Pepper spray. MMMMMmmmmmmmmm.
Forget all these devices.
Why would you want to protect yoursef?
Just stay indoors curled up in the fetal postion.
This all comes down to what she feels the most comfortable with. If she believes the taser is best, then she'll have the courage to use it. Same for the spray or even the gun.
If she doesn't want to use it, then nothing will work.
When my girlfriend (now my wife), was working in a larger city many moons ago, she used an audible alarm. It was clipped to her purse via a pin clip (grenade style), and if her purse was stolen, or if she was in danger, she simply pulled the pin out and the friggin thing would split your eardrums.
Most bad guys don't want a crowd, so the noise causes them to leave.
Foolproof? Hardly.
But if we felt it was too dangerous for that, then she would have worked somewhere else.