RICKAMAVEN
Wednesday, September 6, 2006 9:58:00 PM
by Karen Kwiatkowski,

PHD, LT COL, USAF, (RET)

The American Legion Speeches -- Preaching, Pondering and Predicting

Last week, the administration addressed the 88th annual national convention of the American Legion. Rumsfeld spoke on the 29th of August, and Bush swept up on the 31st preaching the gospel of ongoing and future military operations.

The American Legion is a busy organization of three million, with a full-time staff of 300, split between the heartland in Indianapolis and K Street, Washington, D.C. It is a solid Bush organization, and a convention in the capital of the reddest of Red States, should have been guaranteed to be hospitable to Bush. Pay no attention to the large anti-Bush rallies there and

the anti-war speech given by SLC Mayor Rocky Anderson that week.

Several years ago, the American Legion's monthly magazine featured an article entitled “The Principled Vice President Cheney.' By 2006, Americans and several billion other people around the world understood very well that Cheney had lied about the planning and motivations for the American invasion of Iraq. Most were also appalled that Cheney's Chief of Staff Scooter Libby was indicted for lying to a grand jury on a national security case in 2005.

But members of the American Legion read the papers, and they do honestly care about national security, so the President rose to the challenge and laid it on thickly in his address. He described past, present and future wars in a glorious manner.

On past wars, Bush told the Legion that Afghanistan is newly democratic, and “… the future of Afghanistan belongs to freedom.' How nice for the Afghans, I'm sure. Pay no attention to the headlines in American newspapers speaking of the resurgence of both the Taliban and al Qaeda or the words of Bush's own government bemoaning an explosion in the production of opium in Afghanistan “despite hundreds of millions of [U.S.] dollars spent to reduce the opium.' And pay no

attention to the continued fighting there.

On current wars, Bush told the Legion that Saddam Hussein is in jail, and the Iraqi people have their “sovereignty.' How nice for the Iraqis, I'm sure. He said, “America has a clear strategy to help the Iraqi people protect their new freedom, and build a democracy that can govern itself, and sustain itself, and defend itself.' Bush reported that he has been told, “only a small number of Iraqis are engaged in sectarian violence.' Pay no attention to the monthly Iraqi death count of between 1000 and 2000 dead civilians, or to the Pentagon's latest report that warns “Iraq on the

brink of civil war.' .

On future wars, Bush told the Legion that Iran is a state sponsor of terrorism, is led by a radical regime, and is seeking nuclear weapons. Bush told the Legionnaires that Iran has to make a choice, and we have already made ours. Presumably this is the same deal we gave Saddam Hussein, although it remains to be seen on whether Bush can pull off another such military fiasco in Iran in the time he has left.

Bush's speech in Utah, suggestively subtitled, “Winning the Struggle Between Freedom and Terror in the Middle East,' was in fact all about failure. He spoke of past wars (failed and not over in Afghanistan), current wars (not only failing in Iraq, but spiraling into a hated occupation, perhaps civil war, and a certain cancer on the world's oil supply), and future wars (not planned, of course – not even the bullish-on-war Mr. Bush wants to be accused of planning something as stupid as preemptively bombing or invading Iran).

Yet even the crowd of patriotic veterans associated with the American Legion and its publications could see that. Even they can think. And because they can see, and because they can think, we may better understand Rumsfeld's speech, given a few days earlier to the same crowd.

This infamous Rumsfeld speechhas already produced Pentagon “explanations' and backpedaling. For me, one of his most problematic statements, in a speech filled with problematic statements is this one, where Rumsfeld warns that in long wars or struggles, any kind of moral or intellectual confusion about who and what is right or wrong, can weaken the ability of free societies to persevere.'

