teedubbya
Tuesday, May 15, 2007 11:49:00 AM
Son of professor opposed to war is killed in Iraq

By Brian MacQuarrie, Globe Staff | May 15, 2007

Boston University professor Andrew J. Bacevich has been a persistent, vocal critic of the Iraq war, calling the conflict a catastrophic failure. This week, the retired Army lieutenant colonel received the grim news that his son had been killed on patrol there.

First Lieutenant Andrew J. Bacevich , 27, of Walpole, died Sunday in Balad of wounds he suffered after a bomb explosion, the military said yesterday. The soldier, who graduated from BU in 2003 with a degree in communications, is the 56th service member from Massachusetts to be killed in Iraq.

His father, a veteran of the Vietnam and Gulf wars, has criticized the war in his writings and described President Bush's endorsement of such "preventive wars" as "immoral, illicit, and imprudent."

A West Point graduate and former faculty member at both West Point and Johns Hopkins University, Bacevich joined the BU faculty in 1998 and teaches in the history and international relations departments. He has written books on US diplomacy and military power and has contributed op-ed pieces on the Iraq war to newspapers and periodicals.

In an op-ed column published March 1 in the Globe, Bacevich wrote that "our reckless flirtation with preventive war qualifies as not only wrong, but also stupid. Indeed, the Bush Doctrine poses a greater danger to the United States than do the perils it supposedly guards against.

"We urgently need to abrogate that doctrine in favor of principles that reflect our true interests and our professed moral values," Bacevich wrote.

Katy Bacevich, 22, one of the soldier's three sisters, recalled her brother as a born leader who answered a calling to serve his country. Andrew Bacevich joined the Army in July 2004 and had been stationed in Iraq since October with the Third Brigade Combat Team, First Cavalry Division.

"He felt it was an important thing to do, regardless of the war that was going on," she said. Despite her father's strong feelings about the conflict, Katy Bacevich said, "he never would discourage my brother from doing what he wanted to do."

The family moved to Walpole in 1998 from the Maryland suburbs of Washington, D.C., she said.

A former military comrade of the elder Bacevich was shaken by the news yesterday.

Retired Major General William Nash served with Bacevich, also known as Skip, in Kuwait. "Service to country was obviously a family trait," Nash said. "Skip was a great role model for young officers."

BU professor William Keylor, who also teaches history and international relations, supervised final exams for one of Bacevich's classes yesterday. He said faculty members were "devastated."

"They knew how close the two Andys had been and, particularly those of us who have children, just identified so strongly with him," Keylor said.

The students taking that final exam, Keylor said, were not told of their professor's loss so as not to distract them from other finals. The course, called The American Military Experience, included discussion of the relationship between citizenship and the obligation of military service, according to BU's website.

Professor Bacevich maintained contact with his son by e-mail, Keylor said. "Every time, the word was things are going well, no problems. Then I got a call from him last night with this terrible news," Keylor added.

"He resembled his father so closely that, when you saw him, you immediately thought of Andy Sr.," Keylor said. "His father and mother absolutely adored him."

Keylor described the younger Bacevich, whom he had taught in a two-semester class on international relations, as a good student who wanted to follow in his father's footsteps. "I had the impression of a very popular, likable, exuberant young man," he said. The younger Bacevich had been enrolled in the Army ROTC at BU.

When interviewed by the Globe recently, Professor Bacevich had requested that his son's service in Iraq not be mentioned -- both to limit unwanted attention on his son and to separate the father's professional opinion from the heavy personal stakes.

Behind that request, however, "I always had the impression that he was terribly proud of his son and the service he was providing," Keylor said.

The elder Bacevich was sounding his warnings about the war at the time of the US-led invasion in March 2003. Bacevich wrote in the Los Angeles Times that month that "if, as seems probable, the effort encounters greater resistance than its architects imagine, our way of life may find itself tested in ways that will make the Vietnam War look like a mere blip in American history."

Keylor said Bacevich appeared to come to his opinions about the Iraq war after much thought.

"He's a very learned man, and I think that he studied the background to the war very carefully, and only came out with his strong opinions after he had really, really looked it over," Keylor said. "He's not the kind of guy who shoots from the hip."

Bryan Bender of the Globe staff contributed to this report from Washington.

pmn1
Tuesday, May 15, 2007 11:54:00 AM
Friendly Fire strikes again.
teedubbya
Tuesday, May 15, 2007 11:56:00 AM
I'm sure he is just a wacko or spineless or just effed in the head like anyone else against this war
cbc812
Tuesday, May 15, 2007 12:13:00 PM
^ You got that right!

It is disrespectful to his son that he is against the war that killed him! He should be honored that his son was killed, right? Because if he doesn't want our soldiers to die, he's not supporting them, right? How unpatriotic!

F'in liberal, dog-marrying Massachusetts America hater, that's what this guy is.

jpotts
Tuesday, May 15, 2007 12:20:00 PM
"Katy Bacevich said, 'he never would discourage my brother from doing what he wanted to do.'"

Obviously, his son believed he was doing the right thing. He was, by the way, doing the right thing.

teedubbya
Tuesday, May 15, 2007 12:21:00 PM
And I am sure his father is just a wacko or spineless or just effed in the head like anyone else against this war
teedubbya
Tuesday, May 15, 2007 12:22:00 PM
who respected his son's decision while being against the war......

what a wacko

Charlie
Tuesday, May 15, 2007 12:22:00 PM
RIP brave warrior.

Charlie

jpotts
Tuesday, May 15, 2007 12:23:00 PM
Well, at the very least, he was wrong. Not sure about the "wacko" part.

I'm sure there were lots of people that justified their inaction while that 90+ year-old guy got the sh*t kicked out of him when he was being carjacked in Detroit.

Doesn't make what they did right.

teedubbya
Tuesday, May 15, 2007 12:29:00 PM
lol his background be damned. He is wrong and the equivelent of a bystandard that did nothing when a 90 year old got carjacked.

unreal

And I'm wit ya Charlie god bless his soul. I wonder how his father will be treated for remaining against the war.

teedubbya
Tuesday, May 15, 2007 12:31:00 PM
it is possible to be pro military and anti this rediculas war
victor808
Tuesday, May 15, 2007 12:43:00 PM
no it isn't.

If cornwallace wants to throw 5 new recruits into China and call it an invasion, you MUST support the action. Suggesting it will get those 5 guys killed is tatamount to treason and you will be put in gitmo.

cbc812
Tuesday, May 15, 2007 12:43:00 PM
^ #11

TW - Shame on you! That is absolutely impossible. If you do not worship the policy, nay, every word of our Dear Leader, you cannot possibly be a supporter of the military, or the country, or anything, you godless heathen.

The only way to be pro military is to send them into a war that you are wholly unprepared to finish, skimp on armor, training, weaponry, interpreters, medical care back home, and benefits for veterans, and to keep them there, since bringing them home would be disrecpectful to them.

Geez, get a clue, man. You actually think that this war was a bad idea, and that it's not going splendidly? You must DETEST the military and our soldiers. I wouldn't be surprised if you were a jihadist yourself. Or a tree-marrying gay liberal. Is there a difference?

teedubbya
Tuesday, May 15, 2007 12:48:00 PM
I'm sorry. It will not happen again.
teedubbya
Tuesday, May 15, 2007 12:48:00 PM
And I did hear China was behind 911 and Bush has secret proof he can not make public for national security reasons.
jpotts
Tuesday, May 15, 2007 12:53:00 PM
Guys,

US Citizens voted Bush into office - twice. Once before a war, and during the middle of one.

Congress has voted to fund this war since its inception, and all of them were voted in by US citizens. Most likely, congress will continue to fund the war for another 2 years (just speculating here).

All of the people going to war have volunteered knowing full-well that they can be sent off to war at any given time. No one is forcing them into the service.

It's the way the country works. What people don't really like is the fact that they lost several elections. Bush and his "war mongering" has little to do with it.

You have a chance every 2 years to change the direction of this country. You can stamp your feet all you want, but this is thus far the will of the majority of the US citizenry.

I personally feel sorry for the father. But I know if it were my kid, I'd support him, or at the very least talk about my dissent with him privately. I don't think I'd publicy p*ss all over what he's doing (unless it was clearly, morally wrong).

There is a lot of ambiguity in this war. No one side has a clear moral position.

pmn1
Tuesday, May 15, 2007 12:57:00 PM
Pottsie - It wasn't the majority of the American people it was the majority of the electoral college.
teedubbya
Tuesday, May 15, 2007 12:58:00 PM
"There is a lot of ambiguity in this war. No one side has a clear moral position. "

WOW.

I didn't lose elections. I voted the butthole in the first time. Saw the light the second time, and the citizens of this fine country saw the light a little later (couple years).

This father has been in the military and teaching presumably for some time. His son joined after he was already making his viewpoint known.

So now fathers must cease and decist when their sons join?

Much like the Tillmans should just shut up about things.

I do agree there is a lot of ambiguity in this war. No one side has a clear moral position. Thats refreshing to finally hear.

jpotts
Tuesday, May 15, 2007 2:00:00 PM
pmn1:

"Pottsie - It wasn't the majority of the American people it was the majority of the electoral college."

It's called "representitive government". We all (ideally) know the rules of voting for president. He is just one person that we vote for.

You also vote for a congressman and senator...every 2 years. That's the counter-balance.

