tailgater
Wednesday, November 28, 2007 9:13:00 AM
OK.

I've been getting conflicting opinions and "facts" surrounding HDTV.

Three major items of concern:

1. DLP and/or projection type vs. flat screen (LCD & Plasma). I have the room for a DLP because I'm not hanging the TV. Do any DLP or similar technology offer a wide viewing angle like the flat screens?

2. 1080P vs. 720P resolution: I know the difference, but am concerned about how they respond to different inputs. Will the 1080P have a "worse" picture than a 720P when converting standard cable signals? How about digital cable?

Will the 720P have a problem receiving standard DVD signals from an upconvert 1080P DVD player?

3. LCD vs Plasma. Not all manufacturers list the same specs. I'm concerned with response signal time, since I like to watch sports and don't want a fuzzy motion.

If anybody truly knows any or all of these could you elaborate? If too detailed let me know and I'll shoot you my email.

Thanks.

Thunder.Gerbil
Wednesday, November 28, 2007 9:34:00 AM
1) I'm guessing that when you say DLP you are refering to a rear-projection unit and "projection" you mean a cieling mount front-projection.

I feel that the DLP RP's are more realistic looking in their picture output versus the LCDs, and you have more flexability in your viewing distance (ie: DLP-RPs don't look like you're watching a screen full of lego blocks when you sit too close). The viewing angle varies by the manufacturer and screen type/coatings. Best to evaluate this for yourself in a store.

Front-projection units, if you can't aford to sink some serious bucks into the projector & screen and room to put it in, you might find yourself out a sizeable chunk of change while viewing a picture that is of a lesser quality than what you could have gotten in a large DLP-RP unit.

2) " Will the 1080P have a "worse" picture than a 720P when converting standard cable signals? " Not necessarially. That's a fucntion of the scaler (the chip responsible for upconverting the signal) inside the TV. Better scaler = better picture.

"Will the 720P have a problem receiving standard DVD signals from an upconvert 1080P DVD player? " Depends if the player kicks down a resolution or not.

If your HD display output matches the incomming signal, the image will be viewed in it's native, unadulterated form. 99 times out of 100, this will yield the best picture quality.

3) How big a screen are you looking for?

Ram27
Wednesday, November 28, 2007 9:38:00 AM
This topic came up here a few months ago, may find in search....

I have a Panasonic 42" 1080,,,, bells & whitles and love it.

usahog
Wednesday, November 28, 2007 9:56:00 AM
I've got a Sony 34" HDTV with a Dish HDTV DVR reciever? and to tell you the truth.. I cannot tell the difference when it's HDTV or reg. TV?

Other then Paying for the HDTV is the only way I can tell somethings different? Not Right! LOL

Course I don't sit down and watch enough TV to learn what I'm missing maybe?

Hog

BuckyB93
Wednesday, November 28, 2007 9:56:00 AM
tailgater,

Do you subscribe to Consumer Reports online? They have some good discussion on this.

If not, shoot me an e-mail and I'll cut and paste some stuff for you.

stogiemac yahoo

Thunder.Gerbil
Wednesday, November 28, 2007 10:01:00 AM
Hog,

If you're not seeing a differance, then something isn't setup correctly or the HDTV feeds you are watching are not native HD, but rather upconverted SD.

tailgater
Wednesday, November 28, 2007 10:21:00 AM
ems

Thanks Bucky.

tailgater
Wednesday, November 28, 2007 10:23:00 AM
TG,

my bad. by "projection" I meant rear projection.

I'm looking at a 42" to 50" screen.

Is there a DLP system with good view angles? I've seen the DLP picture and love it, but the ones I've looked at were only truly great when directly in front. The quality diminished dramatically when viewed from the side.

Thunder.Gerbil
Wednesday, November 28, 2007 10:40:00 AM
That's a tough one. The very nature of rear-projection itself makes wide viewing angles very difficult to achieve.

The New Sony's are pretty good. 90-110 degrees total angle, maybe a bit more (I don't have a spec sheet in front of me for an exact number, just going by what I remember from viewing them).