In this case, Rumsfeld gets it exactly and precisely wrong. Let's summarize: Using dubious information and a whole lot of propaganda, we launched the destructive power of the world's most expensive and deadliest military on extremely weak fourth rate Middle Eastern countries of narrowly perceived strategic value in the name of promoting “democracy.' If we question this

situation on moral, ethical, logical (when they vote freely, aren't we the ones who get voted off the island first?), strategic or constitutional grounds, according to Rumsfeld, we are ourselves the enemies of “freedom.'

But Bush and Rumsfeld are right about one thing. They believe that if Americans think about and assess the Bush administration wars – overseas and at home on the Constitution – Americans will cease any remaining support for continued military actions in Afghanistan, Iraq, and potentially Iran. Rumsfeld and Bush believe that if we think, we will oppose their proposed military spending on same, and we will vote against politicians who have advocated such immoral, illegal, illogical, counter-strategic, and unconstitutional policies.

The Bush administration fears a true American legion – that growing multitude of thinking people who love this country and hate what Bush's foreign policy and domestic abuses are doing to it. This is why Rummy needed to chide, to threaten, and to name-call in a crowd of reliable and erstwhile supporters. Even in Salt Lake City, at an American Legion convention, people are increasingly morally or intellectually confused about what the Bush administration is doing around the world, and at home.

Last weeks' speeches indicate that Bush and Rumsfeld both know that if Americans become clear headed and logical, the Bush cabal loses and the party ends. Boldly unhampered by truth and increasingly menacing in tone, their words reveal panic and political desperation.

My prediction is neither earth-shattering nor genius. But between now and the November elections, every opportunity to cause American emotion to trump American intellect will be seized, squeezed and sustained by this administration and its handmaidens

adroomi
Wednesday, September 6, 2006 10:47:00 PM
A retired Air Force Colonal with a PhD? Obviously she was a liberal and only got to the rank she did because she was a lesbian and most likely a minority. What does she know? She's probably a commie too!

I just thought I'd be the first to attack this writers credibility.

good post Rick.

zoinks
Thursday, September 7, 2006 4:51:00 AM
Oh come on, commie is so passe...she's adroomified - it's mix of communism and marxism with socialism tossed in (there's really no progress from one to the other, kind of an undulating limbo), and an extreme lack of forward looking perception and knowledge.

A phd and a lt col...her phd could be in garbage can emptying and, after all, it is the air force.

Pot: Oh look the kettle is black.

"This is why Rummy needed to chide, to threaten, and to name-call"

which is exactly what the esteemed doctor is doing.

"people are increasingly morally or intellectually confused"

Presuming, of course, they were morally devoid or stupid to start with. Perhaps they are just weak and aren't true Americans.

"growing multitude of thinking people who love this country and hate what Bush's foreign policy and domestic abuses are doing to it."

Unfounded outright lie, there has been no domestic abuse. How is Bush's foreign policy different than Clinton's? Other than Clinton's pandering to China, the UN and the bhuddists, they're pretty similar.

"in long wars or struggles, any kind of moral or intellectual confusion about who and what is right or wrong, can weaken the ability of free societies to persevere"

is a perfectly valid and quite astute statement. Indeed, to deny it is to admit one's own stupidity and lack of knowledge, not to mention bad reasoning and questionable judgement.

good post Rick.

rugrunner
Thursday, September 7, 2006 4:59:00 AM
As usual, the left finds one crackpot in the group and holds them up as if they were the majority.

Like Murtha or Cindy Sheehan or the Jersey girls or Wesley clark or Richard Clark or.....

jpotts
Thursday, September 7, 2006 1:39:00 PM
"Pay no attention to the large anti-Bush rallies there and the anti-war speech given by SLC Mayor Rocky Anderson that week."

Gee, there are people out there that don't like Bush? I would have never guessed! Well, they're in good company...with the terrorists...

"Several years ago, the American Legion's monthly magazine featured an article entitled 'The Principled Vice President Cheney.' By 2006, Americans and several billion other people around the world understood very well that Cheney had lied about the planning and motivations for the American invasion of Iraq. Most were also appalled that Cheney's Chief of Staff Scooter Libby was indicted for lying to a grand jury on a national security case in 2005."

