zoinks
Friday, August 11, 2006 8:34:00 AM
victor,

"I see we have some true rocket scientists offering suggestions here."

I didn't see you in my class, are you a recent grad?

More military personnel die in auto accidents in the US than die fighting in Iraq. If we raised the age of military service to 20, would that help?

Did you know the number of people killed by elephants in the US spiked recently? Not sure if it's a trend or just a spike, but it warrants concern.

If we held a lottery and weighted the drawing, we could just offer up some old people to the terrorists to kill. Some may not go for that though.

Or maybe just work closer with the terrorists, in the spirit of better global relations. Sort of like land for peace, except life for peace. We could plan a 90% off Disney tickets promotion for those over 60 with a free buffet and fly them all there on one plane, and let the terrorists blow up that one. Doing that every 14 or 16 months should make the terrorists happy, then they'd leave the rest of us alone.

victor808
Friday, August 11, 2006 8:41:00 AM
Please charlie,

compare for me the cost to our economy from the terrorist attack vs. our costs at trying to stop further attacks? I don't have the numbers, but I seriously doubt that you are going to come out ahead.

Here are a few guidelines

Cost of the terrorist attack: This should include, structural costs (building), rebuild costs, diusruptive costs (loss of business), transportation costs (airline industry) and any others you may have.

Cost for "preventative" measures: Since everyone seems to think we are "fighting them there", you should include our little invasion costs (Iraq), Homeland security costs, costs incurred when "keeping our border safe" (including dockyards, borders). Note, these are all annual costs so each year's cost, as well as future costs should be converted into today's dollar (you may use any time value of money you would like). Since we are assuming a 5 year cycle between attacks, let's cut projections out at 5 years rather than to infinity.

Alternatively you could assume an attack every 5 years, convert the cost of future attacks into current dollars, and amortize the costs of prevention out to infinity. Your choice.

Charlie
Friday, August 11, 2006 8:43:00 AM
Victor

So, you would let the terrorist pick out a target and blast away every few years to keep them happy?

You are a real dreamer.

Charlie

victor808
Friday, August 11, 2006 8:44:00 AM
I don't think you got the point Zoinks
lofty1
Friday, August 11, 2006 8:47:00 AM
for someone to even imply that losing 1000 innocent lives to terrorism is acceptable is disturbing. i can't believe i just read that. i sincerely hope i misunderstood, but i'm pretty sure i didn't.

Charlie
Friday, August 11, 2006 8:47:00 AM
LOL
victor808
Friday, August 11, 2006 8:47:00 AM
And neither did Charlie....

The point is that we shouldn't have fundamentally changed who we are as Americans and what Americans stand for simply because a few of us explode every now and then. The concept of liberty and freedom in our country and for our citizens is much more valuable than the small number of lives lost.

If you are not willing to give up the freedoms teenage drivers to save 5000 people annually, why are you so willing to give up your freedoms (and those of other americans) to save less than 1000 annually? (Note, I'm assuming that you are not willing to raise the driving age to 20).

lofty1
Friday, August 11, 2006 8:51:00 AM
"The point is that we shouldn't have fundamentally changed who we are as Americans and what Americans stand for simply because a few of us explode every now and then. The concept of liberty and freedom in our country and for our citizens is much more valuable than the small number of lives lost."

wow. just wow.

Charlie
Friday, August 11, 2006 8:57:00 AM
I cannot believe this thread...

Just think on Dec 7, 1941 if we had thought like some of the guys on this forum......we would all be speaking Japanese right now....

Charlie

victor808
Friday, August 11, 2006 8:58:00 AM
Please explain Charlie.
Charlie
Friday, August 11, 2006 9:01:00 AM
Explain? Ok, it was only a few battleships and less than 3,000 people lost, so why bother.........that would seem to be your stance the way I am reading your posts.

Charlie

bloody spaniard
Friday, August 11, 2006 9:02:00 AM
Yes, explain the obvious to our resident Pollyana, Charlie.

Lofty, he is VERY confused.

He's more concerned about Christians and their "close- mindedness" than he is in his own myopia.

He worries not about the illegal situation, the thousands of businesses that went under after September 11, or about the pending American Union which will further erode our ability to maintain a high standard of living.

No, he is apparently unconcerned that businessmen like me lost 40%+ of our business due to the the rippling effects of terrorism

To him, the muslim menace is nothing but a figment of our over- active and provincially small American imaginations.

What a child.

He is content as long as he can throw out "impressive" stats which have nothing to do with our problem.

bloody spaniard
Friday, August 11, 2006 9:10:00 AM
Btw, has anyone bothered to mention to our resident know-it-all(s) that white men are being profiled EVERY DAY when they are turned down for jobs/advancement due to their race so that others, who don't score as high as they, can get a "break"?

I guess that this kind of profiling is good, right?

Get over yourself.

usahog
Friday, August 11, 2006 9:12:00 AM
I like to visit 711's and ask the clerks...

Hey ain't you wanna them stupid b@stards that like to shove your thumb up your a$$ and blow yourselves up??

Or

didn't I see parts of you on CNN Yesterday?

That always gets a good conversation started although I can't quite make out what their saying??

Have we cought the last 6 of 11 egytions yet?

now I got that silly a$$ song "Walk Like and Egytion" stuck in my head...Thanks Bloody!

Hog

victor808
Friday, August 11, 2006 9:28:00 AM
BS,

If you look in my previous response to Charlie, I did ask him to estimate a dollar value for business losses. I realize that some businesses suffered losses. The question is how this compares to the economic impact of our current "war on terror".

A smart administration would be spending their money on trying to find ways to root out the underlying cause of these attacks, rather than trying to fight an enemy which has no head, head on.

Charlie,

there is a difference between a terrorist attack from individuals with no permanent country and a sneak attack from uniformed troops. We had a clear enemy back then. I have no problem with war, combat and death. As long as we know who we are fighting and how to do it.

Hog,

I hope you are joking. Otherwise you are even worse than I thought.

zoinks
Friday, August 11, 2006 9:38:00 AM
victor,

I got your point, it was just a meaningless stupid one, that's all.

Government supplied free prostitutes would stop rapes. It would not only relieve the trauma of many women, not that that would matter to you, but it would save alot in legal costs that are currently spent to arrest and prosecute rapists. It could also be filmed and the government would make money from selling the x-rated movies. It would also provide more work for abortion doctors, and their nurses, thus benefiting the economy even more.

Charlie
Friday, August 11, 2006 9:45:00 AM
zoinks

Good analogy....free prostitutes for all...no more prostitution on the streets...

Charlie

jpotts
Friday, August 11, 2006 9:52:00 AM
jetblasted:

I was only kidding. Loved the post.

jpotts
Friday, August 11, 2006 9:57:00 AM
victor808:

"A smart administration would be spending their money on trying to find ways to root out the underlying cause of these attacks, rather than trying to fight an enemy which has no head, head on."

How does one root out hate, ignorance, and stupidity? How do you negotiate with someone who's prime focus is to kill you, or subjugate your life to Islam?

Funny, but back in the 40s, I didn't see anyone wanting to try and figure out how to root the hated out of the Nazis. Maybe becaue they were smart enough back them to realize that you can't.

bloody spaniard
Friday, August 11, 2006 10:00:00 AM
55. Author: victor808 Date: 08/11/2006 01:28 PM Reply

"BS, If you look in my previous response to Charlie, I did ask him to estimate a dollar value for business losses. I realize that some businesses suffered losses. The question is how this compares to the economic impact of our current "war on terror". "

*RESPONSE: There is no answer to your question. How can you put a value on a future terror that cannot be measured?

"A smart administration would be spending their money on trying to find ways to root out the underlying cause of these attacks, rather than trying to fight an enemy which has no head, head on."

*Victor, you are projecting your Western values/judgement system onto an enemy who is irrationally driven by his hate.

You cannot negotiate with a savage who wants to kill you if you don't convert and abandon your "decadent" ways.

No offense, but you just don't get it, brother.

You are either an appeaser by design or simply don't have a clue about the workings of the enemy's mind.

You can't dissuade him with your "open-mindedness".

You and HockeyDad should start your own chapter of the Neville Chamberlain fan club.

You two can pay the member's fees so that they like you and want to stay.

Christians need not apply of course.