
Prior to the 1980s, legally substantive signing statements were rare. Since the Reagan administration, however, presidents have grown fond of them. And the president who's used signing statements to challenge bills he's signed most often is President Bush.
In fact, from 1787 until 2000, all the presidential signing statements combined contained fewer than 600 challenges to the bills the presidents had signed. President Bush has made more than 800 such challenges since taking office in 2001.
Often, President Bush has used signing statements to claim the right not to enforce provisions of laws that he believes impinge on his own constitutional authority, or that he thinks are otherwise unconstitutional. But that, critics say, is itself unconstitutional.
They point straight to article I, section 7, which says, "If he approve he shall sign it, but if not he shall return it, with his objections to that House in which it shall have originated." Congress is then charged with reconsidering the bill, and has the opportunity to override the president's objection.