Dr Pepperhill
Monday, February 5, 2007 5:21:00 PM
The Senate Resolution attempting to stymie Bush's troop surge failed today. Democrats, understanding that in times of war the executive enjoys wide discretionary powers, were trying to parlay their new majority power into the sharing in war powers, which simply isn't vested in the US constitution.

Notwithstanding the uselessness of Bush's proposed troope surge, the Democrats could have been a hell of a lot more useful by actually checking out the bogus intelligence the Bush administration was selling prior to the Iraqi invasion of 2003, rather than saving their concern for 4 years later; what a bunch of chumps.

Bush may be the worst commander & chief in US history, unfortunately, that doesn't preclude him being replaced with someone even more incompetent in 2008.

HockeyDad
Monday, February 5, 2007 5:24:00 PM
...but first we attack Iran.

Gotta get the WMD!

RICKAMAVEN
Monday, February 5, 2007 5:44:00 PM
what a bunch of chumps.

what a bunch of chicken ****.

Dr Pepperhill
Monday, February 5, 2007 5:52:00 PM
That might be a problem HD. While the executive enjoys wide discretionary powers in times of war under the constitution, the Bush administration has pretty much shot their wad on Iraq, and now the Democrats could feasibly be more troublesome regarding an all out attack in Iran than they were with Iraq.

The current administration had the opportuinity to make amazing changes in the middle east but has all but squandered their momentum. McCain is pounding the mighty drums of war loudly going into 2008 in order to keep the war machine rolling (lots of coin yet to be made), and the Democrats are in the unenviable position of not being able to crap or flee the outhouse.

jpotts
Monday, February 5, 2007 7:35:00 PM
Dr. Pepperhill:

"...the Democrats could have been a hell of a lot more useful by actually checking out the bogus intelligence the Bush administration was selling prior to the Iraqi invasion of 2003."

Senator John Edwards doesn't seem to agree with you. Here's a direct quote from his appearance on "Meet The Press", February 4th, 2007:

"For the same reason a lot of people were wrong. You know, we—the intelligence information that we got was wrong. I mean, tragically wrong. On top of that I’d—beyond that, I went back to former Clinton administration officials who gave me sort of independent information about what they believed about what was happening with Saddam’s weapon—weapons programs. They were also wrong. And, based on that, I made the wrong judgment."

Bush's "bogus" intelligence was confirmed by former Clinton people.

Look up the transcript on msnbc.com.

Dr Pepperhill
Monday, February 5, 2007 8:28:00 PM
Potts it's fine for politicisn like Jonathan Edwards to claim the intelligence 'they got' from the Bush administration or the Clinton administration was wrong using 20/20 hindsight. My complaint is that Senators and congresspersons have access to intelligence reports avaliable to them and do not bother to read and interpret those reports, much less to verify them. Therefore they end up with the intelligence 'they got' rather than ever having personally investigating it. I mean, that would require work.

Take Representative Terry Everett, a seven-term Alabama Republican who is vice chairman of the House intelligence subcommittee on technical and tactical intelligence. When asked by the national security editor at Congressional Quarterly, Jeff Stein, “Do you know the difference between a Sunni and a Shiite?” Everett answered, "One’s in one location, another’s in another location. No, to be honest with you, I don’t know."

This is just the tip of the iceberg. You think Jonathan Edwards, Nancy Pelosi, Hillary Clinton, John Kerry, or John McCain actually take the time to do personal research on the body of intelligence regarding middle eastern affairs, much less have a grasp of the historical context of the warring parties there? I doubt it. Hell I'd be amazed if they knew half of the domestic US laws they're in charge of overseeing, or even US history or the basic tenets of the US constitution or their respective state's constitutions. That's why they have staff, legal counsel, and speechwriters.

I say it's pretty hard to make judgements about intelligence, true or false, if you haven't even taken the time to look at it. And with little or no understanding of the historical or political context of a report, accurate value judgements about it are even further out of reach.

Yea Democratic senators and congresspeople were duped, but they wouldn't know they were duped unless someone sat them down and walked them through how they were duped. This is a glaring example of why propaganda is so significant; because that's about all many have to go on, including many very high office holders. These folks aren't PhDs, they read speeches from telepromptors and vote on our laws. Enough to scare the bejesus out of you.

Arcanedice
Tuesday, February 6, 2007 12:51:00 AM
So you’re suggesting each congressman maintain their own personal intelligence agency? Because that’s what would be required to validate a report from the CIA, NIA, or FBI. When a report from the CIA crosses your desk, that reflects the reports of other nations to include the liberal loved UN, I would think one might believe it. You seem to think that the issues with Iraq magically appeared the day Bush was elected and refuse to acknowledge what transpired during the Clinton administration. The difference between the two parties is the Democrats in office used Iraq to “look” strong on National Security, while the Republicans actually are.

You imply that Congressmen are just a bunch of fools who are the victims of propaganda, and it would take someone like yourself to set them strait. Generally it’s these congressmen who are the ones putting forth propaganda, or its real name “spin”. Where is this propaganda coming from that you refer to? Surely not Bush as he has no control over the CIA. Remember George Tenant was a Clinton appointee and on watch for 9/11. You are coming close to revealing your true colors here. I am guessing it involves a “cabal” or some secret organization that runs everything. Or maybe you’re not quite that far gone yet.

