America's #1 Online Cigar Auction
first, best, biggest!

Last post 2 hours ago by Palama. 1890 replies replies.
38 Pages«<67891011121314>»
What'cha Smok'in Azzhats 1,000,000 Vol II
jeebling Offline
#451 Posted:
Joined: 08-04-2015
Posts: 1,392
81257: RP Vintage 1992 Churchill
Rated 92 and 93 I think. I’ll have to research it. I wonder if they’ve changed the blend since then. Hard to imagine that it was rated that high. I know what you guys say about ratings and I do keep that in mind. This one was ok, the last third had a loose draw and got really hot. I probably won’t buy more. I must say though, I enjoy the petite perfecto vitola seconds. Great midnight snack.
Palama Offline
#452 Posted:
Joined: 02-05-2013
Posts: 23,764
#81,258 - AF Casa Cuba Divine Inspiration

From a dwindling 2018 box.
jeebling Offline
#453 Posted:
Joined: 08-04-2015
Posts: 1,392
81259: Cuba Libre Gordo 4.5 x 60
Beautiful little BP Honduran Gordo, hefty but comfortable w/good MF. Kicks of light pepper and sweet, not strong sweet but very pronounced like red fruit. Second third transition to more earth and leather w/occasional salty savor and a hint of hay, a bit toasty with buttery thick smoke. I think this is a good one.
Palama Offline
#454 Posted:
Joined: 02-05-2013
Posts: 23,764
#81,260 - Illusione La Grande Classe Rex
JGRAZ Offline
#455 Posted:
Joined: 10-31-2022
Posts: 787
jeebling wrote:
81257: RP Vintage 1992 Churchill
Rated 92 and 93 I think. I’ll have to research it. I wonder if they’ve changed the blend since then. Hard to imagine that it was rated that high. I know what you guys say about ratings and I do keep that in mind. This one was ok, the last third had a loose draw and got really hot. I probably won’t buy more. I must say though, I enjoy the petite perfecto vitola seconds. Great midnight snack.


Pretty sure the ratings are based off how much money they give to the company doing the rating. Kind of like Rolling Stone and music. In the case of Rocky Patel, I'm pretty sure they keep Cigar Aficionado in business these days. Can't say I've ever tried one I liked
jeebling Offline
#456 Posted:
Joined: 08-04-2015
Posts: 1,392
^JGRAZ seems like getting involved in a discussion about a cigar on this forum is more reliable than the “experts” at CA.
tonygraz Offline
#457 Posted:
Joined: 08-11-2008
Posts: 20,302
81261 - Magellan Dominicans corona
82262 - El Rey Del Mundo Choix Supreme
Telecaster52 Offline
#458 Posted:
Joined: 04-22-2022
Posts: 728
81263- Padron 6000 - 2023 host bag. Not sure who this came from but looked to have some age.
81264 - Flor Fina - 23 host bag JTS
81265 - Cuban stock Toro- c/o Lee
81266 - AB Prensado - 23 host bag
81267 - Montesino - 23 box pass
JGRAZ Offline
#459 Posted:
Joined: 10-31-2022
Posts: 787
81268 - Rojas Breakfast Tacos Connecticut
danmdevries Offline
#460 Posted:
Joined: 02-11-2014
Posts: 17,477
81269 Dumbarton Sobremesa robusto grande from Jakethesnake.

Easy top 5 cigars I've smoked this year so far. Wow. I've not explored Sakas new stuff mostly because the price. Seems they may be priced appropriately. I chalked it up to name/hype. Read a lot of praise as well as negatives. I think the guy is a giant douche but goddamn this is a good cigar.

Tastes like a well aged smoke. Creamy, sweet, very mild pepper in my sinuses. Nutty, caramel, rich spices, just all around everything I want in a cigar. The profile changed significantly throughout the smoke while all staying within my wheelhouse. This has to be aged there's no way this isn't at least a few years old.

I will definitely be picking up more of these. I ordered a sampler so i have one single left but ill grab a fiver next time i fjnd em on sale. Thank you JTS.

Eta: I nubbed that fugger
jeebling Offline
#461 Posted:
Joined: 08-04-2015
Posts: 1,392
81270: RP Decade Robusto
81271: LPH BP Morado Robusto
81272: RP Decade Robusto

My first time w/this RP blend. 2 totally different cigars but from the same 10 pack. First one dog rocket, second one not bad.
danmdevries Offline
#462 Posted:
Joined: 02-11-2014
Posts: 17,477
jeebling wrote:

My first time w/this RP blend. 2 totally different cigars but from the same 10 pack. First one dog rocket, second one not bad.


