bassithound --- you said, " Hey Slim, would you rather me not say anything and just contact CS? Why?"
It's simple. If I had a probem with you ... I would first contront you privately to let you know what was bothering me. Personally, I just think that is the respectful and ethical way to go about it.
If I didn't get satisfaction from that encounter ... I would then take it public, if I felt it would benefit others.
What you did is not wrong, just not the way I, or many others, would have handled it. In your first post you gave very little information, other than 'watch out'. It gave me the impression that I should not buy that particular cigar from Cigarbid. But, down the thread, you state that the problem was with Indian Tabac (because of the moldy cigars from you tobacconist) ... and that sheds a whole new light on the problem.