bgz
  • bgz
  • Herf-A-Holic
11 years ago
I try to keep mine about 65 as well, though it tends to be a little higher inside the drawers(about 67 - 68 or so).

Lesson learned, patience is a virtue. Usually I do let them rest longer, but I was a bit anxious to participate.
tonygraz
11 years ago

GOF some of the best I've had.

Bugz is fired.

danmdevries wrote:



I smoked one GOF and will never buy another---they are on my top ten worst cigar list.
chazbo
  • chazbo
  • Herf-A-Holic Topic Starter
11 years ago

Smoked cigar #2 from Chazbo tonight. It was a 5" 54rg with a dark brown slightly toothy wrapper. It had a very heavy feel to it. Preflight draw was light tobacco with a bit of cedar. The burn was perfectly smooth, with initial ash holding for close to 2". Light leather taste through the first half wit hints of cedar and a littletangyness to it. Through the 2nd. Half the tang faded to a mellow smoke. Superb burn and I enjoyed down to the nub. because of the toothy wrapper I'm guessing mid range, but would absolutely smoke another. My first thoughts on it were visage so I'm gonna stick with thar, but wouldn't be surprised to find out it was an Ashton VSG.


So what did I smoke?

illinichaser wrote:


2 was a Perdomo Edicion de Silvio Maduro with over 10 years in my humi.
jespear
11 years ago

#-o

So now all I have left is the "dog rocket" ?
This should be interesting . . . going into it KNOWING that.

I'll try to be as unbiased as possible.

jespear wrote:



I just finished Unknown #1 from Shaun.
By process of elimination, this would be his "dog rocket" entry.
Nice looking cigar. Possibly 5 1/2 x 50, with a slightly veiny dark brown wrapper.
Not much of a pre light aroma, but draw was easy.
No pepper or spice whatsoever throughout the entire smoke. Not much flavor or kick . . . just a mild uneventful smoke.
It wasn't a bad experience. The draw was real easy and there was a lot of smoke. Burn was perfect beginning to end, so
I wouldn't necessarily call it a dog rocket.

Wild guess . . . Genesis the Project ?
Hillbillyjosh770
11 years ago
Great reviews guys, definitely gonna try a couple.

I got my package today from my good ole buddy, illinichaser.

All arrived unscathed.

It's been raining cats and dogs here. So I'm gonna jump in.

Included in the 5'er is a Viage TNT! And one of my fav's the Shark! You will pay dearly. Thanks Bro!

Number 1

You know me well.

Coming in as a hefty 4 x 45
Dark brown wrapper, minimal veins, tight visible seams. Toothy oily satin wrapper. Wonderful humidor aroma.
Tight pack with a perfect draw with just enough resistance.
First light kinda harsh essence of a candle bring blown out but quickly transformed into a very dark leather, with a chewy woody finish.
Getting into the first third I'm picking up on a bitter bakers chocolate on the retrohale, followed by a very peppery long finish.
Going into the second third no changes in flavor. The bakers chocolate is completely gone now, taking over the dark leather, with a fiery pepper finish. It's burn is razor sharp and getting abit hot. Hard not to hit a cigar your not enjoying. I'm going to let it cool down a bit as I get into the last part.
Getting into the last third I had to touch it up just alittle, nothing major.
Wood has come back out, pepper is durn near at full strength but is going down easy with a root beer. I nubbed it. Very good smoke.

Not as peppery as I remember them being. But I'm gonna go out on a limb and say this was
The Baitfish.

I love them little vitola's

Thanks for the smokes, reviews to follow.
shaun341
11 years ago

I just finished Unknown #1 from Shaun.
By process of elimination, this would be his "dog rocket" entry.
Nice looking cigar. Possibly 5 1/2 x 50, with a slightly veiny dark brown wrapper.
Not much of a pre light aroma, but draw was easy.
No pepper or spice whatsoever throughout the entire smoke. Not much flavor or kick . . . just a mild uneventful smoke.
It wasn't a bad experience. The draw was real easy and there was a lot of smoke. Burn was perfect beginning to end, so
I wouldn't necessarily call it a dog rocket.