That's been my experience with RP. I don't buy them but they often get put into add-on/freebie samplers with other orders. Sometimes I'm shocked by how good they are. Other times they're complete trash.
mjrburn Offline
#463 Posted:
Joined: 02-28-2016
Posts: 1,601
81273 - '07 Royal Jamaica Oro Rojo, from a 9/21 LeeBot smacking. I really enjoyed this aged beauty. Thanks Lee!
jeebling Offline
#464 Posted:
Joined: 08-04-2015
Posts: 1,392
^ unfortunately I’ve got a lot of RP 10 packs in various blends that I need to burn through. I probably won’t punish myself as I did with the Gurkhas, I’ll see if the boys at the VFW want them or I’ll pack them up and send to a charity (or maybe Leebo). I’ve got other brands waiting that I haven’t tried but I’m starting to get the feeling I may have a lot of junk to sample. This is what I wanted though…try it for myself and learn more.
mjrburn Offline
#465 Posted:
Joined: 02-28-2016
Posts: 1,601
danmdevries wrote:
81*** Dumbarton Sobremesa robusto grande from Jakethesnake.

Easy top 5 cigars I've smoked this year so far. Wow. I've not explored Sakas new stuff mostly because the price. Seems they may be priced appropriately. I chalked it up to name/hype. Read a lot of praise as well as negatives. I think the guy is a giant douche but goddamn this is a good cigar.

Tastes like a well aged smoke. Creamy, sweet, very mild pepper in my sinuses. Nutty, caramel, rich spices, just all around everything I want in a cigar. The profile changed significantly throughout the smoke while all staying within my wheelhouse. This has to be aged there's no way this isn't at least a few years old.

I will definitely be picking up more of these. I ordered a sampler so i have one single left but ill grab a fiver next time i fjnd em on sale. Thank you JTS.

Eta: I nubbed that fugger

Great review danm!

I, too, have no love for the owner/blender but that is one effing good cigar. Imo, the Sobremesa smokes this beautifully and deliciously after 2 weeks or 2 years. A humidor must have.
tonygraz Offline
#466 Posted:
Joined: 08-11-2008
Posts: 20,302
81274 - 5 Vegas Gold robusto
MidnightToker( • )( • ) Offline
#467 Posted:
Joined: 10-20-2023
Posts: 921
81275 - Esteban Carreras 211
Palama Offline
#468 Posted:
Joined: 02-05-2013
Posts: 23,764
danmdevries wrote:
812xx Dumbarton Sobremesa robusto grande from Jakethesnake.

Easy top 5 cigars I've smoked this year so far. Wow. I've not explored Sakas new stuff mostly because the price. Seems they may be priced appropriately. I chalked it up to name/hype. Read a lot of praise as well as negatives. I think the guy is a giant douche but goddamn this is a good cigar.

Tastes like a well aged smoke. Creamy, sweet, very mild pepper in my sinuses. Nutty, caramel, rich spices, just all around everything I want in a cigar. The profile changed significantly throughout the smoke while all staying within my wheelhouse. This has to be aged there's no way this isn't at least a few years old.

I will definitely be picking up more of these. I ordered a sampler so i have one single left but ill grab a fiver next time i fjnd em on sale. Thank you JTS.

Eta: I nubbed that fugger


Typo or passive-aggressive snarky comment? Think


COHoyoMan68 Offline
#469 Posted:
Joined: 05-16-2019
Posts: 65
81276: Macanudo Cafe paired with Crown Royal. I have found that mild cigars need a year to be complex. Down to my last two of these and they have 2.5 years in the humi. Cold draw yielded earthy flavors with a hint of spice. Upon lighting, more pronounced spice, the classic Connie wrapper taste, and hint of that Dominican "metallic" flavor. Pretty blonde cigar, with one discernable vein up the bottom half from the foot. Spice mixes more with the wrapper flavors at the first third mark. I remember these as mild, with above average Connie flavors, however, by the half way mark, I am surprised by the steady spice notes (cinnamon). Burn is even to just barely wavy. Really good with the Crown. Spice notes continue through the second third. Really enjoying this old cigar. Burn gets wavier as the nub approaches. A little harsh at the nub, shoulda stopped a puff or two ago. Although these stand up fine on their own, there are just too many better cigars that take up humi space to justify buying them again. I will enjoy my last one next month with coffee, hoping it too has that wonderful spice surprise from the San Andres binder, and then be done with this once classic cigar.
Telecaster52 Offline
#470 Posted:
Joined: 04-22-2022
Posts: 728
danmdevries wrote:
81269 Dumbarton Sobremesa robusto grande from Jakethesnake.

Easy top 5 cigars I've smoked this year so far. Wow. I've not explored Sakas new stuff mostly because the price. Seems they may be priced appropriately. I chalked it up to name/hype. Read a lot of praise as well as negatives. I think the guy is a giant douche but goddamn this is a good cigar.

