dwalt10048
Saturday, February 3, 2007 8:55:00 PM
SFraun, I think I remember you mentioning you knew Marcel from Top Chef. What did you think about him going as far as he did? I wasn't happy he got to the finals. He seems like an Ahole. I was rooting for either Sam or Elia.
Sfraun04
Saturday, February 3, 2007 9:14:00 PM
I can look back at every episode, and mention one person that he OUTCOOKED. It's a cooking competition.

NOW, I do agree thatat a Top Chef is sort of an ambassador, and along with superior cooking skills should also have excellent interpersonal communication skills. If you take a further step back from the show and understand that he's being straight forward the entire time, then you see that Marcel's attitude is a lot better than a lot of people's.

After the show there was an interview with Ilan and Marcel on BravoTV.com. He admitted that when he was a teaching assistant at my school (certain program you can get into), he came across as a ****** to a lot only because he felt he had to be that assertive to teach people. He was right.

I thought the final would come down to Ilan, Elia, Sam or Cliff. Cliff's true colors came through and I knew he couldn't make it. Elia was too classic to do it, so I thought Sam and Ilan would be perfect. Unfortunately for Sam, he didn't step up enough in that last challenge.

dwalt10048
Saturday, February 3, 2007 9:27:00 PM
Agreed, I thought Cliff lost it the last few shows. Forget beatin up Marcel, His last few shows he seemed to slip. I think one of the main reasons Marcel lost was that Sam helped him with that dish where they forgot the fish. Marcel said it was both of them coming up with it, seemed like it was all Sam. If it couldn't be Sam, Elian seemed a decent Top Chef. I did like Elia, but she was a little young. I love to eat and eat well so that show is up my alley. I like to cook too, and would love to turn out food like you guys, but that ain't happening. Cook on friend!

(Who was the one you thought Marcel actually outcooked?

Sfraun04
Saturday, February 3, 2007 9:36:00 PM
Cliff just showed he didn't have much leadership skills, and he was letting his team down. Also, I felt he worried more about presentation over flavor based on what I was told was in his dishes.

I think Marcel lost because he went a little too crazy on his dishes. Ilan used his expertise of Spanish cuisine coupled with what he knew of Hawaiian cuisine PLUS utilization of product (his dessert was the best idea) to win it. Marcel tried to bring in his gastronomy expertise, and it edded up hurting him. Marcel has a great gasp of pairings and such, but he just went a little too broad.

As far as your Elia comment, age doesn't matter. Ilan won at 24, and Harold was 26 I think. Hell, I'm gonna be 24 in a couple days...maybe I should try out.

Top Chef is the one true cooking reality show on TV now (PBS had a great one with Ming Sai as one of the hosts, but it never made it unfortunately). I love watching it.

Name an episode and I'll tell you who Marcel outcooked.

dwalt10048
Saturday, February 3, 2007 9:45:00 PM
A) You should Stefan! I didn't realize all these folks were that young. (Happy birthday by the way!)

B) Had to be the Firehouse show? If not then the beach?

My guess is the caterer lady Betty.

Sfraun04
Saturday, February 3, 2007 9:53:00 PM
Thank you sir (though it's still a few days away). I've been asked why I don't try, and I'll post it here. Many of these chefs on there have used ingredients I have no experience with. I'd have to travel around, and get familiar with other ingredients before I try anything like that.

Betty showed her true colors one episode, and you knew from there that is was just plain ugly. If it were a catering show, she'd be fine. However, get further in the challenges and she wouldn't have much of an idea how to utilize ingredients for individual dishes.

Firehouse show he was in the middle of the pack then. Some of those dishes were scary! Same with the beach. Though the beach challenge was a gamble, and Frank was screwed from the get-go.

pabloescabar
Saturday, February 3, 2007 10:06:00 PM
looks like Sfraun04 found a new friend, I hope it's a dude unquote
dwalt10048
Saturday, February 3, 2007 10:08:00 PM
I was never a big fan of Betty.

Are the folks that make the cut just to get on the show already big time Chefs, or are they young guns with a lot of talent looking for a break? It seems that to even make the cut to get on a show like that you have to have some decent experience behind you.

Even Mikey was throwing out some sweet looking dishes and they kept bringing up how he worked at TGIF's, Chile's, etc. He seemed like he could do a lot more than cooking a burger.

I think I know what you mean about the ingredients. Some of the pairings seemed bizzare, but I guess they make them work. I guess some things are classic pairings, but one of the things I like about the show is seeing some of those odd combo's.

Someday I hope to taste something you prepare Stefan! I know it's hard work, but always know that there are fatso's like me that truly appreciate the skill you guys and gals have!

Did you ever see Hell's Kitchen? Those chefs don't seem like they could hold a candle to the folks on Top Chef.

Sfraun04
Saturday, February 3, 2007 10:15:00 PM
They're all people that apply to be on the show. Check out the Braovtv.com website; you'll see their casting videos and all. Marcell and Otto (who used to be my instructor) are nowhere near bg time.

Mike was smart enough to see what the people around him were doing, and learn off that. That's my theory on it.

A lot of them utilized pairings that are not uncommon, or ones that make sense. When I said "scary," I meant like Frank's trip through the mushroom forest LOL

I love cooking, and would never turn it down. In fact, I got a guy that asked for some nicer things for is place for tomorrow. I should be sleeping since I need to be up earlier to get to the fish market. Oh well...

I watch Hell's Kitche; I think it's hilarious. I actually sent in an application for **** and giggles LOL

pabloescabar
Saturday, February 3, 2007 10:24:00 PM
hey Sfraun04, why don't ya ask dwalt10048 ta post a pic ya sick bastid.
erkwgz
Saturday, February 3, 2007 10:26:00 PM
What the hell were you doing watching PBS?
pabloescabar
Saturday, February 3, 2007 10:27:00 PM
it's better than DSL
Sfraun04
Saturday, February 3, 2007 10:28:00 PM
I concur Pablo
pabloescabar
Saturday, February 3, 2007 10:30:00 PM
what say you Erkowits
erkwgz
Saturday, February 3, 2007 10:32:00 PM
I say you both got DSL

Go talk to dewalt.

Sfraun04
Saturday, February 3, 2007 10:33:00 PM
Damn Erik's bitchy all of a sudden

Need a tissue? Or one of your wife's tampons?

pabloescabar
Saturday, February 3, 2007 10:33:00 PM
I want pics first
Sfraun04
Saturday, February 3, 2007 10:34:00 PM
Of Dewalt or Erik's tampons?
erkwgz
Saturday, February 3, 2007 10:35:00 PM
I got a pic of Pablo I need to post.
pabloescabar
Saturday, February 3, 2007 10:36:00 PM
yeah what'eva...