http://www.telladf.org/UserDocs/OSUMansfieldletter.pdf
This is the letter to OSU from the ADF, which sheds a bit of additional, albeit propagandist, perspective.
It looks as if the librarian suggested a conservative book, and what criticised by the commitee..........THEN, as sort of a "screw you, you think THAT was offensive......", he suggested the other books, including the one with anti-gay rhetoric.
I agree with Victor, this should not be a sexual harrassment issue; this is a liberal faction of the university that are too much of a bunch of pussies to proceed to deal with this as a very stupid lapse of good judgement by the librarian.....so they are "playing" the sexual harrassment card instead. I they are truly offended by the material suggested, than a wholesale scourge of the library would be in order to weed out any books with offensive sexual material. You could call upon the campus Nazi party to help out with that.
To paint this man as a sexual harrasser/aggressor is inappropriate.....to question his fitness as a reference librarian is more appropriate; it looks like we have a frustrated tempermental man here.