Tastes like a well aged smoke. Creamy, sweet, very mild pepper in my sinuses. Nutty, caramel, rich spices, just all around everything I want in a cigar. The profile changed significantly throughout the smoke while all staying within my wheelhouse. This has to be aged there's no way this isn't at least a few years old.

I will definitely be picking up more of these. I ordered a sampler so i have one single left but ill grab a fiver next time i fjnd em on sale. Thank you JTS.

Eta: I nubbed that fugger





I don't think you have a telenubber.
Send me an addy. I'll fix you up.
MidnightToker( • )( • ) Offline
#471 Posted:
Joined: 10-20-2023
Posts: 921
81277 - JDN antano dark corojo
One of my favorite smokes, this one is a couple years old and tasting great.
danmdevries Offline
#472 Posted:
Joined: 02-11-2014
Posts: 17,477
Palama wrote:
Typo or passive-aggressive snarky comment? Think



Yes.

Telecaster52 wrote:
I don't think you have a telenubber.
Send me an addy. I'll fix you up.


I have plenty nubbin tools, but my fingers work best. When I use a tweezer, hemostat, or awl I tend to singe my mustache and that smells awful. Fingers work best.
danmdevries Offline
#473 Posted:
Joined: 02-11-2014
Posts: 17,477
81278 Trocadero Ruelles. 2nd one is much better than the first. A month or two in the humidor tends to do that vs rott.

Pretty boring but good. Peanut shells and a lil cinnamon. Not as astringent as the first one, and no bitterness. Still fairly dry. Overall decent. Not gonna be a repeat purchase. $3.75 per
danmdevries Offline
#474 Posted:
Joined: 02-11-2014
Posts: 17,477
81279 El Suelo Vuelos. Much better after a couple months resting. Bready/cracker/pretzel, slight sweetness no spice. Little pepper on retro, slightly dry. Overall decent but not a repeat purchase. $3.75 per.
Jakethesnake86 Offline
#475 Posted:
Joined: 12-29-2020
Posts: 4,219
^ glad you liked the sobremesa danm. I love those. I don’t run out of those. I have no idea the date on that box. Maybe a couple years. But the other box is much older so I’m unsure. But that’s my favorite saka blend. Umbagog didn’t do much and mi querida was just meh (for the price). They’re all pretty good but I really only buy the sobremesa. I’ve had the brûlée and brûlée blue. If you like Connie’s the original brûlée is the better cigar in my opinion. But overall the original sobremesa is the best from saka.

My personal opinion The todos Los Dias was also very good but they’re unavailable last I checked
tonygraz Offline
#476 Posted:
Joined: 08-11-2008
Posts: 20,302
81280 - Gurkha Status torpedo------------were pretty good about 15 years ago- not this newish one.
MidnightToker( • )( • ) Offline
#477 Posted:
Joined: 10-20-2023
Posts: 921
81281 - Cuba Libre one
Short one for the porch after dinner since it's a little windy. Not a bad cigar for the price so far.
danmdevries Offline
#478 Posted:
Joined: 02-11-2014
Posts: 17,477
81282 Aladino corona from 8/2021 with thanks to Palama.
JGRAZ Offline
#479 Posted:
Joined: 10-31-2022
Posts: 787
81283 - Charter Oak Broadleaf Rothschild
RobertHively Offline
#480 Posted:
Joined: 01-14-2015
Posts: 1,919

81284- Dunbarton Todos Las Dias belicoso
LeeBot Offline
#481 Posted:
Joined: 07-08-2020
Posts: 2,033
81285 - LFD Andalusian Bull from Z. Thanks, Z! That was the first of those I have had, and I dug it. Very nice.

81286 - Plascenia Ehtëfal toro. No way a cigar can possibly be worth that much coin to me. The first half came about as close as you can get though. It was amazing. I think "it" moved. The second half was very good but not amazing.

81287 - EPC Pledge romusto from Stogie. Always a fav. Thank you, Stogie!

81288 - Last Call rothschild
cashmoneydave Offline
#482 Posted:
Joined: 08-16-2018
Posts: 810
81289 - AF HMWY short
tonygraz Offline
#483 Posted:
Joined: 08-11-2008
Posts: 20,302
81290 - Magellan Dominicans corona
Stogie1020 Offline
#484 Posted:
Joined: 12-19-2019
Posts: 5,385
81291 Ezra Zion 9th Year Anniversary
jeebling Offline
#485 Posted:
Joined: 08-04-2015
Posts: 1,392
81292: LGC Classic Wavell
This one seemed more ashy and harsh than the others
Palama Offline
#486 Posted:
Joined: 02-05-2013
Posts: 23,764
danmdevries wrote:
812xx Aladino corona from 8/2021 with thanks to Palama.


