I've had gator once at some dinner thingy at some restaurant in Framingham, MA. Had to buy tickets a month in advance. They served various themes once a week each month. The theme we signed up for was a 5 course meal of various game meat and various wine that coupled with it. If I remember correctly one of the servings was some gater meat as an appetizer. Could also choose frog legs, some cheese and sausage platter, some other stuff on the list. I did gator, others in my party chose other selections like frog legs and stuff. We all shared the picks.
For main course it was some elk, or bison, or some bird thing, or some fish thing. Again we all ordered different stuff to pass around and share. I was OK with that and we all sampled everything they brought us.
Based in that limited taste input, I probably not go out of my way to order another gator meal.
I did like the elk and bison meals that they created. The bird meat was good to (forget what bird it was). Fish meals, I didn't even try. I've not had a fish meal that I would like to try again. My taste buds don't like to eat fish, seafood, or mostly anything that lives in the water.