Sure it makes sense. I was forced to pay SS for all those years. They took the money, and I had no say.
IF I am lucky enough to reach a certain age (and unlucky enough not to have a nice retirement income) I'll get some back. That's bull**** to me. I've been told if I earn over a certain amount in retirement they can reduce what they give me or give me nothing.
I got 3600 back. That's 300 a month, and I am already maxed on my tax deferred contributions. What the hell am I going to do with that 300? Throw it in savings and earn a whopping .45%?
I guess it just comes down to preference. I like getting the money all at once. And it IS akin to the lotto choice. You get it little by little or all at once. If you take the lump sum... you get less.
MACS wrote: