opelmanta1900
10 years ago
Give up smoking or give up her... I'd opt for the latter... Falling in love is easy...
shaun341
10 years ago

Hello,

My name is Harvey; I'm a welder and glassworker from Connecticut, and I've relatively recently begun smoking cigars. There is a small mountain of issues that could be discussed, most of which I care little about, but there is one big problem that I find myself with: I have to keep my cigars a secret.

The basics are simple enough. My girlfriend might as will already be my fiance, and in all likelihood will be soon. We're moving in together sometime in the next few months. She is frugal, almost to the point of insanity. She hates the concept of vice with a reserved passion; alcohol and smoking are two of her least favorite things in the world. Basically, there's no reason for her to do anything but hate tobacco and the smoking thereof.

Perpetual secrecy isn't an option, I already feel bad enough for not having told her the first time I tried a cigar. However, I don't have a clue about how to introduce the topic and handle the fallout. Have any of you had to deal with a situation like this? Any suggestions?

It is worth noting that I am very much in love with my girlfriend. She's brilliant, beautiful, and generally too good for me. Basically, I'd give up smoking for her, but I'd like to keep both. Even if it means puffing away outside in the middle of a Minnesota winter.

(She's a graduate student in Minneapolis. That's where I'll be moving soon. Because love makes people dumb.)

:-({|=

Hmhaines wrote:




Probably not possible buddy but either are replaceable
bgz
  • bgz
  • Herf-A-Holic
10 years ago
It's not a vice, it's a collection!

If you don't smoke that much, she should be cool with it...

Not sure why you're asking a bunch of grumpy old farts about major life decisions though, lol.
zody
10 years ago
If she can't deal with you smoking cigars and that's a deal breaker, pretty superficial and I'd say it's not only doomed, you'd be dodging a misery bullet there brother.
You're in the Honeymoon phase, real love is what develops when things get real....like you are in each other's daily lives and space all the time. Honeymoon love fades and turns into real love or it just burns out and fades away.
Make your choices and be smart, Honeymoon love makes you dumber than dumb. Trust me, been there. If you stay dumb and kids come into the picture the only winners are attorneys.
SmokeMonkey
10 years ago
Whether or not you smoke cigars will be a very small part of the trial and tribulations you will experience in a marriage. If it's an issue for her, as others have intimated above, it will be the least of your problems when the "hard times" come. Be true to yourself and be accountable for what that means. Own it. Your relationship will be better in the long term for it, one way or the other. Or that's just the scotch talking....
danmdevries
10 years ago
If you have to hide something from someone that close to you, the solution is not complicated. Pick the one you want more.

stinger88
10 years ago
If you are an occasional smoker and she can't handle it, probably a warning sign. My wife doesn't like it but she understands. She doesn't give me too much grief and I just have to go through all of the post smoke procedures. Shower, brush teeth, etc.
Palama
10 years ago

If you are an occasional smoker and she can't handle it, probably a warning sign. My wife doesn't like it but she understands. She doesn't give me too much grief and I just have to go through all of the post smoke procedures. Shower, brush teeth, etc.

stinger88 wrote:



+1

OP - better to be straight up with her, always the best course of action. Smoking a cigar is my "Me" time so it's meant to be relaxing. No way I could enjoy it if I had to hide it from my wife.
DrMaddVibe
10 years ago
PUHLEEZE...that boatload of crazy isn't going to just stop at vice. That's just the line you know not to cross today. Tomorrow it will be a whole host of things...the clothes you wear, the way you part your hair, the manner in which you stare...RUN.

I'm positive that there is a better woman out there for you.


You'd be settling for 2nd best with this nutjob wacko that cannot and will not accept you for you. Look, we're not perfect. We're humans and we ALL have flaws. When you have the kind of worries you bring...RUN AWAY. You cannot fix her or her seeded beliefs.


OR



Marry her. Reconcile with that man in the mirror each and every morning when you're shaving that you're a surrender monkey that has to hide his nuts like a squirrel. You aren't allowed to enjoy what you want, when you want and you settled. You could've had a porterhouse steak and you went with the McDonalds plain hamburger. Get used to wearing flannel shirts, Carhart jackets and bib overalls..say stuff like "YAAAA" and "Geeeez" a lot too and when your blood turns into used motor oil and you're wearing shorts when it hits 45 for the first time in 6 months get back to us!


Smoke 'em if ya gots 'em..but in your case you have to hide them...sneak them out...disinfect yourself with soap and water...change your clothes...wash the smoky clothes by themselves because you know who will smell it on her clothes after they've been washed and dried no matter what.

🇨🇮
Abrignac
10 years ago
How often does she pull your nuts out of her purse so you can look at them?
danmdevries
10 years ago
Yup. ^

I don't even know how to say it. If you can't discuss it with her and come to a mutually agreed decision like stingers arrangement, time to run. Or if you are sympathetic to some experience she had to drive her position, you won't be looking to sneak a smoke.
riverdog
10 years ago

Whether or not you smoke cigars will be a very small part of the trial and tribulations you will experience in a marriage. If it's an issue for her, as others have intimated above, it will be the least of your problems when the "hard times" come. Be true to yourself and be accountable for what that means. Own it. Your relationship will be better in the long term for it, one way or the other. Or that's just the scotch talking....

SmokeMonkey wrote:



Damn persuasive scotch.=d>
Plowboy221
10 years ago
Ditch the broad and find a nice Latin hoe


Hector, Pedro's tres cuzin
rfenst
10 years ago
This OP has to be some kind of a joke...
danmdevries
10 years ago

This OP has to be some kind of a joke...

rfenst wrote:



Just looked at it again.

OP in CT, female in MN. That's not commuting distance.
Breakout3030
10 years ago
Uh, maybe put on your big boy pants and explain to her how the cow is going to eat the cabbage. If you set a precedent in the relationship with her dictating how things will work it will be a very long miserable relationship.

As soon as my wife starts barking about my hobbies "vices" I just remind her how frivolous I think make-up is when applied to a woman who is naturally beautiful. Shuts her up every time...
dstieger
10 years ago
Abrignac
10 years ago

This OP has to be some kind of a joke...

rfenst wrote:




Prolly so. Hadn't had a good "grow a pair" pig pile in a while. I'm guessing TW's bored without the fireman around.
tonygraz
10 years ago
You don't want to live in Minnesota in the winter.
SMOKEYOU
10 years ago
Hide smoking? Can you hide not wearing deodorant?
Users browsing this topic