First - indicted in an invenstigation where the prosecutor knew, in advance, that no crime had been committed. By the way, he hasn't been convicted yet. Secondly, given recent evidence, this chickie's allegations about "lies" are in fact lies. So she's now a liar.

"On past wars, Bush told the Legion that Afghanistan is newly democratic, and '… the future of Afghanistan belongs to freedom.' How nice for the Afghans, I'm sure. Pay no attention to the headlines in American newspapers speaking of the resurgence of both the Taliban and al Qaeda or the words of Bush's own government bemoaning an explosion in the production of opium in Afghanistan 'despite hundreds of millions of [U.S.] dollars spent to reduce the opium.' And pay no

attention to the continued fighting there."

And is she suggesting that we give the country back to the Taliban? As if after getting pounded to a bloody frickin' pulp, the Taliban is just going to go away? She must be using some of that opium that's flowing out of Afghanistan.

Last time I checked, we crushed the Third Reich, but Nazis still exist. Maybe she's assuming we failed in WWII as well? I guess that's what a PHD gets you these days.

"On current wars, Bush told the Legion that Saddam Hussein is in jail, and the Iraqi people have their 'sovereignty.' How nice for the Iraqis, I'm sure."

Again, does anyone suggest we give Iraq back to the Baathists? This chick is an idiot.

"He said, 'America has a clear strategy to help the Iraqi people protect their new freedom, and build a democracy that can govern itself, and sustain itself, and defend itself.' Bush reported that he has been told, 'only a small number of Iraqis are engaged in sectarian violence.' Pay no attention to the monthly Iraqi death count of between 1000 and 2000 dead civilians, or to the Pentagon's latest report that warns 'Iraq on the brink of civil war.'"

And pay no attention that the Iraqi army is not in control of over 3/4s of the country, taking the lead in the fights against the terrorists, and captured a terrorist leader in recent weeks. Don't pay attention that they have their own government, the have open elections, a growing economy, falling unemployment, a growing GDP, and more electricity then prior to 2003.

Yeah, just ignore all of that. Their lives suck worse now then ever before. In fact, those mass graves we found were just landfills, and the torture / rape chambers were just badly-painted daycare centers.

Again, this chick is an idiot.

"On future wars, Bush told the Legion that Iran is a state sponsor of terrorism, is led by a radical regime, and is seeking nuclear weapons. Bush told the Legionnaires that Iran has to make a choice, and we have already made ours. Presumably this is the same deal we gave Saddam Hussein, although it remains to be seen on whether Bush can pull off another such military fiasco in Iran in the time he has left."

Or we could leave it to Clinton...who did nothing.

Once more, she's an idiot.

Bush's speech in Utah, suggestively subtitled, 'Winning the Struggle Between Freedom and Terror in the Middle East,' was in fact all about failure. He spoke of past wars (failed and not over in Afghanistan), current wars (not only failing in Iraq, but spiraling into a hated occupation, perhaps civil war, and a certain cancer on the world's oil supply), and future wars (not planned, of course – not even the bullish-on-war Mr. Bush wants to be accused of planning something as stupid as preemptively bombing or invading Iran)."

And pulling out of Iraq will make it a "not-failed" war? Or maybe we should have just left a manical dictator to remain unmolested?

What this idiot chickie doesn't know could fill volumes.

"Yet even the crowd of patriotic veterans associated with the American Legion and its publications could see that. Even they can think. And because they can see, and because they can think, we may better understand Rumsfeld's speech, given a few days earlier to the same crowd."

Obviously, thinking isn't something that comes natural to the author.

"This infamous Rumsfeld speechhas already produced Pentagon 'explanations' and backpedaling. For me, one of his most problematic statements, in a speech filled with problematic statements is this one, where Rumsfeld warns that in long wars or struggles, any kind of moral or intellectual confusion about who and what is right or wrong, can weaken the ability of free societies to persevere.'"

