Haven't tried either of those. I can tell you what I know about others, in case that helps. I've got a couple of the 5 Vegas 100 count humis. Quite nice for the $ I paid here...watch the lots. I also have one of the Havana Footlocker 300 counts, got it for less than a C note. All appear to do a solid job of keeping moisture even (provided I watch them properly) and come with moisture sources and analog hygs, the latter of which have tested pretty close to same reading as two different digitals. Oh, and the aroma on opening these, which are well-stocked, has to be one of the best scents on the planet. On the 300 count, I have a pile of Gurkha in one lower section, pile of PI in the middle bottom section, and a bunch of Rocky Patel stuff in the other third. Both trays have a couple layers of cigars, and all seem to do quite nicely in there.
Hope that helps.