Your defense of Democrats is they just don’t read the reports or understand them is disingenuous of them. Granted some of these office holders are just that, pretty faces who are clueless (or not so pretty). But the majority knows what they are reading. This is why all of the Democrats were anit-Sadam during Clinton’s time in office. Today’s Democrats however are of the “talk loudly and a carry a small stick”, which they are unable to employ effectively anyway. Instead of the “talk softy and carry a big stick” which the Republicans are using quite effectively.

You should run for office.

BiggDawg
Tuesday, February 6, 2007 6:19:00 AM
So, if a NONBINDING resolution gets rejected, is that BINDING?
THL
  • THL
  • Herf-A-Holic
Tuesday, February 6, 2007 6:34:00 AM
Good point Bigdawg. Unless you cut funding, it's just chest thumping. And they don't even have the nerve for that.
HockeyDad
Tuesday, February 6, 2007 6:38:00 AM
The resolution actually has not been rejected as Dr Pepperhill has reported. All that has happened is that a vote to end debate on the resolution has failed because the Republicans want to discuss it further. I believe that once the resolution has been discussed and modified to everyone's content, it will be able to be voted on and passed and immediately enter into its full non-binding force.

I expect the final form of the resolution will call for the full and immediate end to Winter in the continental United States. Of course, it will still be non-binding.

Arcanedice
Tuesday, February 6, 2007 7:24:00 AM
Nope, the resolution did not pass. Reid voted no, but it was only a procedural "no", that way he can reintroduce it. The resolution was considered by many to be a lack of support for the mission, and demoralizing for the troops if it would have passed.
Dr Pepperhill
Tuesday, February 6, 2007 8:29:00 AM
You should run for office Diceman, you read my post apparently, but completely misinterpret the content; a shining example of the message I was trying to convey in post # 6.I wasn't defending the democrtas (or republicans), I was issuing a scathing criticism. There's a congressional office somewhere with your name plate on it, you'll fit right in.

Hockey, you may be an expert in profiting off human suffering, but politically, when a bill, resolution, etc., gets taken out of committee, and effectively shelved for later consideration, it is for all practical purposes a dead letter.

HockeyDad
Tuesday, February 6, 2007 8:41:00 AM
...But Dr Pepperhill, the bill was not taken out of committee or shelved...

The vote that failed was a motion to proceed which required 60% to pass and would have ended discussion and advanced it to a final vote. As a result, discussion continues and no final vote has been taken.

You have interpreted this to mean the bill is killed when in fact it is "fillibustered".

Speaking of profitting from human suffering, did you see that the governor of Texas is making it mandatory that schoolgirls take Merck's new vaccine for papillomavirus?

8trackdisco
Tuesday, February 6, 2007 8:52:00 AM
'..Bush may be the worst commander & chief in US history,..'

-----------------------------------------------------

Martin Van Buren, Herbert Hoover & especially Andrew Jackson were worse. But he's probably looking up to Nixon.

jpotts
Tuesday, February 6, 2007 9:07:00 AM
Dr. Pepperhill:

"Yea Democratic senators and congresspeople were duped, but they wouldn't know they were duped unless someone sat them down and walked them through how they were duped."

You should read some of the summary of the Iraq Survey Group's analysis on both WMDs and their sources, specifically the story of an informant code-named (I think) "Screwball". Or to the purpose of specific dual-use pieces of equipment Saddam possessed, and how many different intelligence agencies came up with their own conclusions on what these items "could" be used for. While I strongly disagree with the ISG's assessment in this specific area, it's stark example of how something like an aluminum tube can be interpreted some fifteen ways from Sunday by any given intelligence agency.

Two or three agencies specified that the aluminum tubes in question could be used for enriching uranium, four said that they couldn't, and the final analysis in the ISG was that, even though they coould be used in some manner to enrich uranium, ir possible that they were used to make rockets...probably...maybe...whatever.

So, as for being "stepped through" how Edwards was being duped, that all depends on who is doing the analysis of the data. However, he did admit to taking the additional step of consulting some of Clinton's people on the intelligence, and they gave him basically the same assessment. Then when you start mining into all of the other foreign intelligence agencies that came out with the same exact assessments, you start getting a picture that Bush didn't lie. Edwards, perhaps being the bonehead everyone thinks he is, just added one more crack in the foundation of the "Bush lied" camp.

jpotts
Tuesday, February 6, 2007 9:14:00 AM
HockeyDad:

I'd have to agree with Dr. Pepperhill - the bill is essentially dead. The aim of the democrats is to get as much through congress as it possible in the first 100 days. The senate obsessing over a non-binding resolution that probably doesn't poll well (let's face it, they originally had some republicans on their side that abandoned it when it came time to vote) doesn't do anything to achieve that goal. Plus, there are also two other non-binding resolutions that are waiting in the wings, and will take up time in committee as well.

For the most, it's shelved. I'd be surprised if it was kept alive at this point.

HockeyDad
Tuesday, February 6, 2007 9:36:00 AM
The beauty of it is that while it is fillibustered and may be esentially dead, it still isn't dead. It still has to be debated. It is still on the calendar. Leadership still has to yank the bill to kill it. They kept it alive because it is on the "to-do" list.

Look on the bright side, would you rather the Demoncrap-controlled Senate to be logjammed debating a non-binding resolution or actually trying to pass laws that the US House could agree to and then force the President to actually veto?

Stalemate = Status Quo = Plunder On!