Wild guess . . . Genesis the Project ?

jespear wrote:




That was a La Herencia Cubano Oscuro Fuerte with about a year on it. I grab a 5er of these every year around the new years for under $10. That one was from last year so had a little time on it, they are a one dimensional wonder but for the price I like to keep a couple in the humi.

Hope I hit some new ones for you that you enjoyed Jespear and thanks for doing the reviews it was much fun comparing what you thought of the smokes to my notes.
reckless
11 years ago

GOF some of the best I've had.

Bugz is fired.

danmdevries wrote:


From the guy who hates anything with the slightest pepper LOL 🤦
danmdevries
11 years ago

From the guy who hates anything with the slightest pepper LOL 🤦

reckless wrote:



True story, but sometimes it's good... Has to be balanced, don't want my eyes watering.
reckless
11 years ago

True story, but sometimes it's good... Has to be balanced, don't want my eyes watering.

danmdevries wrote:


You're missing the best part =p~ But I retrohale faustos......
Hillbillyjosh770
11 years ago
Heading your way Shaun
9114901230801512534939
frozenphoenix1
11 years ago
Cigar #1 from mountainman is a 5.5 x 54 darker brown wrapped cigar. The seam is noticeable near the cap and looks like it endsl before the cap but a good feel in the hand for this one. V cut this one and the draw is nice and smooth with hints of barnyard and a bit of sweetness.

First draws have a hint of pepper with a sweet finish. A lot of good creamy smoke coming off this one. This one is in my wheelhouse and really enjoying it.

Got caught up in the blackhawks and predators game for half of this cigar. Phenomenal game with a great cigar, unfortunately forgot to take notes as i was afraid to look away.

This cigar being the mid range will be on my list to buy more if it is not already, as it feels really familiar. What was it? And I apologize for the underwhelming review on this one.

Thanks for the cigars mountainman. Looking forward to the MF limited edition and the partagas cc.
illinichaser
11 years ago

Great reviews guys, definitely gonna try a couple.

I got my package today from my good ole buddy, illinichaser.

All arrived unscathed.

It's been raining cats and dogs here. So I'm gonna jump in.

Included in the 5'er is a Viage TNT! And one of my fav's the Shark! You will pay dearly. Thanks Bro!

Number 1

You know me well.

Coming in as a hefty 4 x 45
Dark brown wrapper, minimal veins, tight visible seams. Toothy oily satin wrapper. Wonderful humidor aroma.
Tight pack with a perfect draw with just enough resistance.
First light kinda harsh essence of a candle bring blown out but quickly transformed into a very dark leather, with a chewy woody finish.
Getting into the first third I'm picking up on a bitter bakers chocolate on the retrohale, followed by a very peppery long finish.
Going into the second third no changes in flavor. The bakers chocolate is completely gone now, taking over the dark leather, with a fiery pepper finish. It's burn is razor sharp and getting abit hot. Hard not to hit a cigar your not enjoying. I'm going to let it cool down a bit as I get into the last part.
Getting into the last third I had to touch it up just alittle, nothing major.
Wood has come back out, pepper is durn near at full strength but is going down easy with a root beer. I nubbed it. Very good smoke.

Not as peppery as I remember them being. But I'm gonna go out on a limb and say this was
The Baitfish.

I love them little vitola's

Thanks for the smokes, reviews to follow.

Hillbillyjosh770 wrote:




Sorry, been traveling the last couple of days. You are correct, it was a baitfish. Nice review as well.
shaun341
11 years ago
Hillbilly got the package today and everything arrived great. Box smelled awesome when I opened it up. Going to give these a few days rest and then try and get to the reviews.
mountainman
11 years ago

Cigar #1 from mountainman is a 5.5 x 54 darker brown wrapped cigar. The seam is noticeable near the cap and looks like it endsl before the cap but a good feel in the hand for this one. V cut this one and the draw is nice and smooth with hints of barnyard and a bit of sweetness.

First draws have a hint of pepper with a sweet finish. A lot of good creamy smoke coming off this one. This one is in my wheelhouse and really enjoying it.

Got caught up in the blackhawks and predators game for half of this cigar. Phenomenal game with a great cigar, unfortunately forgot to take notes as i was afraid to look away.