There are a number of new Sony units coming out in early 2008 that are 1080P with the "Motionflow 120Hz" engine that will really eliminate most if not all jitter when viewing.

(of course, if the station is sending a crappy HD feed, then all bets are off)

I'll ping bigjohn-s, he knows more about what's currently available than I do.

Charlie
Wednesday, November 28, 2007 10:41:00 AM
Joe

I have a 42 Sony HDTV rear projection, and if I had to do it again, I would buy a bigger screen......I love the thing and yes, you damn sure can tell if you are on HD or not......

Go to Best Buy and compare and see which you like and then investigate it a little for performance factors, etc.....you cannot go wrong with Sony!

Charlie

BuckyB93
Wednesday, November 28, 2007 10:47:00 AM
Tailgater,

I started C&P a bunch of stuff but it got tedious. Check my last e-mail I sent then browse to your heart's desire.

pacman357
Wednesday, November 28, 2007 12:04:00 PM
Not helpful, but I was watching some game last weekend, and some TV brand was being touted coming back from commercials. I wasn't recording it, so I may have missed it, but I think they said something like "The official DLP HDTV of ESPN on ABC."

'bout fell out of my chair laughing. I think they missed adding "EIEIO".

Smashed247
Wednesday, November 28, 2007 12:18:00 PM
I had a 42' Samsung for almost two years.

A couple months ago I went to a 58' Panasonic 58' 1080. Panasonic seems to get the best reviews anywhere you look.

herfsnipe
Wednesday, November 28, 2007 12:51:00 PM
Keep in mind any HD TV you buy will be a big disappointment unless you are also planning on HD programming.

Directv will have 100 channels of HD programming supposedly by the end of the year. I have a NICE Sony WEGA tv and a HP HD set upstairs. When I watch a football game in HD and later, go back to the Sony, it takes me time to adjust again to the "crappy picture."

You're gonna love HD. DLP will save you money, but I recommend LCD. Better resolution, better contrast ratios. But, you're gonna have to see for yourself.

Do yourself a favor and spend some time reading up on different models and reviews on CNET.com. It's worth the research for this big purchase. It's gonna be great. I hope you get one you like and enjoy it as much as I do.

Bigjohn-S
Wednesday, November 28, 2007 1:33:00 PM
So just my 2 cents.

http://www.bestbuy.com/site/olspage.jsp?skuId=8293456&type=product&id=1173577986415 

The television is pretty solid. I need to do some calibrating, I think, but watching HDTV is sharp, really sharp. Seems to have a good scaler built in too.

A few cautions on HD in general. First, unless you're looking at a 56 or greater TV, for the most part 1080p vs 720p is just math. HD is typically broadcast in 720p or 1080i, so in most cases some "bit juggling" happens inside the TV to convert the output. Yes, 1080 lines is higher resolution than 720, but if you have crappy electronics in the TV taking the 720 up to 1080, you are not getting much. It's easier for the electronics to down-scale than up-scale.

Also, pay attention to the amount of light in the room at the time of day you normally watch TV. If it's a bright room, an LCD flat panel will be a better choice than a plasma, and most DLP rear-projection TV's will be better than LCD or LCOS - because, mostly, of the brighter bulbs.

In any case, no HDTV should be "lit" - lighting should be off to the sides of the tv, not directly shining on it.

Source matters. DISH HD, OTA if you can get it, or Cable - The TV I mentioned has clear-QAM, so any unencrypted HD (typically your locals) will look awesome with the native tuner.

Good luck!

teedubbya
Wednesday, November 28, 2007 2:08:00 PM
hd rp here. projecting on a 8'X4' screen. Thats 100" hd and I could go bigger.

outstanding

teedubbya
Wednesday, November 28, 2007 2:08:00 PM
oops fp
pacman357
Wednesday, November 28, 2007 4:37:00 PM
#17 RP makes an 8'x4' cigar? Damn, I think he'd finally even lose ME on that line.
Mr. Jones
Thursday, November 29, 2007 3:30:00 PM
Just bought a 42" Toshshiba HDTV and it works great!

It was a "Best Buy" in Consumers Report and I got the exact serial Number that was in the article.