I am not an expert on this.
Stuff like BrassEx and other cleaners tend to be acidic in nature, which means that there is the potential that while cleaning your roof, you're actually eating away at the material. It's akin to dropping a penny into a glass of vinegar overnight, and letting the acid eat away at the outer layer. next morning the end result is a nice, shiny penny.
Using steelwool or an abrasive, by their very nature, erodes the material of your roof as well. It does so by tearing off micro-ribbons and particles from whatever it rubs up against. What produces a shiny copper surface are millions (billions) of fine scratches in the copper that reflect and diffuse light.
That green oxidized build-up generally tends to protect the copper once it is established (which is one of the reasons why copper tends to last a long time as roofing material).
I've heard that after cleaning, a couple layers of a clear polyureathane will keep the original burnished copper color going for a long time. I'd check a handyman web page to see how to do this.