thumper, I understand your frustration regarding this issue of the 2 Cohibas. The Yellow banded one was made by Monte de Christi Tabacos and the Red Dot Cohibas are made by General Cigar. The Yellow are discontinued because of trademark disputes with General. Also, the Yellow bands are much cheaper and any store that would charge you more than $5 TOPS for one is ripping you off big time. On the other hand, the Red Dot is expensive and a rip off just the same. The Yellow bands are a decent cigar with quite a bit of age on them, but there are way too many inconsistencies in the stick. The Red Dots are a waste of money, plain and simple. If you're gonna spend $10 for a cigar, use it wisely and buy an Ashton VSG or a Padron Anniversario, which are both better than the current underfermented Cuban Cohibas (if indeed you do find a REAL one). Hope that helps 🙂