Hope you enjoyed it Dan.
Palama Offline
#487 Posted:
Joined: 02-05-2013
Posts: 23,764
#81,2NINE3 - Cuban Crafters Cupido Tuxedo Robusto

From a 2016 nOOb PIB smackdown from Corey. Mahalos Braddah!
MaduroJorge Offline
#488 Posted:
Joined: 03-27-2023
Posts: 119
812994 Pita Churchill Nica. Oscuro. Very cheap,Very good.
Mraia Offline
#489 Posted:
Joined: 04-18-2019
Posts: 430
812995 Caldwell Anastasia. Got it from the place of tiny bunch’s cigar of the month club. It’s ok. Pretty mild and creamy. Well made. Distinct barnyard essence which is pleasant.
Nothing I would buy again though.
jeebling Offline
#490 Posted:
Joined: 08-04-2015
Posts: 1,392
81296: LGC Original Maduro Wavell
The first inch was very peppery and then it grew sweeter and more mellow
MidnightToker( • )( • ) Offline
#491 Posted:
Joined: 10-20-2023
Posts: 921
81297 - Caldwell blinds man bluff
Smoked it at church/Bible study
cashmoneydave Offline
#492 Posted:
Joined: 08-16-2018
Posts: 810
81298 - Henry Clay War hawk corona
COHoyoMan68 Offline
#493 Posted:
Joined: 05-16-2019
Posts: 65
81299: RP Edge Maduro. Rocky makes a lot of stuff, most I am not interested in, however, there are a few that I always keep singles of, but this is the only one I buy by the box. White pepper on the cold draw. Immense maduro flavors throughout with a wavy burn and a few touch ups. Delicious with some XO Cognac.
jeebling Offline
#494 Posted:
Joined: 08-04-2015
Posts: 1,392
^Ive read in this thread that some do like RP The Edge Maduro even though they don’t care too much for RP generally.

81300: A&B Tempus Maduro Robusto
My first try on the Maduro in this blend. I enjoyed it.

EDIT: COHO or anyone else, have you tried the RP 60? It’s one I want to try but the bids go sky high and I back out.
Telecaster52 Offline
#495 Posted:
Joined: 04-22-2022
Posts: 728
81,301 - Camacho Triple Maduro c/o JGRAZ.
danmdevries Offline
#496 Posted:
Joined: 02-11-2014
Posts: 17,477
81302 Tatuaje T110 Tuxtla with thanks to Stogie1020

I've had the T110 a few times. I think. This is the first tuxtla. First light is heavy pepper of course but then the lingering note is bready, toasty, sweet. I just ate tacos and loaded em with hot sauce so my tasters may be out of calibration but it's like honey nut cheerios. Weird. But not unwelcome.

That cheerio note held on past the first ash drop. The dirty pepper MSA is still very prominent but balanced. I was going to say I prefer the broadleaf variant but right after I typed that I had to backspace because even more sweetness came up to fight the MSA and balance things out to where I wanted to be.

Halfway it's still balanced bitter/dirt and sweet/bready but some hardwood smoke playing in there too. Pepper died down. It's following the normal tat progression. Stogies cello says this is a bit over a year old. Tastes right.

Bands came off nicely and fully intact without heat. Finished to 1" playing with the same flavors. Overall was enjoyable.
COHoyoMan68 Offline
#497 Posted:
Joined: 05-16-2019
Posts: 65
jeebling wrote:
^Ive read in this thread that some do like RP The Edge Maduro even though they don’t care too much for RP generally.

81300: A&B Tempus Maduro Robusto
My first try on the Maduro in this blend. I enjoyed it.

EDIT: COHO or anyone else, have you tried the RP 60? It’s one I want to try but the bids go sky high and I back out.


I will buy one the next time I am in a B & M, stash it for a few years, then try it. I am not generally a fan of new cigars, I let everyone else try them first, then see if they are worth adding to my already toooo big rotation.
MidnightToker( • )( • ) Offline
#498 Posted:
Joined: 10-20-2023
Posts: 921
81303 - RP The edge maduro ironically
The only RPs I smoke are the Edge maduro and corojo
This one has a few yrs. on it..FYI, they age very well
702Grizz Offline
#499 Posted:
Joined: 02-03-2023
Posts: 3
Foundation The Tabernacle, David (Perfecto size).
Second stick I have smoked of this one. Very enjoyable stick. Earthy with a cedar note on my palette.
Telecaster52 Offline
#500 Posted:
Joined: 04-22-2022
Posts: 728
81,304^^^^^^^^^^^
Users browsing this topic
Guest, LeeBot
38 Pages«<67891011121314>»