Yeah, we can't have ideas like "right and wrong" infuencing our thinking, can we?

"In this case, Rumsfeld gets it exactly and precisely wrong. Let's summarize: Using dubious information and a whole lot of propaganda..."

Recent events have proven out that the "dubious" information that this moron is referencing, was (in fact) correct.

"...we launched the destructive power of the world's most expensive and deadliest military on extremely weak fourth rate Middle Eastern countries..."

Prior to 1991, Iraq had the 4th largest army in the world. In fact, when we pushed them out of Kuwait, we were outnumbered by about 2 to 1. Even up to 2003, it was one of the better armed nations in the world.

Or maybe she's just upset that having a better military is just unfair?

Or maybe that she was upset that the US actually enforced the 1991 cease-fire agreement?

Again, she's an idiot.

"...of narrowly perceived strategic value in the name of promoting 'democracy.'"

Iraq had been helping both the Taliban, and Al Qaeda about the time we invaded - recently translated documents now confirm this. They had also trained terrorists in Salman Pak, and had harbored terrorist organization for decades: specifically Adu Nidal and Abu Abbas.

And writing as if democracy is some sort of imposition is just...well...looney.

"If we question this situation on moral, ethical, logical (when they vote freely, aren't we the ones who get voted off the island first?), strategic or constitutional grounds, according to Rumsfeld, we are ourselves the enemies of 'freedom.'"

Yes, you are.

Moral or ethical grounds? What part of gassing the Kurds is somehow ambiguous? So I guess all of the reports (which were proven, by the way) that torture was being used on a mass scale, and mass executions were all lies? Does these somehow not rise to the level of a moral or ethical crisis?

Idiot.

Constitutional grounds? Didn't Congress give Bush the authority to use force in Iraq? Didn't Congress vote on this?

Does this chick actually read? Oh wait, I forgot - she's an idiot.

Ok, you win. I finally got tired of responding. My head can only take so much ignorant drivel. You just have to remember one thing about this "article" : the chickie that wrote it was an idiot.

Ok, let the left-wing pile-on commence.

jpotts
Thursday, September 7, 2006 1:43:00 PM
addendum (as if anyone is actually gonna read my post):

"And pay no attention that the Iraqi army is not in control of over 3/4s of the country..."

I meant to write, "And pay no attention that the Iraqi army is NOW in control of over 3/4s of the country..."

Big difference.

sw48362
Thursday, September 7, 2006 2:09:00 PM
Turn loose the Carnies on them. Carnival people know how to deal with them.
CWFoster
Thursday, September 7, 2006 3:55:00 PM
jpotts, don't feel bad that your logic doesn't convince them. Even as basic a concept that they are fighting a "Holy War" against us, and nothing short of total capitulation, and mass conversion to Islam will settle this in the minds of the Jihadists will make any difference! I only respond so the uninformed and the fence sitters WILL know there is another viewopoint, and that it is based on logic, and historical precedent rather than feelgood emotional warm fuzzies.
jpotts
Thursday, September 7, 2006 4:31:00 PM
CWFoster:

I agree, however, if this stuff goes unchecked, people will eventually believe it.

I'm no big fan of Bush. I think in many ways he's let many people down, however, war is a tricky business. And while Bush and company have made mistakes, almost EVERY single president had made mistakes in war. Likewise, to go around criticizing a monumental achievement like the Iraq conflict (we've lost less soldiers during this conflict then in virtually any other fight we've been in) only makes matters worse. This type of tripe emboldens the enemy, weakens resolve at home, and brings confusion to the uninformed. There is such a thing as good as well as evil. Removing a muderous dictator and installing a democratic government, while flawed, is one in the "good" column. To mock that, defame, and ignore the accomplishment is evil in itself.

And it needs to be called-on.