This cigar being the mid range will be on my list to buy more if it is not already, as it feels really familiar. What was it? And I apologize for the underwhelming review on this one.

Thanks for the cigars mountainman. Looking forward to the MF limited edition and the partagas cc.

frozenphoenix1 wrote:



no worries about the review, I think the only flavors I remember from it was hints of coffee and dark chocolate mixed in from about the middle to the end, other wise it stays as described. this is one of those smokes I love and can see becoming a go to for myself as well. it is the Joya de Nicaragua Antaño Dark Corojo with about year on it.

enjoy your MF and Partagas. take your time with these guys, it is well worth that effort! if memory serves they are both from 2011 and they should treat you well my friend.
mountainman
11 years ago
I got to enjoy the last cigar in the blind test from dc, cigar #1. unfortunately my notes got erased from my phone and will have to do the review by memory.

it looked to be about 5'x56 and a nice chocolaty brown color. the seams were noticeable but nothing that bad and a good construction.

pre light it had the aroma of cedar and leather. I gave it a v cut and lit it up.

upon lighting the cigar had a slight pepperiness to it with that cedar and leather staying true. the smoke was nice and creamy, a pretty good cigar to say the least. the ash was a nice white, but didn't hold up much past an inch or so.

the cedar and leather stayed to the end with the cigar getting progressively creamier towards the end. it developed sweet notes and another flavor I would call nutmeg.

a great cigar that would surprise me if it was not a mid level or lower but will be taking a look at getting some for my humidor. it doesn't remind me of anything I have smoked before but a wild guess would be a gran Habano something.

thank you for the great cigars DC! that was one heck of a line up of smokes and I really enjoyed them all! I hope we get to do this again soon!

DCLover
11 years ago
Liga Privada #9
Sorry I threw you a curve, not really a yard gar in there.
chazbo
  • chazbo
  • Herf-A-Holic Topic Starter
11 years ago
^that DCLover can't follow the rules#-o
mountainman
11 years ago

Liga Privada #9
Sorry I threw you a curve, not really a yard gar in there.

DCLover wrote:



Wow, that's a surprise! I admittedly havent smoked one in a while, but I definitely remember it differently. Thank you for the great surprise and eye opener!
chazbo
  • chazbo
  • Herf-A-Holic Topic Starter
11 years ago
Finally got to relax on the back porch last night. So I grabbed a few DFH 90 minute brews and #3 cigar from bgz.
Size: 5.5 x 46
Wrapper med brn, smooth, firm with no soft spots.
Cut: straight
First inhale brought a nice spice to da tongue. As I thought about how this was a good thing, the next puff went straight to creamy leather notes. That spice was gone. The cigar had perfect draw with plenty of smoke. For the next hour I was in heaven. The cigar was as smooth as a babies butt. Ash held straight for over two inches before I knocked it off. Great burn. Just pass the half way point the flavors remained the same but it picked up in strength to med-full. This was a very good stick. If it had that spice I picked up on during that first hit at the end this would be a 10.
Thanks bgz🇨🇮
bgz
  • bgz
  • Herf-A-Holic
11 years ago

Finally got to relax on the back porch last night. So I grabbed a few DFH 90 minute brews and #3 cigar from bgz.
Size: 5.5 x 46
Wrapper med brn, smooth, firm with no soft spots.
Cut: straight
First inhale brought a nice spice to da tongue. As I thought about how this was a good thing, the next puff went straight to creamy leather notes. That spice was gone. The cigar had perfect draw with plenty of smoke. For the next hour I was in heaven. The cigar was as smooth as a babies butt. Ash held straight for over two inches before I knocked it off. Great burn. Just pass the half way point the flavors remained the same but it picked up in strength to med-full. This was a very good stick. If it had that spice I picked up on during that first hit at the end this would be a 10.
Thanks bgz🇨🇮

chazbo wrote:




Ahhh, you smoked the premium of the bunch. I went in the order you gave, because I figured it's just as good of order as any.

Anyway, it was a AF Opus X Angel's Share.

I figured you would like this one (it's kinda hard not to I guess).

🇨🇮
Users browsing this topic