Again, people are stamping their feet because they lost elections. Now they're stamping their feet because they didn't win big like they thought they would (or made the assumption that every democratic electee was anti-war, and every republican electee was pro-war).

If there is a fault in the system, it is that people you elected vote the party line, and not their conscience, or as they said they would. You have roughly another 1 1/2 years to rectify that.

jpotts
Tuesday, May 15, 2007 2:49:00 PM
teedubbya:

WOW.

"...and the citizens of this fine country saw the light a little later (couple years)."

I personally don't like Bush, but I have a real hard time justifying about 75% of the criticism leveled in his direction. I personally think it's delusional.

The other 25% is spot on.

"So now fathers must cease and decist when their sons join?"

Yes.

What his son did is not illegal. What his son is doing is not immoral. Acts of war my be terrible, and war itself may be horrible, but it is an unfortunate fact of life that wars must be fought.

We were attacked. Our failure to respond would have been criminal, and undoubtedly would have lead to more attacks. I think there is and was more then enough justification (without it being declassified) to go after Iraq.

Given the strategy of the enemy we're fighting - and the fact that they've basically TOLD us what their strategy is - it serves no good purpose to rant and rave about the war effort in the manner that many do.

"Much like the Tillmans should just shut up about things."

Personally, I think the Tillman's are picking a scab that will lead them nowhere in the end. And I think it dishonors the memory of their deceased family member.

"I do agree there is a lot of ambiguity in this war. No one side has a clear moral position. Thats refreshing to finally hear."

First, I'd like to point out that there is no such thing as a "perfect decision." Some decisions can be one-sidedly good or bad, but none of them ar perfect.

There is ambiguity in every war, and it's not a decision that should be made lightly. It wasn't exactly a moral thing the United States did when they decided to bomb the hell out of civilians during WWII, nor was it a moral thing to do when Union troops raided private residences in the South (and did their own share of raping and pillaging).

What was the alternative?

Lots of things go on that we don't like in the world. Murder isn't exactly high on my "likes" list, nor are child molestors. These things exist, and they will always exist until Man fundamentally changes. Unfortunately that's not going to happen any time soon.

All I really want is to be left alone, and to live my life in peace. Unfortunately, there are people over in the Middle East that get their kicks flying planes into buildings, and caning women for wearing nail polish. There are people over in the Middle East that think it's all cool sending suicide bombers into pizza parlors, and like to fund terrorist missions both home and abroad (here).

How does this all affect me? It really didn't until they started ramming planes into buildings over in New York and Washington DC. Why? Because if they will do it there, and to other US citizens, they will do it to me too. In fact, these same people have said, and quite publicly, that their express intent is to bring about the downfall of the United States, and place us all over the coverage of a specific form of Islam.

So yeah, that kinda affects me.

And all of this belly-aching about gay marriage, abortion, and universal healthcare kinda takes a backseat to the whole "we're going to kill or enslave you" thing. And for those out there reading this that think that this nation is immune from being toppled by a bunch of people who live in caves and wipe their butts with their hands, I've read of stranger things happening. I'm sure there were quite a few Romans that scoffed at those zany Visigoths many, many centuries ago.

Do I agree that war a bad thing? Yes. You'd have to be insane to say that it isn't, and people who criticize me for supporting this war do themselves a grave disservice by assuming that I just like to see people come back dead from Iraq (then again, I've seen some of the errant thinking that belies this attitude). Given the midset of the people we're fighting, we have no rational choice but to use aggressive force. These people don't beleive in diplomacy (we tried 12 years of it with Iraq, and it got us virtually nowhere), they certainally don't believe in civil rights, and they don't really care how many people they kill. Yet, there are some people out there that seem to think that you can rationalize with that kind of thinking, or that an agreement can be stuck. That was tried by Chamberlin ("peace in our time") and failed miserably.

So, given all of this, my imperfect decision is to support this war effort, and support it fully. I don't care to send people off to get shot at or die, and I don't care to send people off to kill other people, nor do I choose either those things for me. However, I didn't choose to have cancer, I didn't choose to get canned from a couple of jobs, I didn't choose my parents (and I'm not saying this in a bad context), and I didn't choose what color my eyes were. But I stall had to fight cancer, find another job, deal with my parents, and wear glasses. And, in the end, I think this nation had no other rational choice but to go after Iraq and Afghanistan: one made no bones about wanting to get even with this country (as well as being a major source of funding terrorism), and the other harbored the people who attacked the US. Iran sits very high up on that list as well.

So yeah, this war is ambiguious, and the balance of right and wrong are not wholly one-sided. But only a fool ignores when the balance tilts in a specific direction. It's an imperfect decision that I don't loose any sleep over. And I do have a conscience, by the way.