RICKAMAVEN
Sunday, December 3, 2006 3:20:00 PM
SEATTLE POST-INTELLIGENCER

http://seattlepi.nwsource.com/national/1153AP_Ellison_Quran.html 

Friday, December 1, 2006 · Last updated 5:52 p.m. PT

Congressman faulted for Quran at oath

By FREDERIC J. FROMMER

ASSOCIATED PRESS WRITER

WASHINGTON -- Keith Ellison, who will become the first Muslim member of Congress next month, has offended some conservatives with his plan to use the Quran during his ceremonial swearing-in. The decision by Ellison, D-Minn., to use the Muslim holy book for the ceremony instead of the Bible triggered an angry column by Dennis Prager on the Web site Townhall.com this week.

Headlined, "America, Not Keith Ellison, decides what book a congressman takes his oath on," Prager argued that using the Quran for the ceremony "undermines American civilization."

"Insofar as a member of Congress taking an oath to serve America and uphold its values is concerned, America is interested in only one book, the Bible," he wrote. "If you are incapable of taking an oath on that book, don't serve in Congress."

Conservative bloggers have picked up the criticism and run with it.

Ellison was unavailable for comment Friday, but his incoming chief of staff, Kari Moe, dismissed the brouhaha.

"I think the criticism is being flamed by the politics of division that were rejected in the '06 election cycle," said Moe, who worked for 10 years for the late Sen. Paul Wellstone, D-Minn.

Moe, speaking in a telephone interview, noted that the tradition is for all members of Congress to be sworn in together on the House floor. It's in the photo-op ceremony that a Bible is used - or in Ellison's case, the Quran.

But Prager argued in a telephone interview that the ceremony was no less significant than the actual swearing-in.

"Oh, that's the whole point - it's exactly because it's ceremonial that it matters to me," he said. "Ceremonies matter. Ceremonies are exceedingly important. That is the way a society states what is most significant to it."

Prager argued that the issue wasn't about freedom of religion.

"I want Jews like myself to take the oath on the Bible, even though the New Testament is not our Bible," he said.

Asked if it would be a problem for a Jewish lawmaker to take the oath on a Bible that included only the Old Testament, Prager responded, "Yes, it would," because he said the point is to honor the "Bible of this country."

But despite writing that Ellison shouldn't serve in Congress if he doesn't take an oath with the Bible, Prager said he didn't think Ellison should be banned from serving.

"I don't think anything legal should be done about this," he said.

Moe said the issue was pretty straightforward.

"Religious freedom is a tradition in our country," she said.

Ellison won an open seat race to replace longtime Democratic Rep. Martin Sabo, who is retiring.

MACS
Sunday, December 3, 2006 4:04:00 PM
That's ridiculous.

If he's Muslim, what would swearing on the Bible mean to him? Let him swear in using the book of his chosen religion.

I see no harm in it.

THL
  • THL
  • Herf-A-Holic
Sunday, December 3, 2006 4:07:00 PM
As long as it doesn't lead to dancing I'm OK with it.
Dr Pepperhill
Sunday, December 3, 2006 4:08:00 PM
As usual, leadership lags. In many civil courts in this country people swear to tell the truth, and nothing but; no bible required.

Why aren't our lawmakers not taking an oath to our nation, to uphold the constitution and the laws therein prescribed? This man can worship his god in his mosque, which is protected by our constitution.

pacman357
Sunday, December 3, 2006 5:43:00 PM
Stoooooopid. I want to run for office just so I can get sworn in using an old Mad magazine.
jackconrad
Sunday, December 3, 2006 8:23:00 PM
What me worry ?
nine999
Sunday, December 3, 2006 8:40:00 PM
i'm a little confused.

what about the seperation of church and state? i am not going to claim to know much about that, but it seems to me that swearing (or being obligated to)on a bible seems to contradict that.

hmmm...

nine

RICKAMAVEN
Monday, December 4, 2006 3:09:00 AM
nine999

i would swear in on "the fountainhead."

it is my rock.

TROY6311
Monday, December 4, 2006 4:50:00 AM
Prager needs to get a life - not an issue.
victor808
Monday, December 4, 2006 6:30:00 AM
Rick,

Fountain head was tiresome...

Atlas Shrugged was a wonderful book.

What MACs said. Would any of you really trust a damn thing I said after swearing on a bible? If you don't believe it matters, then it isn't going to matter.

teedubbya
Monday, December 4, 2006 6:33:00 AM
that would be like me swearing on a box pf perdomos or PIs
Sardious
Monday, December 4, 2006 12:33:00 PM
why do we listen to some lame no body bloggers

"Some bloggers are offended that he is useing the koran"

who gives a crap?? They got there mioni space on the web if you care read it if not don't read it. I see so many post from nobody bloggers, Basing Muslims, bashing Bush, Basking Kerry, Bashing the war in Iraq. Who give a 2 bit? Every one of us here could start our own blog site. if we purosly made our views crazy extream then we'd ge mentioned even though we were just trying to stir the pot up.

We need ot stop caring about random blogs, having a web site does not make anyone credible

Dr Pepperhill
Monday, December 4, 2006 12:40:00 PM
Blogs can be legit, but aren't so simply because they exist. If a blog can back up its claims with credible sources, then they can (and will be) a welcome news resource for the coming millenium. They will be a permanent fixture in our kid's future, and will become more established and regulated, as all enduring advents ultimately do.
pacman357
Monday, December 4, 2006 1:49:00 PM
Nine, as I understand it, member are not "sworn in" with their hands on any book as part of the ceremony. They may, and some do, bring a book. As I understand it, this gentleman's plan is to bring along his copy of the Quran. Why this causes harm or offense to anyone is beyond me. I am a firm believer in the church and state separation. I think it's wrong to even have a chaplain praying over the legislative body, and Dubbya has repeatedly tried to cross that line during his administration. However, I see nothing wrong with a person bringing his/her preferred tome, whether it be religious or otherwise, if it is not part of the official ceremony.
usahog
Monday, December 4, 2006 3:28:00 PM
"Prager argued that the issue wasn't about freedom of religion."

I think Prager is full of crap... he is striking right at this man's freedom of religion...

Hog

pacman357
Monday, December 4, 2006 3:32:00 PM
Peace, love and Harley Davidson, right?^ Friend of mine who owns a '65 panhead and a '93 Fatboy swears by that anyway.