Darbarian
Tuesday, October 10, 2006 6:38:00 PM
Hi Folks,

I just wanted to get an opinion on something that my brother has come up against in his job.

He works for CINTAS, which is a HUGE company (2nd only to Walmart in the US) that deals in uniform delivery/sales and many other service related items. He drives a uniform delivery route and his salary is based on sales and service rating. He has been with them for several months and his service rating is 96% (the next closest person in the region is less than 80%). He was getting some BIG checks, to the tune of about 1000.00/week. He was amazed by this and so asked his supervisor many times if his checks were correct. His supervisor said YES on several occasions and that the checks should get BIGGER since he is on commission and has a good rating. So, for 6 months my brother worked and used the money to pay ahead on loans to try to curb interest in the long run. Two days ago, his supervisor calls him into his office and tells him that CINTAS uses a 3rd party payroll company who had been DOUBLE paying him for the entire time. So, they told my brother that he now owes CINTAS more than 10,000 dollars, which they will be taking from his weekly checks to the tune of 300.00/week. That is 300 bucks off of his now corrected 500/week check. Leaving him with 200/week to live on.

I am probably too close to this, so I'd like to know if anyone else has ever encountered this sort of thing. Also, does anyone know of action that can be taken to combat this? CINTAS is non union and considers their decision fair.

Crazy stuff in my opinion. Too bad too, my brother really enjoys the type of work he was doing.

Thanks guys.

Darbarian

jetblasted
Tuesday, October 10, 2006 6:49:00 PM
My Air Line has Outsourced Payroll and H / R as well . . .

It sucks . . .

The same thing happened to my mom last year . .

andytv
Tuesday, October 10, 2006 6:50:00 PM
I am not aware of the law in this regard, but your brother should definitley meet with an HR employee and indicate that he notified his supervisor that he thought his checks were inappropriate and that the supervisor indicated that they were OK and that he was being paid on his merits.

Have the supervisor acknowledge these interactions in writing as well (a good HR person would do this anyway).

At least there will be a record of the issue.

Bottom line is probably this though.........the employee is responsible for understanding the structure of his/her compensation. A supervisor is often unaware of his employee's wages, etc.

The soop dropped the ball, but the issue SHOULD have been reported to payroll/HR.

Mrs.Tank
Tuesday, October 10, 2006 7:45:00 PM
I would question the percentage that they are taking. Even child support does not take that much. Since he tried to bring it up to review, they should work with him to have a more equitable payment plan. He might want to consult a lawyer also. The payroll processor could be liable for the error.

donutboy2000
Tuesday, October 10, 2006 8:15:00 PM
Legally the company is due the overpayment just like your brother would be due any underpayment he discovered. Ask for an accounting of the overpayment and attempt to negotiate a better pay back schedule.
miketv
Wednesday, October 11, 2006 6:15:00 AM
Run! You can buy a new Social Security Number for less.
Darbarian
Wednesday, October 11, 2006 3:27:00 PM
All good advice.

In the mean time, I guess my brother is screwed. I don't know what you people think about unions, but most unions that do what they are supposed to would have been able to stop this company from such a drastic paycheck cut each week. 200 bucks each week is not even a living wage with a family...let alone enough to get a lawyer to help straighten this out. He can't really even quit because they would litigate and he would lose the money in lawyer fees and then some. Wow, what a wonderful world.

The funny thing is, the supervisor admits to seeing the checks and thinking that they were just big from comission. The district manager just won't budge on the repayment schedule. I just don't know how some people sleep at nights.

Thanks again all and I hope that nothing like this happens to any of you, it is a helpless feeling.

Darbarian