SweetHavok
Monday, April 15, 2013 1:43:04 PM
Students of Gadsden High School while playing a road game against another school in Alamogordo, NM, were threatened to be ejected from the game if they spoke Spanish by an umpire. The same empire also threatened to eject the coaching staff for defending its players. The umpire said that anyone caught speaking Spanish, student or coaching staff would be ejected from the game.

The situation was resolved when another umpire in the game mediated the dispute and pointed out that no rules were broken, when the players or coaching staff spoke in Spanish, and they were allowed to continue to play.

http://sports.yahoo.com/blogs/highschool-prep-rally/mexico-umpire-threatens-ejections-attempt-stop-team-communicating-100308817.html 

Now the question remains should Spanish be allowed in the game at all?

Was the umpire out of line?

Now what say you?

Dayum it! wish I had popcorn eating emoticon, me thinks its about to get interesting in here.

robertsccr5
Monday, April 15, 2013 1:47:41 PM
who cares...not about the story....who cares if they speak spanish.
kyman84
Monday, April 15, 2013 1:49:37 PM
If you don't want people speaking Spanish because you don't understand it, learn to speak it! I don't think it's any different from coaches and players on a team having their own sign language to help communicate without the other team understanding whats going on.
sr20vet
Monday, April 15, 2013 1:51:53 PM
Completely out of line. If they're best able to communicate amongst themselves with Spanish so be it. The only legitimate complaint I can think of is that it could be taken as a means of secretly communicating instructions, but that's part of the damn game. Besides they're in New Mexico, it's a safe bet that the Spanish fluency rate is pretty high there.
madspackler
Monday, April 15, 2013 1:57:23 PM
Played soccer in high school and college. Growing up in NY, there were many ethnic areas and teams and they spoke whatever their native tongue was during the matches. Who cares what language is being spoken, it is about the game. The official was certainly out of line - and should be subject to censure.

Do all the teams speak the same language during the Olympics?

Do all the golfers speak the same language while on the Tour?

Does speaking a different language have any impact upon how the ball moves or how the players play?

Being a true international sport, all languages should be permitted during a soccer competition. If there is a barrier, the team should provide an interpreter for the players as well as the officials.

DrMaddVibe
Monday, April 15, 2013 1:58:36 PM
Was the game played in America? Yes or no?

What's the official language in the United States of America?

There's your f**king answer.

SweetHavok
Monday, April 15, 2013 2:01:56 PM

Was the game played in America? Yes or no?

What's the official language in the United States of America?

There's your f**king answer.

DrMaddVibe wrote:

Yes

English

Now last time I checked freedom of speech did not apply to solely English.

HockeyDad
Monday, April 15, 2013 2:09:46 PM
That umpire's career shall be destroyed.
DrafterX
Monday, April 15, 2013 2:11:15 PM
was prolly a volunteer anyway.... 😟
Gene363
Monday, April 15, 2013 2:17:16 PM

Was the game played in America? Yes or no?

What's the official language in the United States of America?

There's your f**king answer.

DrMaddVibe wrote:

Hence forth:

All baseball catchers will need to communicate calls to the pitcher in English instead of using hand signals.

All NFL quarterback calls must be in plain English.

Be careful what you ask for.

tyyler82
Monday, April 15, 2013 2:23:05 PM

Hence forth:

All baseball catchers will need to communicate calls to the pitcher in English instead of using hand signals.

All NFL quarterback calls must be in plain English.

Be careful what you ask for.

Gene363 wrote:

exactly...

wheelrite
Monday, April 15, 2013 2:27:31 PM
yawn
DrMaddVibe
Monday, April 15, 2013 2:34:16 PM

Yes

English

Now last time I checked freedom of speech did not apply to solely English.

SweetHavok wrote:

You wouldn't know if they were trying to warn you about a car hitting you or planning on hitting you with a car if they didn't speak English.

Seriously.

There's a reason why we have a national language.

As for the hand signs and play calling...whatever...it's not like they're calling your mom a whore or stealing your money.

tyyler82
Monday, April 15, 2013 2:36:24 PM
or are they....???
Buckwheat
Monday, April 15, 2013 2:37:37 PM
Now the question remains should Spanish be allowed in the game at all? No, this is America and we should only allow people to speak American.

Was the umpire out of line? Yes

Now what say you? Only Latin should be allowed to be spoken during a baseball game since the sport is dominated by Latin American players.

Viva la idiocy!!

[ram27bat]

Gene363
Monday, April 15, 2013 2:41:00 PM

or are they....???

tyyler82 wrote:

Now that there is funny. [beer]

sr20vet
Monday, April 15, 2013 2:43:59 PM
Official languages are simply to set a standard for government communication with the general public. Ours, in every state, is English hence all our signage, documents, etc. are primarily in English. Even the government recognizes that it's beneficial to include other languages based on region though. So you see plenty of Spanish & French in areas where also using those languages makes sense.

I barely know any Spanish, and have no particular desire to learn more. However I won't pretend that it's not an immensely useful language to know. I've never looked at the numbers but I wouldn't be surprised if Spanish is the most widely spoken language in the world. I'd guess it's either Spanish or Chinese (due to the immense population there). The only reason English is the Lingua Franca is because so many world economies are tied to ours.

SweetHavok
Monday, April 15, 2013 2:48:14 PM

You wouldn't know if they were trying to warn you about a car hitting you or planning on hitting you with a car if they didn't speak English.

Seriously.

There's a reason why we have a national language.

As for the hand signs and play calling...whatever...it's not like they're calling your mom a whore or stealing your money.

DrMaddVibe wrote:

Actually I would, fluent in Spanish and know some French as well, even picked up a bit of Tagalog. Now contrary to popular belief, paranoia, when someone talks in a foreign language in your presence and you don't understand it, the conversation is not always about you. Been in many settings where I don't understand the language being spoken at all, and had no issue with them speaking their native language.

I have no issue with a the National language being English, but this is a GAME and not a classroom environment. If that were the case then I would be agreeing with you, English should be spoken in class.

DrMaddVibe
Monday, April 15, 2013 2:49:20 PM

Official languages are simply to set a standard for government communication with the general public. Ours, in every state, is English hence all our signage, documents, etc. are primarily in English. Even the government recognizes that it's beneficial to include other languages based on region though. So you see plenty of Spanish & French in areas where also using those languages makes sense.

I barely know any Spanish, and have no particular desire to learn more. However I won't pretend that it's not an immensely useful language to know. I've never looked at the numbers but I wouldn't be surprised if Spanish is the most widely spoken language in the world. I'd guess it's either Spanish or Chinese (due to the immense population there). The only reason English is the Lingua Franca is because so many world economies are tied to ours.

sr20vet wrote:

So, it's a benefit...okay. I'll buy that. All day every day.

So Pig Latin and other just made up languages...how ya feel about those?

Ever wonder how much a nation say like Canada spends on multi-language labels, signage and anything else? Don't forget the tribal languages too!

DrMaddVibe
Monday, April 15, 2013 2:50:28 PM

Actually I would, fluent in Spanish and know some French as well, even picked up a bit of Tagalog as well. Now contrary to popular belief, paranoia, when someone talks in a foreign language in your presence and you don't understand it, the conversation is not always about you. Been in many settings where I don't understand the language being spoken at all, and had no issue with them speaking their native language.

I have no issue with a the National language being English, but this is a GAME and not a classroom environment. If that were the case then I would be agreeing with you, English should be spoken in class.

SweetHavok wrote:

Ahem...this was a HIGH SCHOOL GAME!!!!!

HELLO!🐴