Jay, in your search for good stogies, I recommend this guy's review's:
https://kohnhed.com/
He pretty much only critiques sticks that friends of his send him, doesn't receive and evaluate free sticks from cigar companies nor does he receive any other form of compensation from them that I can tell. He is as much of a FILTER as he is a PUMP of product and isn't afraid to call Cigar Aficionado/Advisor out on their (often) BS reviews. He calls it as he sees it. Only issue is sometimes friends send him some pretty obscure stuff thats very hard if not impossible to find but a lot of what he reviews can be had right here on CI/Cbid.
He's also a hoot to read - was a bass guitar player for The Police and some other bands and has some great stories that he intermixes with his very colorful reviews.
Naturally everyone has their own tastes and you may end up generally disagreeing with his opinions but it gives you a good place to start IMO.
Also I follow CigarObsession on youtube and halfwheel.com, two other review sites that seem to have set up a good firewall between them and cigar producer influence/money.
Last, as you have suspected, there's a sh.tload of talent and experience here on this site and they can make great, informed recommendations (once you find and mute out the prolific [but minority] very fake Platinum Members Squad (PMS, perfect acronym). Their noble mission is to scare away as much bidding competition as possible w/ sophomoric level hazing and circle jerking. (I'm looking at you TonySpaz [If Bif from BTTF and Brick from Anchorman had a gay love child, that child would be TonySpaz]). Many of these few also suffer from Chronic Stockholm Syndrome. Criticize any aspect of Cbid (present debacle included) and you do so at your own peril. Aside from TonySpaz (I singled him out specifically because he's a PMS leader on very high doses of Midol, is particularly noisome AND is a Hillary Clinton Surrogate) but the rest of the PMS will reveal themselves to you soon enough...probably in response to this post, at my expense I'm sure (hopefully they don't take away my birthday) making it even easier for you to identify. My gift to you, fellow noob.
Enjoy the journey and welcome aboard!
LawOfMD wrote: